#extradirty
Kiana Khansmith
macklin celebrini has autism
Love Begins
styofa doing anything
⁂
noise dept.
Today's Document
Cosimo Galluzzi
trying on a metaphor
he wasn't even looking at me and he found me
Sweet Seals For You, Always
cherry valley forever
No title available
I'd rather be in outer space 🛸
@theartofmadeline
Kaledo Art
❣ Chile in a Photography ❣
Three Goblin Art
titsay
seen from Tunisia
seen from Morocco
seen from New Zealand
seen from France
seen from United States
seen from Brazil
seen from United States
seen from Spain
seen from Brazil
seen from Russia
seen from United States
seen from United States
seen from United States
seen from Türkiye
seen from United States
seen from Malaysia
seen from Singapore
seen from United States
seen from France
seen from United States
@pizzaboro
Voldemort was a misunderstood hero who started out as an orphan, graduated as one of the brightest students of Hogwarts, brought the pesky purebloods to heel with his dark and awesome power, who stood for creature rights when no one else would, who was betrayed by the person he trusted the most and failed by all his other useless followers, who died believing in a better future.
R.I.P. Tommy
Shouldve trusted wormy
People who're more useful to the Voldemort than Regulus Black:
- Draco 'my father's gonna know about this' Malfoy
- Fenrir 'three little kids' Greyback
-Winnie the f-ing pooh
-Peter 'long dong' Pettigrew
-Lucius 'I lost me elf!!!!!' Malfoy
-Severus 'omg Lilyyyyyyyyyyyyy' Snape
-Sirius 'hahaha oily dark arts slimeballs go brrrr' Black
-Xenophilius 'are those crumplehaired snorlacks!? ' Lovegood
People who're more useful to destroying Voldemort than Regulus Black:
-Narcissa 'omg my chiiild!!' Malfoy
-Mundungus 'hi there shiny' Fletcher
-Severus 'omg Lilyyyyyyyyyyyyy' Snape
-His freaking elf Kreacher, who doesn't die in a freaking lake after leaving a freaking note
-Lord 'It didn't occur to me to drop that baby from the empire state' Voldemort
- Dudley 'Ill teach Harry some reflexes by bullying him' Dursley
The character limit isn't enough to add all the names that did more to this list. And regulus is a hero? He couldn't even be a minor villain 🤣🤣🤣
Regulus Black is a useless Death Eater, a useless Good guy, and a useless master who almost let kreacher be killed and then let him wallow in misery because he was too chicken to face Voldemort after betraying him.
Why do people respect him? He's the guy who led the most pointless life ever. Even his brother considers him an idiot who probably got himself killed by Death Eaters. Really low opinion of his skills, big bro
How Lily fell for James, finally?
Lily didn’t fall for James in a fraction of second. She did not stand in the quidditch stand and realize that James was hot and she loved him. It was a very gradual and beautiful process and James being the oblivious person he was did not realize it until Lily kissed him because she could not pretend anymore.
This is how it happened
CHAPTER ONE
After Snape called her a mudblood, Lily felt as if she were ripped apart by a sharp knife. But she did not show it. All she could do was hold her tears and walk away from prying eyes into a rabbit hole where she could process her emotions. She found it in the prefect bathroom. She layed there for what felt like eternity, with tear marks on her face. Suddenly she heard the door creak. She wanted to stand up and look who that was bit she couldn’t gather the strength to do it. The someone, who she assumed to be a person, dropped beside her and started rubbing her shoulder. She felt a bolt of warmth run up her spine. She did not want to know how that was………
A ray of sunshine glazed directly on Lily’s face, walking her up. She noticed that she was still beside someone. She turned to see James Potter sleeping with his glasses slipping from his nose and his hair messy as always. She could not believe her eyes. James arrogant toerag Potter, was the person who comforted her last night and the crazy thing being she wanted him to comfort her but why? She hates him. He is an arrogant bully. As Lily processed her thoughts, James woke up, rubbing his eyes vigorously. He saw Lily staring at her with a confused look. “Alright there, Evans”, he said with a smirk on his face. “Yes, I am good. Thank you for yesterday. It was really helpful but I still cannot believe you stayed with me this entire time. I mean you must have something better to do rather than con-.” Before Lily could complete, she was interrupted by James,“ It’s ok, Evans. Anything for you.” With this he stood up and left through the door leaving Lily with a smile on her tear stricken face.
