So I recently went to go look at the super Mario rpg wiki on the wishes, which included both base game and post game (plus any wishes that change throughout the story/post game)
as per usual with me, I wanted to go to read Johnnys wish. Now his wishes are both connected to Mario, even if it’s not by name.
the first wish was him wishing for a heated duel (“I’m itching for a heated duel!”) and this duel would be with Mario, and Mario only. Johnnys boss fights is unique in the regard that unlike most the bosses in the post game there is really no gimmick besides the fact it’s a one on one. Johnnys fighting style relies purely on raw strength.
Now for his second wish which was for that guy to win his fight against smithy (“I hope that guy wins his corker of a fight with the Smithy creature!”) corker, from my research and for those curious, seems to typically mean striking or exciting but can also mean something that settles or closed an argument. Basically, Johnny wishing Mario will be the one who closes the fight between him and his team vs the smithy gang. As for which I think it is, I think it could be used in either context. Johnny is rather battle hearty so a fight like this would be striking but also he would want the guy who literally made him feel the flames of combat to win.
and how do I know he is talking about Mario in his wishes? Well the first ones more open, he could be wishing to fight anyone but given the story events and how he has been waiting for Mario to show up I’m gonna assume he is talking about him. For his second wish, if you go to the wiki page, and click the ‘this guy’ bit of his dialogue, it takes you to Mario’s wiki page.
Now, why am I talking about it? Well, I just wanted too mostly, but I am also fascinated. This is the only wish in the game that actually acknowledges smithy, the closet I can think off is Mallows parents wishing for him to restore starway but they don’t mention Smithy. It makes sense Johnny would mention him as he actually came into contact with a Smithy gang member (Yaridovich/Speardovich) which is actually very uncommon in this game for someone outside the party to come face to face with someone from the Smithy gang.
Speaking of uncommon, it’s not often a wish is about someone else in particular. Mallows parents make their wishes about Mallow coming home and then fix starway, Luigi wishes to help out Mario, Jinx does mention Mario in one of his wishes as ‘our new master’ but then wishes for a new student. Johnny also makes a wish in regards to Mario, the two I’ve rambled about.
It truly does fascinate me how much Mario, a man Johnny had first underestimated, made such a huge impact on him all due to a shared love of combat. How he wished for Mario to defeat Smithy, which gets interesting when you acknowledge that when you beat Smithy,Mario wakes up in bed again as if it was a dream. Johnnys wishes aren’t ever for himself in a way, his wish is tied to Mario:
he wishes for a heated duel, his wish to fight Mario again so much so while he waited his heart had a metaphorical whirlpool within it that sucked all the joy away, how after he is beaten he wishes for Mario to win what could be considered an impossible fight given how no matter how much you fight Smithy you will never have the seventh star in your save file.
Johnny and Mario’s relationship fascinates me so much as a writer, dare I say it almost seems like Mario is a muse to him when it comes to fighting especially when he doesn’t expect much from him upon first glance.
Final thoughts: Jonario is cool but also I acknowledge how this may sound like I’m reaching or overthinking things which jokes on you that’s how I spend all of my time. I love analysing things, especially things I enjoy. If Johnny and Mario have wormed themselves into my brain I may as well have fun with it. also no I really can’t go five minutes without thinking about how Johnny telling Mario that he felt as if the joy was sucked away from his heart and then getting that joy back by fighting him/j












