Natsu x Lucy Fanfiction Gems
A continued list of my favorite stories that keep piling up.
Notes:
-More current updated ones are at the top of the list
-Only one story per author
-Sexual content in some stories
-Stories from FF.net are first, followed by the stories from A03
Happy Reading!
-FF.net stories-
Bound in Blood (M) by xambedo
When tragedy unseals a demon beneath the soil of Fairy Hills, Lucy Heartfilia is offered a choice: remain and be buried alive, or bargain to save her classmates. Seven years later, Natsu is here to collect, but he’s about to get more than he bargained for. / NaLu / Romance - Supernatural - Humour
Capturing Her Damaged Heart (M) by mushi0131
A deadly disease plagues the world. People are dying, the dead are rising. The infection spreads too fast to stop. Everyone tries their best to survive in this post-apocalyptic world, but things get messy for Natsu when he finds a blonde woman on one of his missions. Natsu takes it upon himself to help her, protect her, and accidentally fall in love with her? Zombie Apocalypse AU.
Til Death Do Us Part (M) by superfreakerz
Immortal/Reincarnation AU. There are immortals and there are those who reincarnate, though it’s best to keep these things hidden. Lucy is attending college and meets Natsu, a mischievous boy with pink hair, a devilish smile, and a body that never ages.
Dauntless (M) by HungryPeanut
The Royal Military College was founded a few centuries ago and the traditional laws that were instaured at the time still remained. One of those laws stipulating clearly that only male students were allowed to apply for the formation. But here Lucy was, standing among the other recruits in the ranks, dressed as a man.
Do it for him, Do it for her (T) by schmad20
Lucy goes on with her mission, “without” any one else. She wants to help her client and while doing that she’ll prove to others what she’s capable of! She’s doing it for herself…and for him… While she’s off on her mission, Natsu is waiting restlessly at home. Waiting for her to come home. He knows how much this means to her… So he’s doing it for her…
Walk through the fire (T) by elssiie
Strategist and priestess Lucy Heartfilia gets caught up in the turmoil of war. Torn between duty and love she must decide whether to follow her heart or mind because the destiny of two nations rests on her shoulders.
Implexium Vitae (M) by notjustanyfangrl
It is said that some people have old souls, reborn every couple centuries to find their loved ones again and continue on their never ending journey. But what happens to these intersecting lives when one is immortal and the other is ripped from them? Vampire AU.
Falling into Home (T) by selenityshiroi
Post-canon. Lucy finds it difficult to let certain horrors from the war go but, fortunately, her team mates are having the same struggle and they can work past it together.
Her Master (M) by Letting go of Fate
Neither of them remembered how it all started. How their innocent friendship twisted into something like this. She loved it. He craved it. He was her Master and she, his pet.
Stars that Bite (T) by MizzyPlatinum
AU in which Lucy feeds off of blood and refuses to drink Natsu’s, but what happens when Natsu finds out that he’s the only one she refuses to feed from? NaLu. OneShot. Fluff. Blood trigger.
Dark Side of You (M) by Binky1987
Post Manga/Anime, therefore sort of AU. The progress of Lucy and Natsu’s relationship, five years after the war. When finally their relationship is becoming defined, the world turns ugly and they have to choose a side. With Lucy’s life on the line the choice is clear, the world be damned because you can’t take his things and live to tell about it.
One Week of Danger (T) by Cervella
“Okay, Miss Mystic.” Lucy stood up and held the magazine which she would flush down the drain later above her head. Plue imitated her totally heroic pose and she was dead serious when she yelled,“In the next week I will prove that your horoscope is completely wrong!”
Desire In Strawberries (M) by shelbyshoe
Natsu and Lucy are swept away by a festival held by their wealthy client, Lady Nakahara. There is more than mystery and the scent of strawberries in the air as they find themselves intimately closer to one another. What they thought was a friendly feast turns into something more as the puzzling night goes on.
Letter’s To Mom (T) by ElementalMiko12
Going back to the place they first met after Lucy reveals an unkept promise she made to her mother; Natsu takes her to keep that promise… In the process Lucy’s deceased mother decides to keep a promise of her own she made long ago. (Complete)
The Simplest Gift (A Valentine’s Day Special) (T) by ladyoflitany A Valentine’s Day one shot, involving Natsu, Lucy unspoken feelings and Valentine’s gifts. Throw in a meddling Mira, Natsu misunderstanding the idea of Valentine’s and Lucy’s missing fan mail and problems and Hilarity ensue…
Brightside (K+) by stopnatsu Natsu loves Lucy. Lucy is on a date. Natsu gets roaring drunk and drama ensues. Oneshot. Angst/fluffy. (May or may not be heavily inspired by Mr. Brightside by The Killers).
