listen ive only just seen suicide squad so im very late to the bandwagon but heres some thoughts:
it is INEXCUSABLY terrible, as in there is no excuse for a bunch of professionals getting together and somehow producing this godless mistake. it seriously feels like i should be able to swat will smith with a rolled up newspaper over this movie
even knowing what i now know about what happened with the final edit of the film, i dont even think that good editing would have saved it. im reasonably certain that even the original cut of the film was a worthless sack of shit, so mostly the fucking RANDOM editing is just really funny. like it quickly changes time of day and location so incomprehensibly that you can never tell where the movie is taking place or how much time has passed, which is just BASIC movie continuity that they couldnt keep up. i kept catching myself seeing the sky go from nigh to day over and over and i realize thats an editing mistake but it is an EGREGIOUS editing mistake
the entire “suicide squad” plan and execution is so laughably bad that it is not even REASONABLY within the scope of superhero movie badness. it is not even believable that an actual fucking dipshit would even come up with this plan, because even a dipshit would be like, “hey, this seems like a bad idea?” it is so bad, and poorly thought out, and a stretch that a human adult would come up with it, that i GENUINELY that that the “mean woman” in the red coat who orchestrated it was working for the joker. it was SO UNFATHOMABLY BAD A PLAN that i literally thought it was just a way to bust all the villains out and get another movie. but no apparently it was legitimate and people in the government in gotham, real adult humans, thought this was okay. alright. sure. no wonder gotham needs batman, it is apparently run by a bunch of absolute fucking neanderthals
i mean the continuity errors were so painfully egregious, i just,,,,it was so bad. it was so bad, you guys !
the joker was terrible. i mean i dont think i need to say anything that hasnt already been said. on top of Not Being The Joker, he just wasn’t even scary or edgy like he was trying to be. there are cartoon iterations of the joker that are scarier and have more personality than this fuckign. abomination. like ive seen some rly good, spooky jokers with a lot of charm and a lot of scares and this was Not That
i spent half the movie wondering ‘why isn’t the joker in this movie?” even when the joker was on screen doing things
none of the characters make sense. they spend about a third of the movie with this incredibly slow, unnecessary series of introductions for them that go on for WAY too long (like, seriously, things in this “”Action Movie””” do not even begin to actually Happen until its almost over) and then do not have them do or say anything aligned with their characters at all. so by the end you dont know their names outside of deadshot and harley quinn, and killer croc i guess, who does absolutely nothing in the entire movie. no, seriously. he doesnt do anything. they have a crocodile man in an action movie who eats people and he doesnt do anything. hes barely in the background in some shots. he doesnt eat anyone, and probably has 3 total lines of dialogue. thats that
wanting to fuck a pink unicorn isnt even edgy any more, snyder, you pile of cocaine with a rat face attached to it. thats tame. get better material. you arent funny.
they had opportunities for the movie to be funny and somehow missed them completely, like. all possible comedy beats were missed, so the movie wasn’t funny Or charming OR even suitably violent to be enjoyable
oh yeah why is this movie rated pg-13. if were gonna spend an hour and a half with a bunch of serial killers and its NOT gonna be cartoony and funny, how the hell ?? are you going to pass them off as a credible threat when they cant kill anyone, be violent, or say fuck ???? as a result the fucking Hardened Criminals never actually do any Bad Things, we’re just expected to KNOW theyre badass bc they have cool music playing over them not doing anything. like, ok. sure.
like for an action movie, there is no action. for a comedy, there is no comedy. all laughs derived from the movie were from me screaming at it so loudly that my voice gave out and i collapsed, ready to die
im not a huge fan of marvel OR DC, but I feel like they really fucked DC fans here. like, seriously. im not even super familiar with the DC characters and the entire movie I was like They Wouldnt Do That. even if you love the characters you will walk away disappointed bc they fuck that up So Bad
the bad guys dont do bad guy things, which was entirely what we were all here to see them do.
you can tell the entire plot of the movie after the first like 15 minutes. enchantress is bad, underdeveloped side characters to fake some kind of emotional investment, etc etc. blah i dont even remember their names and they were the entire emotional crutch for the whole movie. enchantress was horrifically flaccid as a villain
im serious when i say that bad editing was not the death of this movie. people who say “oh its the editing” are wrong. the editing is a fucking nightmare, yeah, but the movie has NO redeemable qualities. what so ever. at most, fixing the editing might raise it from absolutely horrible to disappointingly mediocre, but is that really the standard we wanna set?
batman is in the movie for .5 seconds and he immediately does something batman would never do
why does deadshot not act like deadshot
why does harley quinn not act like harley quinn (also, why cant the actress playing her pull of her voice quirks/accent at all? sometimes she sounds southern, sometimes the accent is absent completely, like,,was nobody gonna be like, “hey lady, maybe we should do, i dunno, one more fucking take, and u could say it RIGHT this time”??)
my roommate called the joker “sex voldemort” which is apt. thats basically what youre in for with this joker. sex voldemort.
anyway it was a godless atrocity and im glad its in the past. i had honestly even held out hope that the point of the movie would be that the suicide squad plan, being so bad, would blow up in everyones faces and unleash hell onto the streets of gotham because that might be, i dunno, fun or interesting, but at the end they all go back to prison and dont even get to wreak mass havoc at all
its a movie where nothing happens. you dont know whats going on, the characters are all wrong and poorly written. like. its an action movie and theres barely even any action at all
it fails on EVERY LEVEL. theres not a single part of it that i would pick out and be like “this is okay.” every single thing about it fails, even the shit that LOOKs like it might have potential at first, bc all of the ideas are bad. its just a bad idea movie from the ground up. it progresses more like bad crack fic than a film made by real adult humans. 2/10, would recommend if you like to scream angrily for hours
tl;dr: go see lego batman it looks so much better im serious i dont even care that much abt batman and i am so fucking hype for lego batman please watch the trailer if you havent seen it already it looks so good