| Maybe We Would Go Together like Fall and Football |
I wrote this short essay in direct response after seeing @terencenance‘s An Oversimplification of Her Beauty in 2013. The movie was truly inspirational and I left the theater with so many thoughts. I sat down and this story just poured out. I was too nervous to post it then, as it’s autobiographical, but I’ve decided, why not? The love interest’s name has been changed to protect the innocent. I hope you enjoy and maybe get something out of it.
| Maybe We Would Go Together like Fall and Football |
His name was Glenn. I met him in college. We worked together. We spent long hours side by side, getting to know each other by the way we handled situations. We laughed. I made him laugh more than he made me laugh, and I liked that. I liked that I could make him laugh. You see, he was a biochem major, and I a creative writing major, so the fact I could get him to laugh made me feel smart. We spent long hours side by side, getting to know each other by the way we handled situations.
We were promoted to managers at the same time. We worked at the gym on campus. We dominated the scene. We walked around on our respective shifts, chatting with the associates, making sure only students were let in, breaking up fights on the basketball courts, telling meatheads to keep the grunting down in the weight room. We held the highest position a student could have.
Even though we were both managers, we sometimes, well, a lot of times, worked together. This was purposed. I would be his assistant manager or he'd be mine. I would take orders from him, "Hey, could you go give Danny a break? He's been here since noon," or "Melissa, please help Megan set up the volleyball nets." It was easy to do what he asked. I wanted to do what he asked.
There was something different about Glenn. Something different from any boy I'd liked before him. It wasn't his looks, he was white with glasses and blondish brown hair. I had liked white guys before. I went to a school in the suburbs and that was pretty much all I'd seen. I particularly remember liking this one guy in high school; he liked golf and wore a Tiger Woods hat every day he could. I started watching golf so I could have something to talk about with him. "Did you see Tiger? He was hitting birdies left and right," or "Sergio Garcia's no match. He wishes he could be as good as Tiger." I also thought I liked another white guy in high school, but it turns out I only "liked" him because everyone else did. He was the typical boy people were drawn to, with dark hair, an easy smile, big eyes, a sense of adventure. All my friends were crazy about him, and I thought I should be too. In retrospect, I've realized those weren't real feelings for him, but more so a need to fit in.
But with Glenn, it was more than his looks. Or maybe in spite of his looks. He was quiet, introverted, kinda melted into the background. He was everything I wasn't. And I liked that. I subconsciously challenged myself to bring him out of his shell. I would ask questions like, "What'd you do this weekend," or "Are you going to the football game on Saturday?" Mundane questions, really. I didn't want to scare him off with silly whimsical wonderings. I learned what he liked to do, what things made him uncomfortable, what music he listened to. We were becoming friends. I'd make observations about the students coming into the gym or tell him some ridiculous writing idea someone came up with in class. He would listen, he cared enough to listen.
Work parties were a thing of the norm. We were college kids, we worked at a gym, people liked to show off and get drunk. Glenn and I didn't get drunk, though. But Glenn never really came to parties anyway. I went for social interaction, for the dancing, for the amusing conversations with my intoxicated peers. Eventually I got Glenn to come to a party. "The guys from work are going to be there. You don't have any plans tonight anyway, and you can sleep in." I remember dressing in a way to get a guy's attention. My jeans were form fitting, my shirt more revealing than the work uniform I donned almost every day. I was more flirtatious in this social setting. My eyes lingered longer than usual on his eyes. I threw my head back in laughter at his jokes, sometimes laughing a bit longer than warranted, touching his arm all the while. I wanted him to know I liked him, as more than just a friend, that I wanted something more. I didn't want to tell him, though. I didn't want to flat out tell him. I thought my clues were enough for him to pick up on.
This was not the case. Glenn and I continued to be friends, I continued to make him laugh, he continued to come to some parties, and we continued to spend long hours together, working side by side. He didn't pick up on my clues, he hadn't honed in on my hints. He never made a move or asked me out on a date. I thought this was because he was shy, right?
I know I'm a fun girl. I know how to get out there and engage people and get to know them. That's not hard for me. I'm not shy about asking someone to go to a movie with me. "Hey, Glenn, Wedding Crashers is coming out on Friday. Let's go see it." This was harmless enough, this was friendship. Of course we each paid for our own ticket. He thought we were being friends and I got to spend time with him. We would go see movies like that occasionally, when I wasn't chillin out, maxin, relaxin all cool. I was doing everything I knew to get him to know I liked him, without exactly telling him I liked him. I remember one night he picked me up on our way to a movie and I had just put lotion on. It was a generous portion, I can't be ashy around my crush. When I got in the car, he said, "Your lotion smells like formaldehyde." I was mor-ti-fied. Formaldehyde??? Come on, St. Ives, you over here sending me off. He didn't say this in a seductive way, as if the smell of formaldehyde were sexy to him. He said it disgustedly, and there was nothing I could do about it. Everything in me wished a sink would appear and I could quickly wash off any and all offending lotion smells with the soap of his choice. Maybe he liked a rain scent, or lemon, or green apple. I'd douse myself in Chanel No. 5 if it would please him. Anything to rid the car of the smell of formaldehyde. How would he ever like me now? He would forever associate me with formaldehyde, with dead worms and pigs, with lifeless frogs assigned to be dissected in order to pass biology.
