When Phoebe mentioned having crushes, Jack pulled away from her neck, looking slightly puzzled.
"You had crushes before me? What the hell?" Jack let out an exasperated sigh, as if Phoebe had just delivered the worst news he'd heard that day. She sort of had! "I just don't understand why you couldn't have known that I was going to be in your life one day and waited?"
All jokes, of course, but Jack did feel a little jealous of anyone that had known Phoebe longer than Jack, which was ... most of the people in her life. Crushes, friends, ex-boyfriends, teachers.
"I used to— make stuff, when I had crushes. So I would have made you a really big paper Valentine. I learned how to make pop-up cards, so it would have been like, a 3-D pop up Valentine, with the twitterpated lovebirds from Bambi in it, or something. Would you have been my Valentine?"
Jack listened intently, raising a brow as he pondered his options.
"I would have been your Valentine," he decided. "But you probably already had other Valentines that you preferred. Clearly..."
Jack was milking it now, but it felt easier than focusing on the sad. The idea that Phoebe would never know his mother, and his mother would never know Phoebe. If he and Phoebe ever got married, if he was ever lucky enough to be a father, his mother would not be there.
It was very sad to think about.
It was easier to joke about Phoebe's crushes and her sweet tooth.
"Would you try to kill me with your triple chocolate cookies with chocolate sprinkles and whip cream?"
Jack detaches from the cozy place between her shoulder and neck.
'You had crushes before me? What the hell?'
Uh-oh. There's even a sigh accompanying Jack's words too— it was serious! As funny as Jack's tone his, the noise of indignation, Phoebe felt it. Actually felt it. Wouldn't have life been so much better if it had always had Jack? Teamed up during dodgeball. Exchanging paper Jack o' Lanterns during Halloween. Trading secrets after school, trading a first kiss too.
Maybe she could have even met his mom.
A fierce pang overtakes her heart. What Phoebe would have given to have met the woman who had made Jack — who had loved him so well. She would have loved to look her in the eye and promise to love Jack just as seriously.
'I just don't understand why you couldn't have known that I was going to be in your life one day and waited?'
Which— fair question! Extremely fair. If Phoebe had any gift of foresight, any knowledge about the existence of Jack, the eventual intersection of their lives... of course she would have waited! Of course. There was no question of the matter.
'I would have been your Valentine,'
Jack, graciously, would have still accepted— but there's certainly a specific tone to his words now.
'But you probably already had other Valentines that you preferred. Clearly...'
Uh-oh. Phoebe had better smooth this over.
Phoebe beams up at Jack, bats her lashes apologetically as she smooths a hand along the crown of his head.
"I didn't know!" she giggles. "I'm sorry! You would have been my only Valentine, Jack, you're the only one who would have gotten one from me! And I wouldn't have taken any random guy's stinky Valentine either!"
Yuck! Phoebe can see it perfectly in her mind's eye— her explosion of gluesticks, craft scissors, paper, studiously ignoring all other boys in favor of completing Jack's gift.
Phoebe wiggles in— kisses him again, soft and slow.
"If I had known about you... I would have waited. So you could have had my first kiss."
Her brows push together. If only she had known— known about the miracle, the perfect alignment of stars and ley lines that had led her to Jack. It feels exceptional that she knew him now, felt like a rare gift, an opportunity that could not be wasted.
Phoebe was not particularly religious, but a part of her wants to ask God for help, for guidance. Please help me to make the most of this. Please help me to love Jack right.
'Would you try to kill me with your triple chocolate cookies with chocolate sprinkles and whip cream?'
Another soft kiss. A giggle.
"Mmm. No. I would have made you some regular ones too. Not just triple chocolate. I wouldn't make you suffer through my sweet tooth."












