The second time around Padma was too horrified to recoil; instead she stared at Harry, her eyes going wide and her mouth hanging slightly open. She had expected him to be angry, yes, had expected him to dislike the idea – even to dislike it vehemently; she had heard several stories from her sister and Lavender about Harry losing his temper against Professor Umbridge – but she had still expected him to understand even if he didn’t like it. She certainly hadn’t expected him to be this furious. She might have lied if she had, left it to someone like Ginny or Seamus or Neville to explain how the D.A. operated – but she hadn’t thought it would be this hard. Harry had a temper, but he wasn’t stupid – ordinarily…
“Wh-what are you…?” Her voice trembled and she hated herself for it; swallowed hard, tried to steady herself, and failed. “That’s not what we’re doing at all! We are trying to keep people safe as best we can, and it’s been horrible, don’t you dare act like – like we’ve just been sitting around in comfort! Yes, we have been using the Unforigivables, because we haven’t been given a choice! Everyone from third year up has – and the younger kids are the ones we’ve been made to use them on! Do you have any idea what that’s like?” Her voice broke, but she kept talking through it; kept talking through the tears stinging her eyes. “We’ve been tortured, and been forced to torture, and there’s nothing we can do about it! If we refuse, we get d-dragged off to the Carrows’ offices for a private session – and as often as not, get Imperiused so we have to do it anyway but trapped inside our own heads watching!
“Have you ever been Imperiused, Harry? Have you ever used the Cruciatus Curse on someone? I have!” Her voice was turning into a shriek and she couldn’t stop herself; wasn’t sure she wanted to stop herself. She’d been quiet and sensible for so long that the chance to yell at someone was almost a relief, even as it made her guts twist and clench and her hands tremble. “I had to Crucio second years, Harry! Second years in my own house! When I got back to the common room that night and Sue Li and I went over to make sure they were okay, they cried when they saw us – cried! I’m their prefect, I’m supposed to help them, and the best I could do was to raise my wand myself because I know it hurts more when the Carrows make someone do it!”
She shook her head, as furious as she was heartbroken. “You have no idea what it’s been like, being here this year,” she told him brokenly. “D-don’t you judge me, don’t you dare – don’t you dare – tell me who I sound like!” Somehow she was on her feet too, inches from his face. She dashed a hand across her face to wipe away the tears that must be spilling from her eyes and was surprised to find her cheeks were dry; maybe she had none left. Glaring wetly at Harry, she continued, “I sound like somebody’s who had to do awful things not because the alternative is worse but because there isn’t an alternative! I’m not hexing other students because it makes my life easier, I’m doing it because there’s no way for any of us not to! Go on and ask Ginny or Neville or Seamus if you don’t believe me!” Maybe he’d understand if one of his friends, one of his fellow Gryffindors – so notoriously self-righteous, her sister’s house – said it to him. “They’ve done it too, it’s not just me! Third year and up, Harry – everybody third year and up has had to try the spells at least once, and those of us in our N.E.W.T. years have to do it regularly!”
Padma’s hands were balled into fists so tight that her nails cut sharply into her palms, but she hardly noticed. “The only choice I have is whether to fight back or not, and that actually is a choice! Parvati and I aren’t here for our own sake, you know; we don’t have to be! We chose to stick with the D.A. because it’s the right thing to do – but when you’re living in the enemy’s camp under the enemy’s rules you don’t have the luxury of clinging to high-minded ideals! You have to do the best you can with what you’ve got, and considering that what I’ve got involved trying to lead the Carrows away from your entrance yesterday even though if I got caught trying to trick them I’d be Crucio’ed for it, I think you could be a little more appreciative!”
The tears finally spilled, catching Padma by surprise; she’d gotten so upset she’d forgotten about them. “What have you been doing that’s so important then, huh? Because me, I volunteer to monitor detentions because it keeps the Carrows from just torturing everybody every time. I patrol the halls because if I catch someone, I can let them ‘off with a warning’ instead of reporting them for punishment. I help the Carrows because it’s the only way I can help anyone else! You think we’d make any kind of a difference if we resigned to make some stupid idealistic point?” She shook her head again, her braid slapping hollowly at her shoulder blades. “They’d just appoint someone else – someone they control, someone they trust – to take our places, and then what would we do, huh? Tell me, ‘Chosen One’ – what would we do then?”
