Her pt2 - Mattheo Riddle x Theo Nott X fem! Reader
Summary: who will you agree to a second date with ?
Go to part 1 for this story <3
It only took a night for an owl to come. Y/n sat in the great hall eating her breakfast when a huge owl crashed on the table spilling everything around it. A goblet of tea fell onto her lap. She jumped up from the sudden temperature change
“Merlin’s beard!!” She huffed wiping her skirt with tissues. Hermione helping her
“Who’s bloody dumb bird is this?” Ron said taking the letter from its foot the bird screeched and flew away its big wings causing everyone’s hair to blow
“It’s for you” Ron handed you the paper you stared at it the owl put you In a sour mood and whoever sent it will get an earful from you.
“Let’s see who was smart enough to send in a bloody owl the size of a dog!” Y/n huffed peeling the green ribbon off it
Meet me at the astronomy tower doors before dinner
Bring a blanket or a jacket you choose :)
“Well?” Hermione asked looking over her friends shoulder
“Mattheo” y/n replied looking around for the boy smiling at him he winked at her with a piece of toast in his mouth
“Well we have class so let’s go before the traffic starts” Harry said laughing y/n pulled out a spare skirt out of her bag
“Can we stop by the toilets first I need to change”
Theo and Mattheo gave y/n subtle glances throughout the day which she responded with a smile her mood much better after changing.
During potions Mattheo sat next to y/n the trio looked at him but ignored him.
“Hey pretty girl” a kiss was placed on her cheek she gave a small smile and continued with her potion
“Sorry about the owl. He’s a bit dumb” Mattheo chuckled y/n gave the slytherin a really? You don’t say look laughing.
“Mr.Riddle I don’t think this is your table” professor snape raising an eyebrow. Mattheo smiled awkwardly before whispering
“See you in a few hours” and walked to his table. You can see Theo’s clutch on the silver rod tighten
“What am I gonna do?” Y/n sighed mione tried to comfort her friend
Dinner came by quickly. As you got dressed into something nice you faced Hermione spinning
“How do I look?” A big smile formed on your face
“Amazing as usual!” You linked arms as you left your common room
As you bid your goodbyes to your friends you made your way to the tower where Mattheo was already waiting for you. With a large bouquet of your favourite flowers in it.
“Hey” y/n said blushing. Mattheo pulled her into a hug her arms went over his shoulders and his went to her waist.
“You look so gorgeous” Mattheo whispered in her ear his lips pressed against her cheek
“Well you clean up rather nice your self” she remarked placing a kiss to his cheek
“Shall we?” Mattheo offered his arm which she gladly took as they ascended the stairs. Y/n was shocked to see the astronomy tower littered with lights and a table it was very sweet
“Oh wow you did all this ?!” You gasped looking at every detail Mattheo nodded proudly
“Of course I wanted it to be a great first date!” Mattheo pulled the chair out for you and tucked you in.
“A gentleman?!” You joked Mattheo chuckled before sitting himself opposite you
“For you” he smiled a big cheesy smile
“So what’s on the menu today?” Y/n asked looking at her surroundings
“Uh I’m not sure I told the house elves in the kitchen to surprise us for 10 galleons” as if on que the house elves arrived and placed the food in your table.
You both sat on the floor covered in soft pillows and watched the beauty of Hogwarts in comfortable silence
“I’ve really enjoyed our time together mattheo” y/n sighed her head leaning on his shoulder he hummed in agreement a hand snaked around her waist pulling he closer.
“Thank you for giving me a chance and if you don’t choose me I don’t mind as long as we stay friends” his voice was soft and you can tell he was tired
“Do you want to head to bed! Woah!” Mattheo practically tackled y/n to the ground holding her tight
“No I don’t want this night to enddddd!!” His grip tightened as he layed on top of her she laughed at his childishness
“Oh your laughing at me now ?!” The boy challenged y/n eyes widened as he started to tickle her.
“Mattheo no!!! I’m sorry!!” She pleaded in a fit of giggles mixed with Mattheos chuckles the bittersweet moment lasted only seconds before he stopped and stared at your face
“Wha-“ y/n was cut off with a pair of lips on hers. She froze not knowing what to do until she gave in and kissed him back her hands wrapping around his neck Mattheo hands raked her body as they made out. The two pulled away panting for air.
Mattheo walked y/n to her common room both very tired considering it was 1am.
“Thank you so much for such an amazing night. It’s been so fun” y/n pulled Mattheo into a big hug which he gladly returned.
“No, thank you for giving me a chance” y/n kissed Mattheo on his cheek before bidding him good night.
She entered the dorm she shared with Hermione and Ginny. They were both awake and y/n flopped on Miones' bed squealing
“Good night?” Hermione asked her friend laughing
“Tell us EVERYTHING!!” Ginny sang landing next to you. As you gave them a brief story about your date you sighed
“Girls I really don’t know what to do”
“Just sleep on it until you have to go out with Theo” Ginny suggested
“But what if I can’t choose?”
“Then date both” Ginny joked making Hermione laugh
The next morning y/n sat down once again for breakfast as she enjoyed her much-needed coffee. Theo sat next to her holding a bouquet of your favourite flowers and chocolates glued to it. Your smile was huge at the sweet gesture.