Post #3
Snape rattled out Remus' condition just because he could not receive the Order of Merlin. He potentially wanted Remus to lose his job which was the last option for him as he will not be able to get another job due to his condition. All he could think about was himself. Even though he made the portion for Remus, this was excessive. He already wanted the job so he thought that by making Remus, who found it difficult to secure a well paying job, to resign just so he could teach his favourite subject even though he had a well paying job. He wanted take revenge for not getting the order of Merlin by making Remus unemployed. He really is the bravest man I ever knew hahahah!! Snape is a toxic person pining over his high school crush who he called a 'mudblood' in the first place.
The last is true, but why wouldn't you want bloody revenge on a werewolf who almost turned you twice? I'm really all for more werewolves in the castle, but Lupin tranformed infront of three kids. I mean
It’s Snape’s birthday and I would just like to say
I don’t respect the greasy abuseive teacher man
Please use today as an excuse to cyberbully fictional characters
The spelling is wrong, but you got the spirit! ❤️
Because he was a f-ing asshole
It's crazy bc I will admit that I'm a villain apologist at times but only if they're hot. Snape doesn't even have that going for him
Self awareness is good
Regulus Black defected out of compassion.
Severus Snape defected out of selfishness.
And y’all have to ask why only one of them’s the real Hero of Slytherin lmao.
Regulus black died for nothing. He's the lamest Slytherin ever.
I really don’t get the headcanon that Snape was super close with the Malfoys and was Draco’s Godfather.
Surely by those standards, Snape is nothing more than another Peter Pettigrew? Someone who sells out his own friends who he relied on for ‘protection’ when he wished for it, for his own personal gain. Even if he isn’t friends with the Malfoys, that’s what he does to the rest of them.
He might have been fighting for the right side in the end but that’s only because the dark side no longer served his interests. What a sell out.
Let’s stop comparing Snape to James. He’s basically the Death Eaters’ Pettigrew.
He totally is another pettigrew. Just that pettigrew actually stood to gain something. Snapey turned his coat for nothing. Freaking idiot
Snape was no hero. He was a self-serving asshole who went along with whatever the highest bidder had to offer and was quite happy to sell out his friends to pursue his own self-interests.
First sweet Lily, who was better off without him, then his Death Eater pals.
A dick of the highest order.
Ikr. Freaking hell. It never made sense to me why he would ever care that Lily Potter lived or not. He brought down all the people who accepted him and gave him a place to belong for a pathetic crush on a ex friend
nobody:
nobody at all:
snape: im gonna make a spell that causes the victim to suffer from multiple deep cuts that will cause them to bleed out. just for fun lol
So much potential, wasted
Why did Snape use the Sectumsempra to disarm a death eater in the battle of seven Potters?
Please answer this question for me🙂
Because he was disarming him, duh
While I like the headcanon that everyone in the staff hates Snape, since I find the angst delicious, it isn’t canon. In Philosophers Stone, Quirrel mentioned that Snape “made himself unpopular among the staff” when he offered to referee the Quidditch match. Meaning that before doing that he had been well liked.
you don't go from well liked to unpopular due to a single match. They must've been lukewarm at best on him. How can you truly trust a death eater on staff?
Apparently he was, well liked. There’s no explanation for Quirrel’s comment otherwise. As for why they would trust a Death Eater, the answer is simple. 1) We don’t know how many of them knew he was a Death Eater, since he wasn’t well known in the first war. Sirius, for example, had no clue. The only one who gives some indication of having known is McGonagall, the only member of the Order on staff other than Snape and Dumbledore, when she says “we all wondered” after killing Dumbledore, but that could easily been interpreted as her having found out after he started actively spying in Harry’s fifth year, along with the rest of the Order. After finding out, she would consult Dumbledore, and end up trusting his judgement.
Besides, you underestimate how important Quidditch is to the staff. McGonagall was willing to directly circumvent school rules to give the Gryffindor team an advantage, and was a commentator for the games. Quidditch points go to the House cup, which is also a source of fierce rivalry. Without the context, it would have been seen as blatant cheating, by the staff.
And the teachers don’t really give a shit about how Snape behaves in the classroom, the only times where Snape is presented as unreasonable by other adults is when he goes on rants about Harry. Otherwise, they don’t care at all.
