âWhen they were young, really just starting out their Hogwarts careers, Lily had made up a story in her head about Peter Pettigrew, based solely on observation, and the assumptions she made about his friends. In Lilyâs mind Peter had been a scared little boy, clinging to the biggest bullies he could find in the hopes that he could avoid becoming their target by being their sycophant. Of course, in this story those bullies had been James, her future husband, and Sirius, whoâd grow into the man sheâd trust to be her sonâs godfather in the middle of a war that wanted her dead. When sheâd realized sheâd been wrong about James and Sirius, sheâd assumed sheâd been wrong about Peter, too.
It had taken years for Lily to put aside her preconceived notions, and her pride, and admit that the marauders were not who she thought they were. Once she did that, sheâd formed a mental image of Peter as a charming and funny young man, if in a quieter way than some of the others. After that she always made a point of building up Peter, encouraging his better angels and discouraging his worse impulses, just as she did all of her boys. Sheâd even supported his relationship with Mary. Mary who, more than any of Lilyâs friends, deserved only good things.
Oh, how Lilyâs heart had broken when she realized her first estimation of Peter had been the true one. But even that, she might have been able to forgive. After all, she knew everyone made mistakes. She knew you could love someone without loving the choices they made. Lily still loved Petunia, despite everything that had gone wrong between the sisters, but Petuniaâs choices had only ever hurt Lily. Peterâs choices had threatened Harry.
Not only that, but Peter had known his choices threatened Harry, and that Lily could never forgive.
That Lily would never forgive.Â
So when Peter sneered at her Lily was not cowed. When he leaned against the bar and showed her the Dark Mark on his arm she did not flinch. Lily had spent the past several months hardening her heart to this man, with every ounce of stubbornness, and pettiness, that she contained on her side, and his casual arrogance had no effect on it. Instead she leaned, pushing up on her toes and bracing herself against the bar, getting as close to in his space, and in his face, as she could.
âBut Voldemort did. That was all you could bring to the table, wasnât it? All your Dark Lord was interested in. It was never about you, only what you could give him. And you couldnât even get that right.â Lily rocked back on her heels, still holding Peterâs gaze. This was the ugly side of Lilyâs temper, the side she was most likely to regret later. Her anger would tip over into self-righteous indignation and name her judge, jury, and executioner. And she never hesitated to use someoneâs weaknesses against them. Lily knew Peter had struggled after they graduated, that heâd felt left out and left behind. At the time, it had been a reason to go out of her way to make sure he felt included, and valued. Now it was just another weapon in her arsenal.Â
âDonât forget who won the war. You signed your own death warrant, trying to choose the strongest side instead of the right one. So you can have the shadows. You can have the back alleys and the gutters. But donât for one second think you deserve to stand in the sun with the rest of us. And I donât care if it means you never set foot outside Knockturn Alley again, you make sure you stay away from my son. For your own sake.â
Peter had always noticed the casting glances. Those who didnât quite size him up to be akin to his friends, those who viewed him as a boy who just fawned at the other Marauderâs feet. That assumption had never been true, He had always been his own person in his own right. Perhaps it was because he didnât come with his own golden halo quite like James or from a well-established family like Sirius. Perhaps in that aspect, he faded into the other boyâs shadow. But not without a fight, always large in laughter and jest, his cheeky comments radiating through the corridors that he walked. A wink at McGonagall and a fist thrown at Slytherins. He had never been quiet or a kiss-ass waiting to bask in the Marauderâs glory. Those who saw him as inferior just happened to have that preconception.Â
 At Hogwarts, Peter Pettigrew didnât have an opinion on Lily Evans. Other than teasing James about drawing her heart dotted letters on his parchment. She had seemed dead on, with not much for Peter to begrudge against her. Barring the obvious friendship with Severus Snape, a questionable taste. Although, Peter could hardly judge with the current company which he had felt solace in. It was only once the man began to date Mary, that his friendship with Lily Evans began to flourish. Finding a similar humour and comfort with the woman as they spoke. If Peterâs life hadnât of took a spin, perhaps Mary and Peter still would have partook in double dates with James and Lily.
 In their early years of friendship, Peter appreciated Lilyâs dedication to Peter bettering himself. With conversations about the new and up-coming, Pettigrewâs Pub. One of Peterâs charming ventures before the mirror cracked and the darkness came flooding out beneath the shards. A kindred ship that Peter appreciated, until he didnât. In the last three years of his friendship with the Marauders, from the group of friends joined the Order. It became overbearing. Who were these people advising him to do more with his life? The same ones who barely had the consideration to ask him how he was coping after Hogwarts? The same ones who witnessed him withdraw without a bat of an eye-lid? Taking his fake laughter as a reassuring gesture that he was ok? These people had no right to tell him what to do, or how to live. Not whenever they could barely direct an OWL in his direction.
Lily Potter could come in here acting high and mighty, Peter Pettigrew truly couldnât give a shit.Â
 His eyes unflickering, unbothered. Peter retreated his arm from the bar. Clearly that wasnât going to get her to fuck off. Perhaps he should get it all over with, set up a stall in Hogsmeade for his ex-friends to come and berate him. It would be easier to get the tedious interactions over with. Of course, Peter found it ironic. He knew his betrayal was severe, catastrophic and if the man could take it back, he would. Not opting to give them the luxury of droning on about his own mistakes when they had been shitty friends.
 Flicking his tongue, he began to wipe at a glass behind the bar. What did Lily know about his situation? Had she sat through the evenings he sat alone in his dark flat? Dealing with what he had done to the shop-keeper? How he had tortured an innocent man? Just to prove some shoddy loyalty to a group that Dumbledore had forced him to infiltrate when Peter already felt beyond redemption. Just like Mulciber had tortured Mary Macdonald, the love of his life, a few years prior. Lily had never been thrown into the vipers pit and told to resist being eaten.
âPerhaps, if you had actually been my friend, I would value your opinion more.â His voice cold, setting the glass down on the counter. A lie, but he didnât care. Peter just wanted Lily Potter to leave. He had enough regrets about his actions. âAll you were was my best friendâs wife. James Potter was my friend, I betrayed him. I couldnât give a fuck about what you think of me.âÂ
 âTrust me, Iâve been up in the sunshine with you all. And it wasnât that fucking great.â Peter acknowledged with a roll of his eyes. They were all good on reflecting on Peterâs flaws, if not a bit ignorant of their own.