“Hey Theo!” Y/n said looking up at the boy who smiled warmly
“Hey y/n I wanted to ask if you wanted to go on a date with me today?” Theo said confidently as he handed you the flowers/sweets
“Of course I would love to”
“Brilliant meet me at the courtyard fountain in like 3 hours does that give you enough time?” Theo sweetly smiled
“More than enough I’ll be there!” Theo pecked y/n forehead before going off to his table
“Bloody hell” you hear Ron mumble Harry rolled his eyes
“Mioneee you have to help me get ready pleaseee!!!” Y/n begged hugging on to her friends arm
“You don’t even have to ask” the curly haired girl beamed as y/n grabbed her hand and they both ran out the great hall
You took a while to get ready making sure everything was perfect you looked at yourself in the mirror. It was weather appropriate but still amazing !
“You look so good!!!” Hermione said fixing your hair
You both headed down to the courtyard as some people were going to hogsmeade you see Theo waiting for you with his friends
“I’ll catch you guys later yeah?” Y/n waved goodbye to her friends and made her way to Theo. Draco was the first one to notice her he nudged Theo making him look to where he was nodding to.
“Hey y/n. Let’s go boys” Draco said dragging Mattheo with him Theo pulled you into a hug
“You look gorgeous as usual” Theo smiled twirling the girl around making her giggle
“Thank you Theo. You look handsome nothing new”
“So I was thinking we can go to London for the day instead of Hogsmeade I have permission from professor snape" Y/n's eyes lit up at the sound of going to her city.
"no way! I was waiting until the holidays to go and restock oh this is going to be so fun" she squealed hugging Theo. the boy laughed rubbing her back
"come on then before it gets too late" As they travelled via flu powder to London they found themselves at the Leaky Cauldron. theo placed a protective hand on the small of her back leading them out to the street.
theo watched as y/n went in and out of shops a smile never leaving her face
"hey Theo what do you think about this smell?" y/n presented her wrist to theos nose he wrapped a large hand around it and inhaled the perfume humming in satisfaction
"this one is much better than the other one" he put it in the basket that he was holding for her
as the pair shopped longer Theo noticed a group of guys staring at y/n and whispering to each other. theo went up behind her and wrapped both arms around her making her jump
"oh, Theo you scared me! is everything alright? I'm sorry I'm taking ages" she apologised leaning into him.
"Don't apologies princess take your time" he smiled against her neck the group of boys long gone now.
y/n showed Theo the best places she liked to go considering she was born and grew up in this city. They somehow ended up outside y/n old house, the place she grew up in the place her mother was found dead.
"I'm sorry I brought us here. I just always visit it when I'm around" she sniffled leaning into Theo
"Never apologise for that it's absolutely fine" A small sincere smile was set on his face
"I don't want to rush you but we should head back to the leaky cauldron soon. professor snape gave me a time limit" he whispered into her hair. She nodded in response pulling away.
they headed back to Hogwarts. it was almost curfew when they arrived outside her common room.
"Theo?" y/n asks looking up at the boy
"what if i can't choose? like you guys are best friends and I don't want you to fall out over me" She began to get teary-eyed, making Theo's gaze soften as he pulls her in for a hug
"hey don't worry about us, and don't rush into a decision if your not sure yet just take your time. we will both be here for you." he rubbed her back she gripped his shirt tighter
"i like both of you and it's hard" she wiped a stray tear away she lookd up at Theo all doe eyed before grabbing him by the collar and pulling him in for a kiss which Theo gladly returned placing a firm hand on the back of your neck and another on your waist squeezing the area. Theo slipped a tongue in your mouth making you moan softly he smirked against your lips and got hungrier by the second wanting more of you. Theo pulled away from the kiss and started nipping at your neck your sweet noises make him let out a groan. Before pulling a way making you whine.
“Love. We can’t not yet. As much as I would love to” his forehead rested on yours as you caught your breath
“Get some sleep angel. I’ll see you in the morning” he placed kiss to your lips before bidding goodnight.
As you blindly entered the dorm room your vision too clouded by your own mind Hermione stepped in front of you
“Wow your flustered” she smirked helping you sit down
“How was it?” She gave her friend a supportive pat on the back as she laid her head on her shoulder
“It was nice. But I think I’m gonna sleep. Night mione” sleep overtook y/n within minutes
The next morning came and y/n was more then ready to see him. She went to the great hall and gestured for him to follow her.
“Hey gorgeous. How are you ?” Mattheo winked shoving his hands in his pockets
“Mattheo I uh. I choose you” you whispered mattheos slit eyebrow cocked up
“Sorry sweetheart couldn’t hear you could you maybe speak up?” He got closer to you knowing full well what you said
“I choose you. I want to be with you” you said a but too loud. Mattheo smile grew as he lifted you off the ground spinning you
“Oh love you don’t know how happy I am right now” he pulled you into kiss keeping you in his grip as tight as he could. You wrapped your arms around his neck and tugged at his hair making him grunt
“Don’t be doing that princess. Not here anyway” he whispered In your ear making you blush HARD.
“And don’t worry about Theo we had a conversation after your date with him and agreed no matter who you chose we will be happy for each other and not get in the way of the other one’s relationship” he pecked your lips tenderly and a bunch of wolf whistles were heard behind you. You span around to see your friends cheering you on. You hid in Mattheo chest making him chuckle
You made your to the great hall a big smile plastered on your face as you looked around for him. Finding him at his usual table in his usual spot you went over and sat down next to him.
“Good morning ange-“ Theo was cut off with your lips on his he smiled and pulled you in closer
“Alright you two it’s too early for that” Blaise says chucking a piece of toast your way Theo gave him the middle finger as he kissed you one more time.
“So does this mean?” Theo questioned looking down at you. You nodded and smiled shyly as he pulled you into his side
“Mattheo and I spoke yesterday so don’t worry about anything ok. We are good” Theo whispered in your ear
“But will you do the honours and be mine?” Y/n nodded pulling the boy into a big hug
