Your Funeral My Trial (1986)
8/10
Sad Waters / The Carny / Your Funeral, My Trial / Stranger Than Kindness / Jack's Shadow / Hard On For Love / She Fell Away / Long Time Man / Scum
There are two different track-lists for this album, the original to which this review refers and another, less effective version. The reason I prefer this order, is that the three opening songs so effectively set the mood for this album, not to mention the fact that they are just three stellar songs. 'Sad Waters' is Nick's first real attempt at an original ballad, and remains one of his most beautiful, the gentle guitars create such a grand melancholic atmosphere that might lead you into thinking that this is going to be a much more sombre, affecting affair. The former quality is quite accurate, as the band do show a lot more restraint on this album; the instrumentation tends to be much more subtle and varied than on earlier releases. Nevertheless, Nick Cave is no less unhinged in his lyricism, as the following demented, carnival waltz, 'The Carny' demonstrates. Another classic, it's Nick at his lyrical best and perhaps the highlight of the whole album. It is followed by the softer title track, where Cave accompanies himself on Hammond organ, which lifts the mood of an otherwise, dark, brooding song.
After such a strong start, it is unfortunate that the band cannot sustain such a strong set of songs, although they do come quite close. Jack's Shadow and She Fell Away are wonderfully immediate, the former driven by aggressive guitars and harsh piano flourishes, while the latter makes use of racing tuned percussion juxtaposed by Nick's slowly grinding melodies. Equally brilliant is the added extra to the album, Scum, an exercise in hatred to a friend that Nick once had the displeasure of living with. I feel that this makes a far better, and somewhat more humorous ending to the album than the cover 'Long Time Man,' which while an excellent cover, is one of the less interesting tracks on the album.
Overall I feel that Your Funeral My Trial is a wonderful album and definitely a worthwhile listen. It finds the band evolving musically into a more mature, though by no means less interesting state. As a whole the album works beautifully; it is not as truly bleak as their earlier releases, it is a bit softer around the edges with its inclusion of more subtle melodies and of course, the ballads. Nevertheless, there is still a darkness to the album and in some ways, I feel like the clever, more subdued musical aesthetic the band are developed on this album is actually more harrowing than their more abrasive early work.
