Quirell's statement makes complete sense. It's only objective is to show how Snapey became unpopular after the quidditch match. If he was popular or not is not explicit, and really how does a well liked teacher become unpopular with one action? It only makes sense if he was not that popular in the first place. Do you thing McG, a well respected member of the staff would become unpopular with just one act?
It's just important to McG. The rest don't really care about it afawk.
It must've been pretty well known. It was covered by Skeeter, Snapey was a named death eater in even Igor Karkaroff's trial. At the time he was a staff member. Most staff members are very old. How would they not know that he was one? Maybe some of the newer ones, but really, there is no newer one this year. And of course they trust in Albus, but letting him teach and tolerating him is quite different from liking him. His blatant dislike for the students and his dark reputation amongst them wouldn't help
You know what, you're right about Quirrell's comment not necessitating that he be popular, just that he not be unpopular. He very well have been neutral, as in, neither popular nor unpopular. And him being that makes more sense.
They all care about the House Cup, and that implies caring about the Quidditch cup, even if you don't care about Quidditch, since Quidditch points transfer over.
For all we know she did become unpopular at some point. We get very little insight into the inner workings of the staff, that's why we have to rely on offhand comments like this. Though in my personal opinion McGonagall was very well liked, more than Snape, and thus it would be harder for her to lose popularity.
Was it well known though? Fudge seemed extremely surprised when Snape showed him his Dark Mark, and he was Minister of Magic. There were around 400 Death Eaters in the First Blood War according to Remus, that's a lot. Karkaroff named Snape only as a last resort when he was running out names, after he had already given a lot. Snape was barely known as a Death Eater in the first war, to the point that Sirius didn't know he was one. Sirius. Out of 400 people, it makes sense for Snape to pass unnoticed among the staff. I don't quite remember Skeeter covering him, could you point me to that?
Maybe they do, maybe not. McG has history with quidditch which makes her love it enough that any perceived injustice in it would bleed over into her personal relationships. The other professors really aren't shown loving it enough that the bleeding in would happen. If they worry about the points, surely they have more reason to dislike Snape, who mostly takes points from other houses, not his own
I agree
400 were fighting against the order, assuming you're getting that number from his offhand comment of 20x order members. That doesn't mean all of them would be death eaters. Death eaters seem to be much limited in number. Not everyone is given the mark.
When voldemort returns, he names two that have been lost. One is karkaroff, the other Snape. The rest are either in prison or have come at their master's call. He may have lost more supporters, but in terms of death eaters, he's only missing two. Unless the ministry somehow got 400 DEs either captured or killed. That doesn't seem feasible. When the azkaban is broken, only 10 or so death eaters come out. That hints toward a lower number of marked death eaters. The rest of the ranks would be filled out by snatchers and creatures. They would still be counted as fighting the order, which is what Remus was likely referring to
Skeeter covered the next trial. The ludo bagman one. Still, it's hardly feasible that a named death eater would not make waves, especially when he's vouched for by albus dd, who confirms infront of 200 witches and wizards at Igor's hearing that Snape was a DE but had defected.
The wizarding community is 10k strong at the maximum. They have one school. A school whose headmaster just admitted that one of his staff members was a death eater. It's impossible for this not to get back to the staff. It's simply a numbers game. There were no measures to ensure silence. Why wouldn't they tell their child to be wary of the death eater teacher? Why would news from these 200 witches and wizards not reach the staff who stand at the centre of the wizarding world?
Sirius doesn't know anything because he went to azkaban before the trial happened. His main objection is that Dumbledore wouldn't hire someone who was a death eater on staff (which should be even more telling of how much it would be gossiped about among the 200). It's his belief in DD, not his belief in Snape, who he knew loved the Dark arts, that makes him say that to reassure Harry.
Fudge is an outsider, for all he is minister. Snape is not someone who'd be very interesting to outsiders, but very interesting for people with children and the teachers of Hogwarts. Maybe he forgot, maybe he never really thought of DEs and pretended to forget that one of his backers was one, maybe he knew, and that surprise is due to seeing the mark for the first time, so black, rather than Severus being one.
