After the smashing season finale, we're once again left with the burning question, "Who is A?". We haven't quite figured it out, but we're going to offer our suspects, in hopes that it will help yours! We respect all feedback given to us in our ask box, and if you have more information to add as to why a certain character might be A, we'll add it to our post with credit to you! So, let's start analyzing.
Caleb Rivers:Â We don't have much dirt of Caleb just yet, but isn't it ironic that he makes his return known just after the incidents of 'That Night' on the rooftop? Is it possible that Caleb was the one under the ski mask? We also do know that he was working with Jenna, who we've debunked as "A", but it could be a plot to get to the liars all along.
Noel Kahn: For anyone who's read the books, we all know where Noel's fate is lying if he continues to be a guest star on the show. For those of you who don't know, Noel finds himself as an "A" suspect, where a psycho-A beats him and leaves him left-for-dead in a barn for the girls to find. He survives, but that's not to say that he isn't showing a similar fate in the show. Maybe this time he is "A". Where has he been since the game was stolen from Mona after all? Ali make's it clear that he has secrets too, and when Alison DiLaurentis holds something against you, it's apparently enough to want her dead. Noel was also the only one who knew where Ali had been hiding when "A" attacked.
Alison/Courtney DiLaurentis: Now, we know this is a touchy subject, but hear us out! By now, everyone is aware of the twin, Courtney, who —in the books — steals Alison's identity and in turn, sends Ali to the nut house and giving Courtney a perfect life. In the show, the events of Labor Day Weekend happened only two years ago, the same time that the Clark Rehabilitation Centre that Jason lied about going to closed down. We received a flashback from two years ago, just as Alison (or truthfully Courtney) is heading out to the barn to meet up with her friends, and to discover who "A" is. We hear Jessica on the phone saying "How could you let this happen?" — Could she be talking about the Real Ali escaping while they were closing down? She insists her daughter stay in tonight to keep her safe, but her wishes are ignored. Come the night of that weekend, Courtney's head is bashed in with a rock, where Jessica and CeCe are there to witness Ali's supposed murder. Jessica, in order to protect her daughter, buries Courtney, muttering to the other twin "What have you done?". Ali runs away, and her mother, in order to protect her daughter, keeps a bedroom available for her if she ever wished to return. When Ali returns, she makes up a fake story about being saved, somehow getting Grunwald to go along with it. And for you book readers, Ali came back with a few lies in the novels as well. This wouldn't be a far stretch.
Also keep in mind, Jessica had mentioned Ali had broken her arm. Courtney hadn't, which is why the body didm't come up with any fractures. The fact that Jessica was trying to desperately to keep the detective off her dead daughters case could also mean they don't want them finding out there was a twin, as well as the fact that Jessica buried her.
Also, keep in mind that later in the series (which, because they skipped an arc according to the show), we do find out that one of the "A" members are a guy, along with Ali. Which could explain how one "A" pretended to come after Ali. After all, how many opportunities did they have to get her?
Thanks for reading. Be sure to leave your comments in our ask box! Stay tuned for all-new Pretty Little Liars episodes, Tuesday, June 10, 2014!
yousharknotpass
janainaart
areudirty
titsay
vaporwave
dailybridgerton