He could recognize the way she looked at him. People had given him that very look throughout his entire fifth year here at school. She couldn’t believe he was saying this to her – was frightened of him. But Harry had decided long ago that he wouldn’t back down from the truth. That he’d do whatever it took to try and save as many people as he could. That meant fighting. He knew that his task was a quiet sort of battle they wouldn’t understand. But he’d never be able to get behind their claim of doing something good while also raising their wands to provide a detention they should’ve been revolting back against in the first place. If Harry were at this school, he would’ve refused. Over and over again. He would’ve died first.
His grip around the wand tightened even more when she mentioned the Unforgiveables and he had to force himself to keep it by his side. He wouldn’t hex her. It wouldn’t change anything – or help anything. “Then get Imperiused! At least it’s not you doing it with your own free will then!”
She was yelling back now, on her feet, tears in her eyes, and Harry felt little sympathy for her. Yes, he knew what it felt like experiencing all of them. In fact, he’s the only person alive to have ever felt all three of those curses. He knew it very well. And Padma’s words only sounded like empty excuses in his ears. He didn’t care what she had to say because, to me, there would be no justification great enough. “Yeah, I have Padma! All of them – I know what it’s like!” He glared at her, hard and furious. There was nothing akin to kindness or sorrow in his voice. “I tried to cast it – the cruciatus. On Bellatrix Lestrange last year. After Dumbledore. And I couldn’t then. I couldn’t mean it. And I wouldn’t be able to mean it on second years, either.”
More excuses. Like Dumbledore. Like too many other people that Harry knew. “Of course they were afraid of you, Padma! You’d just put them through unbearable pain! Oh, don’t give me that bullshit!” Harry rarely cursed at others. Always to himself when something went wrong or when he’d accidentally hurt himself. But he couldn’t control his words anymore. The rage having taken him to a place where he was hardly aware of what he said until it actually came out of his mouth. “Crucio hurts no matter who the castor is. If it worked on them, it meant that some part of you was willing to put your own neck before theirs!”
His heart sunk when she brought his friends into this. When she brought Ginny up. He didn’t know if he could believe that, but his brain was working too fast to stop and think about it. Because it didn’t really matter. All he knew is that the entire school was letting this happen. The people in this room – who had decided to start up his old group for revenge – were letting it happen. For the Greater Good, For the Greater Good, For the Greater Good… it never stopped. “Funny, considering they’ve all got bruises on their faces. Yours looks pretty clean to me.”
“There is always a choice, Padma. You can fight against them or with them, that’s the choice. And right now you’re just pretending like you’re doing the right thing when you just told me that you’ve use unforgiveables on second years, all because someone told you too!” Didn’t she see the hypocrisy. In this end, he too, could choose to back down from his destiny. If he did that, everyone he loved would die and Voldemort would win. His choice would never be any other than facing down Voldemort, than trying to beat him. Even if it killed Harry in the end. So he couldn’t believe her. His choice – it was barely a choice. Hers… well, she’d made it very clear what she decided to do.
He laughed, a bitter thing with no trace of humor. “You really think I’m going to thank you for something like that now? I would’ve, had you been what I thought you were.” Everyone – everyone would surprise him. No one was really who they said they were. Her brimming tears leaked over her face. In the past, Harry would panic when he saw a girl crying. Everything had changed. He stood firm, glaring, chin raised. “I’m on orders from Dumbledore – I’m doing something to take You-Know-Who down for good. I can’t tell you what I’ve been doing or what I’m here for. And, even if I could, I wouldn’t. I can’t trust you.”
What do we do? The never-ending question. One he didn’t have the answer to. “Does it matter?” He wasn’t yelling anymore and didn’t really know what it meant. His anger was solid and real and overtaking, but he was running out of steam arguing over this. Padma wasn’t going to change, she’d made that very clear. “It doesn’t matter what you’d do then because you’re not doing it now. You just… you just keep fighting. It’s the only way to show them – “ He pointed to the door, indicating the Carrows or Snape or maybe even Voldemort himself. “ – that they haven’t won. Isn’t that what this whole thing has been about?”