The Lacrima Wish (T) by LucyLacrima
In the midst of a battle with Natsu, Lucy stumbles upon a cursed tree and something is released. She is given the opportunity to make one wish, with no limitations, and is given a Lacrima. The Lacrima allows her to see the repercussions of each potential wish. She tests different futures while watching her guild’s future unfold.
Thirty Days of Misadventures (T) by MagiLiv Imagine waking one morning in one world, sleeping, then waking in another. Different lives, different scenarios- together, Natsu and Lucy venture through the trials of laughter, anger, sadness and love.
A Big Problem (T) by Jayalek
How is Lucy supposed to live her life normally when an overgrown lizard won’t leave her alone? Of all the things to be obsessed with her, it just had to be a dragon who won’t give her some peace and quiet. NALU! Dragonized!Natsu
Just Kiss! (T) by WhiteRose123
Even when Lucy is feeling at her worst, Natsu is always there to try to cheer her up. NaLu. Oneshot.
Strawberry Heaven (K+) by PrinceCharmingsPrincess
Oneshot: A NaLu lost moment… Ranges after the Games.
It started with a kiss (M) by Eugenee
Natsu comes home from a mission to find the guild in full swing and in the middle is his worst nightmare… a drunk Lucy.
Priorities (K+) by PEANUT v1.2
“Moving forward is what Fairy Tail mages do, isn’t it?” Lucy says to Natsu. Yesterday he would have agreed immediately, but that was before catastrophe struck. How can he move forward after his mistake? Nalu friendship/romance oneshot.
Switched (T) by SyberSweetHeart
Once again the lives of Fairy Tail mages are interrupted- but the problem is Lucy and Natsu have switched bodies! Oh boy, this is bound to cause problems…
Exceedingly Adorable (K+) by Sweet Little Demon
A magical mishap happens in the middle of a battle, leaving Lucy fluffier and more adorable than ever. Humor, Fluff, adorableness, cuddliness, master planning and envy guaranteed.
Are You My Daddy? (T) by BlackLynx17 It was just a normal day at Fairy Tail… that is until a little girl is carried in claiming to be Lucy’s daughter. The only thing she remembers about her Father is that he’s strong and has a fairy on his body, that narrows it down to every male in Fairy Tail… hold on she said strong, maybe about half the males then. What’s Fairy Tail to do now?
-A03 stories-
Flame’s Desire (M) by Rougescribe
As the last of her tribe, Lucy barely escapes the grasp of slavers and falls into the hands of a man as wild as the flames that destroyed her clan. She’s been given a second chance with her life, but why does her savior awaken a fire in her blood she’s never known before?
Of Dragons and Gods (T) by Gemini888
Lucy Heartfilia: Fairy Tail’s resident Celestial Spirit Mage who is currently in love with the Guild’s own Fire Dragon Slayer.
Natsu Dragneel: One of Fairy Tail’s aces; a powerhouse Mage that is more than conflicted and confused about his feelings for Lucy.
Suberashi: A ancient, powerful, and fabled Guild straight from legends. Only, now, it’s no longer fabled, nor does ‘just a children’s fairy tale’ quite fit the reality of their sudden presence.
With Natsu unintentionally hurting Lucy emotionally and with Suberashi’s sudden interest in her, will she leave Fairy Tail and accept their offer to give her the powers of a ‘God.’
A Fever in the Night (G) by starmini
Coming back from a mission, Lucy collapses in the the middle of a forest with a dangerously high fever. Natsu sends Happy to bring back help, as he desperately tries to keep her alive.
Heaven Sent: A Fairy Tail Fairy Tale (G) by joliemariella
Natsu Dragneel is the infamous ‘Dragon Prince’ who rules Fiore with the assistance of his carefully chosen council. His life is changed forever, though, when his dear friend Happy, is struck by an incurable disease. Desperate, he turns to the ancient fairy tales that tell of the Celestial Maidens, whose robes hold the power to do anything a determined man might set his mind to…
Starcrossed (G) by wisdomofme
Bonus Prompt 1 of FT Angst Week: Ever After/ Perfect Disaster Once upon a time there lived a star that had seen it all, and boy who could see the stars… Who would’ve thought that their paths would cross?
what’s the big deal? (Explicit) by julamei
Natsu’s sexual awakening is… clumsy and awkward, obviously. The poor boy has purposefully remained ignorant of these more mundane, human miracles. that is, until something happens he can’t ignore and things between him and Lucy being to grow. Here is my headcannon on their journey around the bases (hopefully this reflects more our own experiences than just our need for fulfillment for these characters).
Hunter (M) by Freyjabee (No longer available?)
Natsu and Lucy follow some dangerous hunters into a city housing sin. While one is desperate to leave, the other can’t help but stay.
A Lesson for Natsu (M) by aeotae
Despite the injustice of it all, the men of Fairy Tail endeavor to prepare Natsu for his new manly duty as Lucy’s boyfriend.
I have a lot more so let me know if anyone wants more recommendations.