While all who have the Dark Mark are Death Eaters, not all Death Eaters have the Dark Mark. Fenrir Greyback for example is a Death Eater, and he doesn’t have it. The mark is just a tool Voldemort uses to be able to summon certain followers or have them summon him. He gives it out if he deems it necessary. While it’s considered an honor by his followers to have it, he himself doesn’t really give a shit. He treats Wormtail, who has it, with absolute contempt.
The reason he singles out Karkaroff and Snape is because two of his marked death eaters are missing. Not two out of all of them. The reason he that only the marked came to him is because rhey were the only ones that he could summon. The rest had no clue he was alive up until he started making waves again.
When did Ludo Bagman’s trail happen? I would like to reread, but I don’t remember.
Is it confirmed that Albus declared that Snape had defected the DE? I think he just denied it altogether, claiming that he “was as much a DE as I am”. Though I could be wrong. It would explain Fudge’s surprise more.
If Dumbledore did indeed say that he was a former DE, then that indeed heightens the probability of it getting back to the staff. Then again, did the staff know that Karkaroff was a DE? If they did, then it increases the probability even more. If they didn’t, it lowers it a lot.
Nice discussion!
Wormtail was given it as a sign of honor, for all voldemort has contempt of him. Fenrir is not considered a proper death eater. His lack of mark is because he's a werewolf, and not considered an equal by Voldemort and his followers.
Ludo Bagman's trial, alongwith Karkaroff's and Barty (and the other three) happens in The Pensieve chapter of the GoF, p517. The Skeeter bit is right after Karkaroff's, but she was sitting for Bagman's trial, which happened sometime after.
The marked ones are the death eaters, the most loyal. The rest are merely supporters. They are the ones important enough to be marked.
Albus confirmed it: " I have given evidence already on the matter. Severus Snape was indeed a death eater. However, he rejoined our side before Lord Voldemort's downfall and turned spy for us, at great personal risk. He is now no more a Death Eater than I am"
I don't remember if they know about Karkaroff or not. Presumably yes, he was a death eater that led to the capture of Rookwood, who had many spies inside the ministry. Very high chance they'd know of Snape who's a colleague though. Atleast the older staff, which form the majority.
Thanks, I agree.
While I like the headcanon that everyone in the staff hates Snape, since I find the angst delicious, it isn’t canon. In Philosophers Stone, Quirrel mentioned that Snape “made himself unpopular among the staff” when he offered to referee the Quidditch match. Meaning that before doing that he had been well liked.
you don't go from well liked to unpopular due to a single match. They must've been lukewarm at best on him. How can you truly trust a death eater on staff?
Apparently he was, well liked. There’s no explanation for Quirrel’s comment otherwise. As for why they would trust a Death Eater, the answer is simple. 1) We don’t know how many of them knew he was a Death Eater, since he wasn’t well known in the first war. Sirius, for example, had no clue. The only one who gives some indication of having known is McGonagall, the only member of the Order on staff other than Snape and Dumbledore, when she says “we all wondered” after killing Dumbledore, but that could easily been interpreted as her having found out after he started actively spying in Harry’s fifth year, along with the rest of the Order. After finding out, she would consult Dumbledore, and end up trusting his judgement.
Besides, you underestimate how important Quidditch is to the staff. McGonagall was willing to directly circumvent school rules to give the Gryffindor team an advantage, and was a commentator for the games. Quidditch points go to the House cup, which is also a source of fierce rivalry. Without the context, it would have been seen as blatant cheating, by the staff.
And the teachers don’t really give a shit about how Snape behaves in the classroom, the only times where Snape is presented as unreasonable by other adults is when he goes on rants about Harry. Otherwise, they don’t care at all.
Quirell's statement makes complete sense. It's only objective is to show how Snapey became unpopular after the quidditch match. If he was popular or not is not explicit, and really how does a well liked teacher become unpopular with one action? It only makes sense if he was not that popular in the first place. Do you thing McG, a well respected member of the staff would become unpopular with just one act?
It's just important to McG. The rest don't really care about it afawk.
It must've been pretty well known. It was covered by Skeeter, Snapey was a named death eater in even Igor Karkaroff's trial. At the time he was a staff member. Most staff members are very old. How would they not know that he was one? Maybe some of the newer ones, but really, there is no newer one this year. And of course they trust in Albus, but letting him teach and tolerating him is quite different from liking him. His blatant dislike for the students and his dark reputation amongst them wouldn't help
You know what, you're right about Quirrell's comment not necessitating that he be popular, just that he not be unpopular. He very well have been neutral, as in, neither popular nor unpopular. And him being that makes more sense.
