So everytime I watch MCM 2011, I see a comment that says "So surprised this show didn't get legendary status." But it got a 97.05. "Box six" is defined by a 97-100. In history, there are 7 shows to get a 97 or higher (by comparison, there are 18 shows to get a 96). SO I watched them all and decide to make a critique of each show.
1999 - Blue Knights
Airborne: A Brief History of Flight
Score: 97.1
First of all, the line is marching Premiers. Lets just get that out of the way first and foremost. The show feature large props with propellers around the floor, as well as a big hangar-like box on the back of the floor. The opening of the show is very in your face, loud, a lot of playing. The propellers in the back are spinning the entire time, while the battery is dressed almost like mechanics or pilots, white t-shirts with army pants and boots. After the opener, there is a very entertaining segment where the battery goes into the the hangar, and the extra performers take large props and build a fake biplane on the floor, before lifting it up and running around the floor with it and then tossing it onto the ground. The whole time, the pit is playing very xylophone rag-ish music, kind of adding to the whole Charlie Chaplin goofy vibe of the segment. The battery then comes out with bomb vests on, and the propellers are turned from vertical to horizontal to simulate helicopter blades. They start the segment with a dynamically cool roll with rubber-tipped sticks and I'm assuming a sample, blending the helicopter sound with the roll. Very cool effect, and very intense segment after that. Following the helicopter portion, they have a dancer dressed as a butterfly run around the floor, before the battery emerges again from the hangar wearing bomber jackets for the big finish. They finish right up against the front of the floor, a cool effect as they push forward and the propellers are pushed behind them, almost literally propelling them forward. I don't think this show holds up well against these more current successful shows, but still an entertaining look to how far this activity has come.
2005 - Riverside Community College
Manifest Destiny
Score: 97.0
This is RCC's first appearance, having THREE box-six shows. An entertaining sort of show, the drumline is dressed in all gold, I'm assuming simulating the gold rush, but nothing in the show is particularly prevalent to showing a theme besides "play beats." We see RCC doing all of their classic tricks and being goofy, adding that West-Coast feel. There's a lot of incredible little features throughout the show, including a xylophone and snare feature where the xylo pushes out onto the floor to duet. After they finish the show, the battery puts their equipment down and takes part in a 30-second dance block to "Like I Love You" by Justin Timberlake, including a full battery moonwalk. I think this show was entertaining and a calling card for most of the mid-2000 RCC shows, but nothing was too memorable about this show aside from the "victory lap" at the end.
2009 - Rhythm X
Touch
Score: 97.263
This show claimed the highest score record from BK99. Featuring 10 snares, and an insane quad line, Touch was a musical and visual masterpiece. From the acoustic guitar and pit building to the first big impact, you knew this show was something special. There's so many parts of this show that build and then drop off, and then build again. It's like a constant roller coaster ride. They also use "touch" in many senses of the word; from the tenors rising out of an impact playing 15 inch heights with the sound of a 1 inch tap, to during another tenor feature where the cymbals touch the tenors all over, to a bass run where the last note by bass 1 is played with his finger. The show builds to a huge loud climax before the battery walks into the pit and everyone hugs and embraces each other while the acoustic guitar player walks onto the floor, joined by a bass drummer touching his arm on the last note. It's an incredible show, emotional, powerful, intense, and I think expertly crafted and arranged. A definite jump in quality and maturity from the box-six shows that preceded it.
2011- Music City Mystique
Mantra
Score: 97.05
This is the show that prompted this list. When this show first came out, I'll never forget how all of my friends in the activity freaked out. They were throwing down beats and doing goddamn yoga. Featuring a giant "drum" on the back of the floor, and multiple silk panel props across the floor, the show was very spiritual in nature. The pit book in this show is incredible, and never fails to inspire me as a mallet player. Every second of the ensemble is fantastic, but the tenors take the cake as most of them have beards and shaved their heads bald, going with the whole spiritual monk kind of theme. The middle section where the front ensemble plays is one of the best pit moments in WGI history, where they come in cold out of nowhere and play an accelerando part that constantly pushes and pulls in tempo, while the rest of the ensemble fills the floor behind them doing yoga and tai-chi-like movements. The ending of the show gets a little more Indian, with really groovy drum rhythms, before building to a big loud climax ending with a singular bass drum note and low drone monk-like note. Truly a masterpiece in terms of music and show design, despite not being particularly mind-blowing or innovative.
2012 - Riverside Community College
The Gift
Score: 97.085
This show remains top 5 most viewed on WGI Fan Network and very well deserved. It tells the story of a war. The floor is complete with those anti-ship blockers that you see on shores when an invasion is happening (see Normandy). The show is intense, very emotional. The battery is playing the entire show and RCC's fantastic tenor line is shown off yet again. At one point the battery has a really cool body break where they use their sticks as guns and pretend like they're in a fire fight. Near the end of the show, the basses carry a fake-casket draped with a yellow and black striped flag with one hand while playing with their other hand, and the show ends with the battery on their knees surrounding the casket, as a final voiceover says that a soldier fights for the freedom of people to do whatever they want, and that is their gift to you. Very powerful and intense show, very very good playing, and I think very deserving of winning that year.
2013 - Riverside Community College
State of the Arts
Score: 97.425
This show had the honor of being the highest score in WGI history...for about 3 minutes. And it's also the only show to achieve "box six" status and not win first place (although at the time I think it should have). It is narrated by Sir Ken Robinson's TED Talk on creativity, and outlines the main ideas of his talk, and how kids creativity is being squandered. Decked in all black and grey, the battery starts the show out in front of black desk-like props, before the tenors and snares all put on snares and play matched grip for a beginning feature. Everyone playing uniform together, highlighting the conformity. Slowly, the show gets bursts of color. The black desks flipped around revealed colorful graffiti, patches on sleeves and sections of drums were pulled away to reveal different colors, and cymbals were decorated with zigzags of color, as the narrator talks about being creative and having original ideas. It's again not a very mind-blowing spectacle, but the message behind the show and their fantastic playing and marching is well-deserved of the score in what I think is one of the strongest WGI years ever.
2013 - Rhythm X
The Man In The Arena
Score: 98.263
Beating their old record by exactly 1 point, X had a fantastic show. Also outlined by a speech, Teddy Roosevelt's speech about how credit doesn't go to the critic, but to the man in the arena, the one actually putting himself out there to critique and willing to risk failure. The ensemble is dressed as gladiators, the floor is a giant oval with black posts lining the outside. During the first battery break (which is barely audible to start off, incredible dynamics), the pit is doing pushups. Another section, a cymbal player is alone on the floor doing a one-handed pushup to show willingness to fail while daring greatly. The ballad is a choreographed partnered-up fight scene, complete with confetti throws as blood sprays on punches, all set in slow motion to a gorgeous slow piece by the pit, I believe Rachmaninoff. The closer, "Survival" by Muse, finishes strong with the loud falsetto note "Yes I'm gonna wiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiin!" which...they do. I think this show isn't as complete musically over Touch or Mantra, but as far as overall production, I think it packs a punch and entertainment the entire show, and has a more complete design.
It's hard to say which show is the BEST show in WGI history. There's shows like Inspired (Rhythm X 2010), Memento (RCC 2007 which is a guilty pleasure and got a 96.95), or even Pulse this year, that you could argue are better than these shows. But at that point, it then becomes preference, and is no better than a bunch of judges giving their opinion and we're back to square one.
If I had to make an order...
7. BK 1999
6. RCC 2005
5. RCC 2013
4. RCC 2012
3. X 2013
2. MCM 2011
1. X 2009
I just think you don't get much better than Touch.