Do you think Severus was gay in canon? He's canonically very feminine and, while it's not a requirement for every adult character, most of the unmarried men in the series are blatantly in a blatantly homoeroctic friendship which Severus notably lacks. It would have been something he kept under wraps for a variety of reasons - growing up in the 60's, under a (at best) strictly masculine father, status as part of Lucius's inner circle and as a teacher at a cushy private school with parents that would certainly be breathing down his neck, a general distrust of others, and seeing love as 'irrelevant' to his mission.
Do you think in an AU where he lives through the war he would be able to find a partner?
I don’t think there’s anything in canon that confirms Severus as gay, and honestly, when a character doesn’t have a partner, I think it’s perfectly valid to leave it open to individual interpretation. I always say that a character who canonically has no partners or clear romantic interests is bisexual until proven otherwise, so to speak. At the end of the day, nothing is established, so everyone can interpret it however they want.
What is very clear in canon is that Severus is emotionally repressed, socially isolated, and deeply uncomfortable with vulnerability and intimacy in general, so the absence of relationships—romantic or otherwise—can be explained without necessarily tying it to his sexuality. That said, your point about him not participating in the kind of intense male friendships that are very present elsewhere in the series is actually interesting, because it highlights how separate he is from those dynamics rather than part of them. He’s not just outside heteronormative romance, he’s also outside male bonding structures, which makes him feel even more disconnected. In any case, this isn’t necessarily tied to sexuality, but more likely to the fact that the abusive figures in his life were men who embodied very heteronormative dynamics and traditional masculine standards of behavior and aggression. So his rejection of those bonds can be read more as a refusal to engage in relationships that remind him of harmful masculine models than as something rooted in sexual orientation.
As for the “feminine” aspect, I’d be a bit careful there, because a lot of what gets coded as feminine in fandom discussions can also just be traits of someone who is traumatized, withdrawn, and hyper-controlled. Severus doesn’t really perform gender in a socially legible way at all; he’s kind of stripped down to function, bitterness, and obsession. And even if we do read him as more feminine than masculine, that reading is based on social standards imposed by patriarchal dynamics. The masculine/feminine divide comes from differential socialization within a patriarchal binary. So if Severus doesn’t fit traditional masculine standards, it simply means he doesn’t fit an imposed model of masculinity that is often tied to toxic stereotypes. But not fitting that model doesn’t make someone gay, just like fitting it doesn’t make someone straight. Sexuality has nothing to do with gender performance, and conflating the two is problematic because it implies that, in men, sexual preference defines their core personality, which in turn ends up excusing harmful behaviors in men who perform traditional masculinity. And yeah, no.
Now, could he be gay? Sure, why not. As a headcanon it works, especially if you frame it within repression and internalized shame given the time period and his environment. But I don’t think canon gives us enough to say that’s what Rowling intended, more that he’s written in a way that’s open to projection because of how closed-off he is. And it’s also open to interpretation simply because, as I said, he never has a canonical partner, so it naturally lends itself to speculation and free pairing. Personally, I think he’s a character who works with both men and women depending on the angle you want to give the story; again, bisexual until proven otherwise.
That said, the partner topic. I’m going to go off here a bit because there’s a lot to unpack, and honestly it could be a separate answer because it’s kind of a different subject, but anyway.
If Severus were to find a partner in a post-war AU, it wouldn’t look anything like a conventional romance, at least not at first. It would have to begin in a space where he doesn’t feel observed or expected to perform emotionally, because the moment something feels like a demand—affection, openness, vulnerability—his instinct would be to withdraw. So whatever connection develops would likely start almost accidentally, in a context where proximity is natural and doesn’t immediately carry emotional weight. I’ve also always thought he would feel much more comfortable if that person had little or nothing to do with British wizarding society, because there he has a name, a reputation, but above all a very heavy past, and I think he would feel much freer if the person he connects with either knows nothing about that or comes from a context where it simply doesn’t matter. Guilt is one of Severus’s biggest conflicts and one of the things that binds him and prevents him from moving forward, so someone who constantly reminds him of the source of that guilt would only make things worse. Someone external would be far more suitable.
What makes it difficult is that Severus doesn’t just struggle with intimacy, he actively mistrusts it. For most of his life, attachment has led to pain, humiliation, or loss, so he’s built an entire internal system around control and self-containment. Letting someone in wouldn’t feel like something positive at first, it would feel like a liability, like introducing a variable he cannot fully manage. So the person who ends up close to him would have to understand that what looks like coldness or indifference is actually a form of self-protection, not a lack of feeling. They’d need to be able to exist near him without constantly trying to decode or fix him, and this is actually really important. In a lot of fics there’s this “let’s fix Severus because he needs help” dynamic, and while it’s true he needs help, he doesn’t need to be fixed. What he needs is someone who understands that he carries a lot of wounds and accepts him as he is, without trying to manage him or pull him toward some ideal version of himself. They don’t need to accept him despite his darkness, but because of it. And they need to understand that Severus likely has a very avoidant attachment style, so he’ll constantly avoid, hide, or repress his emotions. Every time it seems like he’s opening up, he’ll close off again; when he gets overwhelmed, he’ll probably lash out in ways that are difficult to deal with because he tends toward emotional dysregulation when something hits too close. He wouldn’t be easy. So a partner would need both the strength of character to stand their ground, call him out when necessary, and metaphorically send him to his room to think about his behavior, and the emotional intelligence to understand where all of that comes from. I also think it would help if that person had their own history of trauma, because that shared darkness can create a stronger bond, but unlike him, they’d need to have worked through it to some extent, to balance things out.
At the same time, the relationship would have to operate on an unspoken understanding that Severus will never be emotionally demonstrative in a conventional way. His way of caring would be indirect, practical, and tied to protection or usefulness, making sure the other person is safe, anticipating their needs, maybe even quietly removing obstacles from their life. It wouldn’t look like obvious affection, but it would be consistent, deliberate, and very hard for him to withdraw once established. That said, I do think he would need someone more emotionally open, someone expressive who can verbalize feelings and provide consistent validation. Deep down he’d likely feel very insecure, and even if he’d never admit it, he would need that emotional reinforcement. So the other person would have to be vocal about how they feel, while also not needing that same level of verbal expression in return, someone who values acts of service over words.
The real turning point would come when he stops framing the relationship as something temporary or conditional, something that exists only as long as it doesn’t interfere with his sense of control or his self-imposed idea of penance. For someone like Severus, allowing a relationship to matter is the most dangerous step, because it means accepting the possibility of loss again. So if he ever reaches a point where he no longer feels the need to keep one foot out the door, where he allows himself to exist in that connection without constantly anticipating its end, that’s when it becomes something real. It wouldn’t be an easy relationship, and he would need someone extremely compatible, not in terms of hobbies or tastes, but compatible with his issues. It doesn’t matter whether their personalities are similar or different; what matters is that their wounds align in a way that allows mutual understanding. If someone has no wounds, they won’t understand him; if they’re too superficial, they won’t be enough; if they’re deep but incompatible, it won’t work either. And he would never make the first move, the other person would have to. They might even have to pursue him for a while, because he’d almost certainly push them away more than once. His temperament isn’t easy, so what would suit him best is someone with a strong temperament as well, because strong temperaments tend to regulate each other.
theartofmadeline
areudirty
gamechangershow
romaincrisis
