Deltarune Chapter 5 Spoilers, both normal and Weird routes
A criticism I’ve seen with Susie and Noelle being a thing and the whole festival and lake scenes are that they as a couple seem really forced and that it feels like we’ve rushed way too fast into it.
I genuinely think that’s the point.
Note: I personally like Noelle/Susie most but this isn’t about that. This is a story discussion.
The name of the OST during the lake scene is titled “I guess I’m in love”. Peep the wording.
Not ‘I think’, ‘I guess’.
I think that’s a legitimate hint that the state of their relationship isn’t proper one.
To me, it goes like this. Noelle is the driving force behind the relationship, who was already practically obsessed with Susie even before the events of Chapter 1 (as evidenced by all the dialogue that shows she doesn’t thing Susie is all that bad and takes the thing about her eating chalk seriously). We’ll get to Susie later but I think this obsession is fueled mainly by Noelle’s desire for chaos.
In the Weird Route, Noelle spelled it out that she was enamored by Kris’ ‘weird’ tendencies because she hated the monotony that her life had become ever since Dess went missing and her dad got ill. The Weird route happened because Noelle caught on to the player’s weird actions and wanted THAT. To not be Noelle anymore, at its worst stage.
But before that? She wanted Susie.
The social pariah who did whatever the fuck she wanted.
I don’t think Noelle genuinely finds love in her heart for Susie, but for what she represents. The chaos she’s been wanting, the freedom to do whatever she wants and not care. The choice to spread her wings and fly.
Of course, I’m not saying there’s absolutely no love on Noelle’s part, but the main basis is how much Susie just does whatever she wants, which is what Noelle always wanted to do. Susie inviting her for the group study meeting behind Berdly’s back, Susie telling Berdly to shove it and throwing her phone, and Susie deciding to play the guitar. All of this, Noelle felt hesitant to because it conflicted with her perfect girl persona, and that excited her when they went through with it anyway.
As for Susie, I genuinely think a large part of why she’s grown so attached to Noelle in Chapter 5 is because she was hurting and looking for comfort.
In the previous chapter, Susie and Noelle’s relationship was still mostly on Noelle, but they did progress slightly thanks to them finding shared interests in horror movies during the blackout scene. Susie probably didn’t fully feel in love with Noelle, but had the little spark in her judging by her reaction to the ‘Love finds the girl’ prophecy she saw.
Of course, we know how Chapter 4 ended. With Susie being betrayed by the one adult she genuinely respected and probably kinda loved. And she absolutely was stung by it, considering her reaction to trying to go back to Kris’ home during the festival. Not to mention, a tragedy is due thanks to the prophecy glass she shattered (btw, I’m like 90% sure it’s that Castle Town will have to be sealed away).
So, what happens then? Susie’s hurt as fuck and aching inside, and turns to the one person she is probably could; Noelle. The spark in her heart for her was stoked artificially by the pain of Toriel’s betrayal and the horrible news that we don’t know yet, pushing her to find some comfort with Noelle (which does end up going pretty well… until the end of course).
And this is where the relationship shatters.
Noelle will be in absolute devastation mode for her dad, and Susie will have absolutely no idea how to help her through it. Their relationship will reveal itself for the crutches they were to both to them, and they’ll break apart. Because it wasn’t built to handle that pressure.
It’s here that the story can either go with them learning how love genuinely works and their relationship healing through the pain of the coming hardships, or them downgrading to just good friends after coming to realize that they can’t work as a couple. Either way, I think it’ll work. The story is set up that I can see either thing happening and don’t really have a preference which, even though I do like Susie/Noelle.