As someone who has only seen the first 5 seasons of Supernatural, I’m calling out to the community to recommend some of your guys’ favorite Supernatural fics in ao3. The reason as to why I’m asking strangers for their recommendations is because i can’t find anything I want to read since I’m not exactly sure what’s canonical and what’s not when it comes to the later seasons.
I do have some preferences when it comes to fics, though, and i will list them out. I am pretty flexible about those preferences if the story is intriguing enough, but there are some lines I won’t cross.
My preferences are the following:
NO INCEST (non negotiable, i won’t read anything involving incest)
Sam Winchester focus or both brothers (they have to have a good relationship and get along with each other)
If there is a ship, preferably Sam/Jess or Dean/Cas
I like when Bobby, Jim, Caleb, Ellen, Missouri, etc. appear and treat the brothers as they should
It has to be somewhat long (around 200k words)
It has to be completed (no hiatus or incomplete works)
Not a big focus on the angels or the demons (i want it to evoke the early season’s vibes with monster hunting)
Psychic Sam is one of my favorite tags, but it’s not strictly necessary
I don’t care much about smut (if the story contains it i usually just skip over it)
I also enjoy Stanford era stories
I’m a sucker for angst and hurt comfort, but they also have to contain a bit of fluff to make everything better
Not really into the omegaverse thing
I’m not sure how i feel about crossovers (if it makes sense i can always give it a try)
The writing has to make sense to the characters as they are, i don’t want to read the brothers acting strange or talking in a way they wouldn’t canonically
I would really appreciate anything you guys send in, if it has something I didn’t mention or anything really, send it in and i can decide for myself if i want to read it or not










