here's a review about the character depiction in the Gk live action movies and series that no one asked for, by my absolutely not film critic ass. I'd be happy to read other people's minds about that subject. it contains spoilers. also I'll comment on physical appearance which I normally avoid to do. all of this is perfectly subjective of course
characters that I liked more in the live action than in the manga or anime:
usami. he looks really good. Personnally i like his design more in the live action. curious to see how the acting will go when he'll show his darker sides. quite funnily he's one of the characters I liked the least in the manga but maybe the films will make me like him heheh.
koito. What the hell are these eyebrows even about. Not sure about the physical resemblance, but the goofiness is on point, maybe better than in the manga/anime. I see Koito coming running graciously into a scene and I know I'll be delighted.
shiraishi. while I find asirpa and sugimoto a bit bland .. shiraishi brings life and fun in the group and he genuinely made me laugh almost everytime he was on screen.
kantaro. it's the kind of character I didn't pay much attention to in the manga and anime. but he's cute in here haha
nikaidou. straight crazy drug addict boi 😭
characters that I liked/found accurate in their acting :
tsurumi. seductive and charismatic. maybe he's less scary than in the manga and anime though ?
tsukishima. serious in all situations. and yet you can see some of the emotions going inside :-)
inkarmat. smart and beautiful queen.
hijikata. good ol hijikata.
ushiyama. although not 100% looking like the manga , I liked the acting and embodiment of that character.
in-between:
tanigaki. he looks much older than the tanigaki I remembered ^^
ogata. this person looks beautiful omfg. they even accompany his apparitions with a little badass music to make him look cool. but maybe he lacks the weirdness and the void-ish eyes of the original ogaga ? I'd say he's not disturbing enough. like I can't imagine him smiling weirdly when he confuses yuusaku with sugimoto in that "let's-protect-yuusaku's-virginity" mission.
kadokura. I think his laziness/jadedness does not appear enough as well as his physical crookedness... or his small relaxed tummy 😌
didn't find accurate:
sugimoto. he looks too young and his face does not remind me of sugimoto imo. also he lacks a fun dimension, most of the time he looks serious and as if he's containing himself.
Asirpa. she seems much older than in the original story. although I can imagine why they chose someone older for the role. also lacks some fun, although less than sugimoto.
idk what to think :
Ienaga. wouldn't it have been better if she was acted by a non cis person ? i wonder what Queer/trans people think about that. on pure acting the actress did a cool job i think.
I know there have been critics about the quasi absence of ainu actors in the cast...it must feel weird to have representation of your people by the people who colonised you... right? I read here and there that there were not that much ainu actors around. if that's true would there have been ways to involve more ainu people ? I wonder how it could have been otherwise.
also this show is weird cause it switches from homo romantic/erotic to homophobic vibes ? am I the only one who feels that ? ^^
and about the sea otter scene. it was fun but at the same time the guys looked/sounded a little bit creepy right before deciding to get to that sumo wrestling 😅 and that creepy vibe was not there in the manga imo
also WHY DID THAT OLD MAN DROP THE OTTER IN THE SAND ? Okay maybe to get his hands free to salute inkarmat but I wouldn't drop fresh meat in sand like that wtf
anyway, I still enjoy this show and I'm eager to see the karafuto arc being put on screen!
Please comment or reblog with your impressions !