They all care about the House Cup, and that implies caring about the Quidditch cup, even if you don't care about Quidditch, since Quidditch points transfer over.
For all we know she did become unpopular at some point. We get very little insight into the inner workings of the staff, that's why we have to rely on offhand comments like this. Though in my personal opinion McGonagall was very well liked, more than Snape, and thus it would be harder for her to lose popularity.
Was it well known though? Fudge seemed extremely surprised when Snape showed him his Dark Mark, and he was Minister of Magic. There were around 400 Death Eaters in the First Blood War according to Remus, that's a lot. Karkaroff named Snape only as a last resort when he was running out names, after he had already given a lot. Snape was barely known as a Death Eater in the first war, to the point that Sirius didn't know he was one. Sirius. Out of 400 people, it makes sense for Snape to pass unnoticed among the staff. I don't quite remember Skeeter covering him, could you point me to that?
Maybe they do, maybe not. McG has history with quidditch which makes her love it enough that any perceived injustice in it would bleed over into her personal relationships. The other professors really aren't shown loving it enough that the bleeding in would happen. If they worry about the points, surely they have more reason to dislike Snape, who mostly takes points from other houses, not his own
I agree
400 were fighting against the order, assuming you're getting that number from his offhand comment of 20x order members. That doesn't mean all of them would be death eaters. Death eaters seem to be much limited in number. Not everyone is given the mark.
When voldemort returns, he names two that have been lost. One is karkaroff, the other Snape. The rest are either in prison or have come at their master's call. He may have lost more supporters, but in terms of death eaters, he's only missing two. Unless the ministry somehow got 400 DEs either captured or killed. That doesn't seem feasible. When the azkaban is broken, only 10 or so death eaters come out. That hints toward a lower number of marked death eaters. The rest of the ranks would be filled out by snatchers and creatures. They would still be counted as fighting the order, which is what Remus was likely referring to
Skeeter covered the next trial. The ludo bagman one. Still, it's hardly feasible that a named death eater would not make waves, especially when he's vouched for by albus dd, who confirms infront of 200 witches and wizards at Igor's hearing that Snape was a DE but had defected.
The wizarding community is 10k strong at the maximum. They have one school. A school whose headmaster just admitted that one of his staff members was a death eater. It's impossible for this not to get back to the staff. It's simply a numbers game. There were no measures to ensure silence. Why wouldn't they tell their child to be wary of the death eater teacher? Why would news from these 200 witches and wizards not reach the staff who stand at the centre of the wizarding world?
Sirius doesn't know anything because he went to azkaban before the trial happened. His main objection is that Dumbledore wouldn't hire someone who was a death eater on staff (which should be even more telling of how much it would be gossiped about among the 200). It's his belief in DD, not his belief in Snape, who he knew loved the Dark arts, that makes him say that to reassure Harry.
Fudge is an outsider, for all he is minister. Snape is not someone who'd be very interesting to outsiders, but very interesting for people with children and the teachers of Hogwarts. Maybe he forgot, maybe he never really thought of DEs and pretended to forget that one of his backers was one, maybe he knew, and that surprise is due to seeing the mark for the first time, so black, rather than Severus being one.
people aren't ok with james and sirius bullying a racist greasy slimeball who threw away the only person that ever cared for him and called her a slur then proceeded to cradle her dead body in front of her injured traumatized crying son but are ok with snape bullying literal children and threatening toads and outing a werewolf who was literally harmless under care just because of something that happened almost two decades before (and he didnt ever have anything to do with it) even though he wasn't even harmed................ that's fucked up
Lupin was a fucknut who transformed in front of kids. I'm all in favor of more werewolves, but calling Lupin harmless is insulting, frankly. He's a dark creature. He's good when taking wolfsbane, but he didn't take it
Fuck Snape for the abuse. He should've stuck to his dark arts
people posting snape hate, thinking they’re making a really good point: if snape was real he’d hate you and be really mean to you!!!!! what would you do then??
snape fans:
He'd probably get arrested for pulling half the shit that he did, so really, there wouldn't be much to watch except sev being read his miranda rights
snape fans watching him get put in handcuffs:
Degenerates, the lot of you ;)
