Okay, apology time here my friends. This is going to be ranty and rambling. No, I’m not angry or anything and I’m not going to be calling anyone out with this. I am very tired, however, and that’s why it may get rambly.
Something that tends to really get on my nerves is this seemingly over emphasis on selectiveness with RPers. No, wait, let me change that a bit. Not so much over emphasis, but the way it’s done often.
How do I mean? Well, there are two main things you tend to see in this case. The first is “I will only RP with mutuals” and the second is “I’ll only work with canon character blogs.”
The later one is extremely frustrating when you come across it, especially if one of the reasons why you don’t run a canon blog is that you don’t feel any kind of a connection to the canon characters or you don’t feel confident enough to play one. There are a lot of times when it’s far easier to roleplay something of your own creation then something established (much less pressure for one thing).
Not only that, but it often times just comes across as OC hate. Yeah, I’m sure that’s never the intent a good 99% of the time, but there’s that feeling. Especially when you see things going on about how OCs are horrible and nothing but shitty Mary Sues/Garry Stus.
This can cause a lot of people to not even try, dull their creativity and do nothing but carbon cut-outs of canon characters over and over and over again. Yeah, I know, you’re going to come across more than a few “Well I’m the son/daughter/missing relative/secret lover of so and so canon character(s) and yeah, those can be insanely annoying to deal with, but not all them are bad.
Now, I can understand (somewhat) why you may chose to go that route. A want to keep it “pure”, only having a trust of people who do canon character blogs because they aren’t Mary Sue-ish (which makes me laugh), and a number of reasons.
The mutual one is a bit trickier. I very easily understand why people choose that route. Trust, a want to keep their RP group small and manageable, showing that “hey, you’re awesome and I want to do something with you as much as you want to do something with me.”
This can cause a lot of frustration. I know, I’ve had that frustration. I’ve seen blogs that I really would like to RP with but can’t because of that selectiveness. That bitterness that builds up in you isn’t easy to deal with. It can also cause some major depression too. “Why am I not good enough?” “What makes person A better than me?” “Oh, you’ll work with that shitty OC but not me? Well up yours too.”
I’ve had those thoughts. It’s never pleasant at all. Yet at the same time, there’s got to be an understanding to why they may be like that. Incidents in the past that have shaped how they RP and how they choose who to RP with may be involved.
That being said, I still do think there should be at least a little bit of flexibility given. Especially if it’s a new blog just starting up. Not only that, but even it’s an RP’er who at one point was crap, they should get a second chance. I can easily think of one blog who qualifies for that description. We’re talking as god-modding as you can get here. Now they are a pretty decent roleplayer.
I’m not going to lie. I’m selective as fucking hell myself. I may not fall under the “only RP with mutuals” or “only will work with a canon blog” categories, but own criteria can be extremely off putting as well. I’m sorry if it bugs you, I really am.
On the flipside of things. For those of us on the outside looking in? Those who see a clique and are “Why can’t I have that?” We have to be understanding. For the sake of everyone, don’t go all high and mighty and start a bitchfest with someone if they say “no” when you try to RP with them. It doesn’t better your chances and just make you look like an ass to others, making them less likely to want to do anything with you as well.
I’m sorry if I’m stepping on toes with this. It’s something that’s kinda been on my mind for a while now. Easily a couple weeks at least and I think it may have had a part in my own quick depression and foul mood (well that and some RL stuff that brought about an insane amount of frustration) and it was something I saw on the dash that finally prompted me to speak up.
I guess it’s just that I can see both sides of this thing. I know full well why some aren’t mutuals with me. Blog is highly NSFW for one, despite having canon characters around it’s headlined by a mary sue-ish OC, and I’m a shitty roleplayer.
Oh, that brings something else to mind. If you’re going on a bitchfest to someone who said they don’t wish to RP with you, don’t bring up how many years you’ve been RPing. That really doesn’t mean a whole lot. I’ve seen people who’ve been RPing for over ten years who are still shit (hell, I’ve been doing so for about that long myself and I’m still shit with it) and I’ve seen those who’ve maybe been at it for a few months who are insanely amazing at it. All you’ve done is shown yourself to be a condescending asshole.