I like how itâs universally accepted that Game of Thrones was trash after they ran out of book material. Like in the SDCC Amazon panel, the interviewer telling Wheel of Time showrunner Rafe Judkins - âEveryone knows what happened with GOT after they ran out of the books, but you donât have that problemâ. And there being no pushback from Judkins on this who simply explains that they have a different problem - fitting 14 huge books into 8 seasons.
And just after listening to Benioff and Weiss interviews, everything Rafe Judkins says about their adaptation - like having both book fans and non book readers in the writerâs room to balance things out, having a diverse writerâs room including a female co-writer, that he likes being challenged on his writing etc. - makes me hopeful about the TV show.
I am not a purist - I donât need the show to 100% follow the books. Thatâs just not possible - the world of the books is just too expansive for that to happen. Just tell a good story, be true to the characters - donât use them as plot devices, stick to the overarching theme of the story, keep the fantasy elements in - the magic system is what makes these books great, let these characters go on their adventures and have fun. Ex. The Expanse - an adaptation that is actually better than the books IMO - though that is science fiction, the book writers are heavily involved with the show, and the world is less complex than WOT.
I came across an old interview of Robert Jordan on one of the WOT forums and what he says about fantasy is why I love the genre:
In the real world we have a great deal of uncertainty, a great deal of danger and very little certainty of where we are going, how we are going to get there, what the end result is going to be. In fantasy, you face a great deal of danger, a great deal of uncertainty, but you have one particular certainty when you get into fantasy. You know that evil is not going to win the final victory. There will be victories by evil along the way, people you like, people you love may die but in the end good will win out. And that I believe is becoming more important to people - to have that certainty. - Robert Jordan
We donât need any of that dark, nihilistic âIf you think this has a happy endingâ garbage that GOT served up to subvert expectations because happy characters are boring or some such edgy take on all this.
WOT is just old time Good Vs evil fantasy fare and I hope Rafe Judkins embraces that and incorporates that into his TV adaptation.