I have a lesbian who is hunted by a monster for much of my book, and I've been avoiding it (she only barely escapes at first) but I think she needs to die. How do I do it tactfully? She's not the only lgbt main char but I want to do her justice
The Bury Your Gays Breakdown, from a Super Mysterious Assistant
Alright!  First, in case itâs helpful for anyone reading, Iâm going to go into âshould she die?â  It sounds like youâre pretty settled on that, but bear with me for a minute here.
So you want to kill your lesbian (or otherwise not-staight-and-cis) character!
The first thing you should consider is, does she have to die?  If so, why?  Is it the logical conclusion of her character arc to die?  Is there no other possible way the plot could be resolved?  If you canât answer âyesâ to one or both of those, you might want to reconsider killing her.  (If the answer to âwhy does she need to die?â is âso her girlfriend is single again and can be paired with another characterâ then you really want to reconsider, because it will not look good and there will be backlash.)
The second thing to consider is, do you have other living representation? Â This is pretty simple: if you only have one lesbian character, killing her is more of a problem, because then youâre killing 100% of your lesbian characters. Â If you have five lesbian characters, killing one-who is now 20% of your lesbian characters-isnât as big an issue. Â Keep in mind, you also want to consider how significant these other characters are: if you kill off a major lesbian character, you need other major lesbian characters to balance it out; minor characters who have two lines in the entire book donât count, even if theyâre lesbians. Â (Whether other LGBT characters count is a bit of a gray area. Â If you have one lesbian character who dies, but a bisexual, a transgender, a gay, and an ace character that live, itâs not quite as good as having several living lesbian characters, but itâs better than only having living straight-and-cis characters.)
So youâve decided you have a good reason to kill your lesbian character, and your story wonât be bereft of any living representation when you do? Â Letâs talk about how to kill her well!
The first rule is, however your character dies, it should not have to do with her being a lesbian. Â She should not be seduced by a woman who turns out to be an assassin (or vampire) and murders her. Â She should not run into Zeus, who kills her for refusing him. Â She should, probably, not be shot and killed by a stray bullet, although five years from now that one might be okay. Â What kills her should be just as likely (historically, in both media and real life, as well as logically) to kill anyone else.
The second rule is, her death has to be the result of her choice. Â She shouldnât die because someone else decided to kill her, and she didnât have enough plot armor to stop them. Â She should die because she made a decision-maybe not rational, maybe not fully aware of the risks, but her own decision-and that decision directly resulted in her death. Â She stepped in front of the charging mook to protect the hero while he finished the spell that will save the world, or she decided to cross the canyon on the rickety bridge as a shortcut, and it broke when she was halfway across.
The third rule is, her death has to matter to the plot.  This one is a little hard to pin down, because âthe plotâ is such a variable thing, but the general idea is: imagine if, instead of dying, your lesbian character got exasperated with these idiots sheâs been hanging around with, bought a bus ticket to California, and lived out the rest of her life in happy plot-free-land.  Would the rest of your story go the same way, minor details (such as a mention of her) aside?  Then there is a problem.  If, however, whatever she does while or because sheâs dying, or what she does that results in her death, changes the direction of the plot, then her death matters.
Now, one last thing: if you do all this, your reader, or listeners, or watchers, will still be upset. Â But if theyâre upset because a favorite character of theirs died, rather than because another lesbian was killed for no purpose but sensationalism, then youâve done your job well.