Has anyone heard of Flogging Molly? I certainly had not until Glenn mentioned he listened to them. I never brought myself to listen to them, but maybe Glenn wanted to know about some of the music I enjoyed. I told him about the singer Kem, and I lent him Kem's Album II CD. "This is baby making music," Glenn said as he gave me his feedback. I'd never realized that until he said it. I was embarrassed when he told me this, as if he had caught me at my game. I listened to it as jazz, not necessarily as sexual or erotic. I loved Kem's voice and his style, but maybe since I wasn't attracted to him that way, I didn't interpret his music as such. But subconsciously I must've picked up on the sensuality, and thus passed my CD on to Glenn. Maybe I was trying to seduce Glenn into liking the same music I liked, and therefore he would like me in return. If Kem's smooth voice couldn't convince Glenn to like me, what could?
Thankfully Glenn's attitude toward me didn't negatively change after my "seduction" faux pas, but unfortunately, it didn't change for the better, either. Our friendship went along stagnant for the next several months, we worked side by side, but I didn't discover anything new about him. He didn't volunteer any information about his life and I was tired of asking questions. Weren't we friends? Why didn't he want to share his life's tidbits with me? Why did I always have to ask him about his class workload or what he did over spring break?
I was growing to resent Glenn. I thought we had something special...not that he liked me more than a friend, but that he talked to me more than anyone else at work and we shared more laughs and secret smiles; I thought he should want to be around me more outside of work. I thought we had fun together. But he never asked to hang out with me, I asked him. He never reciprocated. But I didn't want to be resentful of Glenn. He was a smart and funny, and he cared about work and school. He was a stand-up guy, and I wanted to be more than his friend.
So I finally decided to step out and put myself out there. What did I have to lose...except everything? If he rejected me, I would have to work with him every day and try not to act weird around him. Could we go back to being just friends? Could I just ask him to see a movie with me on a random night without him being leery of my motives? Would I want to be around him after he just told me he didn't want to be with me?
After I weighed all this, I just decided to do it. I couldn't see him every day and never tell him how I felt. Maybe he secretly felt the same way I did? Maybe we could be this odd couple: me loud and boisterous and him quiet and reserved. Maybe we would go together like fall and football.
One day, when Glenn was leaving work and walking down the long hallway to the door, I followed him out. I pretended I needed to ask him a question about work. "Are you working tomorrow cause I'm going to be a little late coming from my class." Once that little exchange was over and we were in the stairwell just in front of the door, I had to stop him from leaving. "Hey, Glenn, wait." I told him I liked him and I told him he was cute and I liked when we hung out and I told him he was funny and I told him I liked that he was quiet and I hoped I wasn't too loud and in his face and I told him I wanted to see if this could work and I told him I wanted to be more than friends and I told him until I couldn't tell him anymore. I said all of these things in my head, but I realized I only said "I like you and do you think you could like me? As more than friends?" He looked at me, he searched my face with his big blue eyes and he looked down for a bit. I knew this was a mistake. I had my answer; he didn't even need to say anything. But nonetheless, he said, "I like you as a friend, Melissa."
I'm not sure what I was expecting to happen. I certainly wasn't expecting to be crushed as much as I was. I didn't realize how much I liked him until this exact moment right now when he turned me down. I was deflated. I wanted a romantic comedy ending where he would look me lovingly in the eyes and tell me he of course wanted to spend every waking moment with me. But instead, he let me down gently, and I was devastated.
I took a chance, a chance I vowed never to take again. I never wanted to put myself out there again, to be vulnerable and initiate the start of a romantic relationship. I learned then that a gambler I wasn’t. I couldn’t handle it, and the reward was definitely not worth the risk.
Years later, I think back on this experience with some fondness. Thinking about the friendship I had formed out of nothing, I value those times we spent together. But a part of me wishes I would have left it the way it was, left the easiness we shared. We still worked together after my detrimental decision to put myself out there, but it wasn’t the same. It was never the same. I wish I would’ve stayed his friend so I could crack his code. But it was too late, I couldn’t turn back the clock. The deed was done and I would never talk to Glenn the way I had before. Maybe expanding myself wasn’t the way to go. I’ll never know. But I do know that ten years later, I haven’t put myself out there like that since. Maybe this is a mistake.