In your opinion, what was each character’s best season? (Both TO and TVD characters)
This is so hard but I tried to do everyone I could think of:
Elijah Mikaelson - Season 2 of TVD and Season 2 of TO
It is a truth universally acknowledged, Elijah will own a Season 2. His entrance in TVD Season 2 was fantastic. I loved his mysterious vibe and was honestly more scared of his entry than Klaus. It's also when we learned about The Originals lore. It was just a great season, in large art due to Elijah. But TO Season 2 was also great. I loved seeing Elijah seem to have a life outside of Klaus. He bonded with Marcel, helped build a community with the vampires. His relationship with Gia was so great. We get some of his backstory through the red door. And he just looked great all season. Although I adore Season 1 TO Elijah and the softness we see in him, really for the first time, I needed him to stop obsessing over Klaus. He should have left with Rebekah.
Hayley Marshall - Season 3 TO
To me, Season 3 TO is really where Hayley finds herself. I love Season 1 Hayley because she was less jaded, but I had issues with some of her "girl boss" moments. Much like is Season 2, where she is still trying to find her place in the supernatural world. But Season 3, she really discovers who she is and what she wants to fight for. We see her start to set boundaries and stand up for herself. She becomes the leader that she was trying to be in the previous seasons. I also love moments we get in Season 4 and 5, but it was so rushed her development got lost in the chaos.
Stefan Salvatore - Season 3 TVD
I'm such a sucker for this storylines. The lengths Stefan goes to try and betray Klaus and fight the compulsion. We get to see a completely different version of Stefan with his humanity off. We get his backstory with Klaus. We watch him claw his way back to his humanity. This season really focused on Stefan and his struggles.
Damon Salvator - Season 1 or 6 TVD
Damon was a better character when he was just evil. We got his lore. We felt slightly bad for him. But at the end of the day, he was the evil vampire killing, SAing, destroying Mystic Falls. And he was good at it. But if we want to say best season, as in when he was at his best, it has to be Season 6 when he's stuck in the prison world with Bonnie. I've said it before, Damon was only ever able to be good when he was removed from any complications. He improved slightly with Bonnie's influence.
Klaus Mikaelson - Season 3 TVD or Season 3 TO
Unpopular opinion, but Klaus stayed on TVD far too long. Season 3 was great. He entered the show, terrorizing the town in Season 2, but we really got to see him thrive as the villain in Season 3 TVD. But then after that, it just felt odd for a incredibly powerful, thousand year old vampire to be hanging out with high schoolers in a small town. But Season 3, he had purpose and was comical achieving it. Season 3 of TO was the first time we really saw character development for Klaus. He realizes that he has caused a lot of problems for his family and seeks to change his ways. He sets his pride aside and is willing to sacrifice himself multiple times for family.
Rebekah Mikaelson - TO Season 1
I never minded the character shift between TVD and TO with Rebekah. I thought she was amusing in TVD, but ultimately wasn't a favorite of mine. But in TO Season 1, I loved that she was ready to fight for herself. Instead of just being the insecure, codependent sister, Rebekah is allowed to be devious and intelligent all in her own right. I think a later season would have topped this if Rebekah had been in the show more. I wanted to see this character growth continue, but we only got bits and pieces through TO.
Elena Gilbert - TVD Season 2
Elena for most of Season 1 was playing catch up, learning what everything was and who all the players were. But in Season 2, she is more settled and ready to fight back. I love the strength we see in her, but most of all, I love how she held onto her compassion. She was willing to sacrifice herself for her friends and family, but she did so wisely, making deals with the enemies to keep them safe. It was peek Elena, which we don't really get to see again after Season 2.
Bonnie Bennett - TVD Season 4
I love Season 2 Bonnie coming into her powers and going up against Katherine and The Originals, but she still very much felt like she was just acting in Elena's story. Season 4, to me, felt like she had her own storylines that were just as vital to the plot. We get to see more of her family dynamic. Bonnie is allowed to struggle and grow as a witch. They had to bring in Qetsiyah and Silas because she was growing so powerful. I also adore the early seasons of Bonnie, watching her learn her magic.
Cami O'Connell - TO Season 3
Season 3 was peak Cami. She was learning how to fill her uncle's foot steps by protecting the humans from the supernatural with Vincent's help. I even loved Cami's vampire era and wished it had lasted longer. Cami was constantly fighting for those around her, but Season 3 really gave her the ability to do it. She didn't let her fear hold her back until it literally killed her. And even after that, she clawed her way back to her humanity and died just as compassionate as she ever was.
Katherine Pierce - TVD Season 2
This should go without saying. TVD Season 2 was Katherine's best season. And like Klaus, she should have left the show earlier than she did. Her hanging around high schoolers, trying to make a man love her, really lessened her intimidation factor. Although I did enjoy her human era later on. But Season 2 was great. Her entrance was iconic (although I think that was technically the end of season 1). She had a goal and it made sense for her character based on survival.
Caroline Forbes - TVD Season 3
Season 3 for Caroline is where she finds herself. I love her in Season 2 when she is finding her strength, but her insecurities often get in her way. While in Season 3, we get to see her intelligence on top of it all. I also think Forwood was such a good character shift for Caroline. She had matured enough to help him through his own journey of the supernatural world. I wasn't a fan of them maturing her so much in the later seasons.
Marcel Gerard - TO Season 2
Season 1 Marcel was a little too much like Klaus for me. But Season 2, really found their mark with him. He didn't just want the city for power, but truly to build community. We got to see him as a leader and he was great at it. I liked him in the later seasons as well, but I liked in Season 2 that he wasn't a Mikaelson. He was better than them. It was his best season.
I liked Davina in Season 1, but Season 2 she was able to be more than just a Harvest Girl. She had her own motivations and goals outside of Marcel. And she was determined when it came to destroying the Mikaelsons. It really showed how powerful she was. I feel like a lot of her character gets a little lost in the later seasons as it tended to center around Kol and she lost her own identity a bit in that.
Bonenzo is how I survived Season 8. His love for Bonnie was so great that he was able to fight against Sybil's mind control. I also love how we see his character growth really emphasized here. We see him grow a lot as a character in Season 6 and 7, but season 8 is where it all comes together. He is no longer anchored by his revenge or hatred, but his love. He is the best version of himself in season 8 and I loved it.
This is clearly not everyone, so let me know if there is anyone in particular you want me to talk about!