They consider themself an Indie/Alternative/Folk Punk/Emo band and they first performed in June 2011.
From Holbrook (NY) The Real Whitaker Todd already released three EPs, a single and a full length with very interesting sounds from acoustic to rough punk passing through all directions.
Suburban Ballet also sees many collaborations with several local artists, something that sure helped the band being known.
When did it all start and how?
Tommy: The Real Whitaker Todd started right after the breakup of my old band back in 2011. I knew I still wanted to make songs. I wrote lyrics for the old band, but never music so trying to do the latter for the first time was difficult. Jon and I got together about six months later and recorded the Illustrious EP over the next couple of months.
Jon: Yeah, I was a senior in a little recording school and Tommy and I were friends on Tumblr and he messaged me, I said yes, I had no idea what I was recording, but I was down.
Nick: I think that’s a loaded question, in that I feel as though “The Real Whitaker Todd” didn’t so much start, but rather evolved. Tommy performed as a solo act under the moniker. I was pursuing (and still am pursuing) a modest solo venture when Tommy asked me to provide some of my vocals and instrumentation to his records… Well, it was a no brainer, and I was just thrilled to be recording with one of my best friends and just a like minded friend who I connected with musically from day one of us working/jamming together. I met Jon the producer, and we all sort of clicked. Tommy simultaneously asked Jon and I to become full members of the now band, collective, what have you. We were happy to come aboard. Although in my opinion a phenomenal guitarist, Jon Clarke came on as our bassist. And we have just added Matt from local favorites Best Left Unsaid. I believe the band will continue to evolve.
Who is Whitaker Todd?
Tommy: That’s actually a joke, in a sense. I used to write a lot of short pieces of fiction and there were several stories that contained a character called Whitaker Todd who was largely based on me. However, those stories were all awful and never saw the light of day, so calling myself (when the band was originally just me) The Real Whitaker Todd was kind of a joke since no one knew who the fake one was to begin with.
Did you attend any particular music school or course to learn how to play instruments? How many instruments do you play?
Tommy: I took guitar lessons for about two years, but that’s about it. Besides guitar, I play a little bit of ukulele (but not much since Nick’s always borrowing it haha) and I know a few chords on piano. I would definitely be open to learning more piano stuff since I’ve always wanted to learn how to play.
Jon: I do go to a music school, but I’m focused in Sound Recording. I use a lot of music theory for the bass parts (especially in Hamartia) and I kinda use it for the lead guitar parts. I help Nick with some keyboard parts too, just some triad inversions and stuff. I learned guitar through a teacher for about 2 years and then decided to learn on my own from there.
Nick: My Aunte Jannete, just about the sweetest woman on the planet, is a classical piano teacher. I played by ear and once I was learning classical peices, I could fill in the blanks, so to speak, and put the peices together. I taught myself all of the most common and more advanced chords and scales. However I rely heavily on improvisation and my musical ear, of which I am extremely grateful, and evidently Jon, Jon knows theory. I prefer 1 part theory 3 parts winging it, and seeing what comes out!
Did the lineup change much since the first EP?
Tommy: Absolutely. Until we recorded Hamartia, The Real Whitaker Todd was just me on vocals/guitar with Jon doing the engineering plus whoever felt like helping out, but now we’ve got an official lineup with Jon on bass and Nick on keyboards as well as vocals and we just recruited a drummer as well, as Nick said earlier.
Jon: It has definitely been a weird band in the past. But now we actually have members, and I’m not just the recording engineer behind it all.
How do you work when creating a song? And what about a whole album?
Tommy: Up until now, I would write the entire song (music and lyrics) myself and bring it to the others as a finished product. Then, they would write their own parts using mine as reference. But now that we’re an official band, I hope to do a lot more writing together when I get home from school as opposed to separately.
Jon: After Tommy is finished writing them, he sends me demos and I start to construct “Pseudo Songs” which is basically programmed-drums, scratch track worthy guitar and bass parts. No vocals. This then goes back and forth. We did this for Hamartia and it made the recording and writing process a lot easier and cleaner. I’m terrible at writing, but I can create around something that had be previously written.
Nick: The way I write music is different then the other members. For the most part I have been given chords, and sometimes listened to the “garage band” psuedo track but really, I just get my own feel for the structure, and write an arrangement, weather it be piano, organ, or most recently on Hamartia, synth!! I just do my own thing, which is really the only way I operate at 110% is to be left to my devices. I am truly grateful for not being in a band of music Nazis and rather some awesome dudes that can take and give great constructive criticisms and really let me have a little bit of free range creatively. It’s collaborative and it's loose, and it's just sort of a think tank of “hmm maybe this would sound cool,” ultimately boiling down to Tommy’s brainchild. But obviously he likes the stuff we do, as we are still around! haha!
Who are your personal music influences?
Tommy: Bright Eyes, the Wonder Years, Pink Floyd, and Neutral Milk Hotel. Plus, any of the local bands we’ve watched/performed with like Best Left Unsaid, We Take Fire, Monster Band etc. I look up to.
Jon: For bass I look at bands like Rancid, Wilco, and Deerhunter. For guitar, I think it’s mostly Wilco and just old school 80’s hardcore punk.
Nick: Jackson Browne, Conor Oberst, and Taylor Goldsmith
I personally took one of Tommy’s poems I really love and turned it into a music piece (if I may call it music). Do you consider poems and songs to be related or to be two completely different things?
Tommy: For me, it depends. A lot of the lyrics from Suburban Ballet come from poems I’d already written so I would say that they’re pretty interchangeable.
How much the events of your personal life influence your music?
Tommy: Every song I write is very personal. Every song on Illustrious was about a girl I liked for a very long time while Suburban Ballet drew from various aspects of me and my friends’ personal lives while entering adulthood. Hamartia is the sequel to that, and I think the main message of that record is just trying to make the best of a life that can sometimes be kind of shitty.
What do you really want to convey through your music?
Tommy: It’s about making a connection; I want people that feel the same way I do to know that they aren’t alone.
What is your advice to anyone who wishes to start a band or any music project?
Tommy: Be real. Like, for example, don’t write love songs if you’ve never had feelings for someone before. You need to be honest with yourself and with your audience because in reality, there is no better way in getting the message that you want to get across to people. And don’t do it to get famous; it takes the purity in creativity right out if the wrong motives are there. However, there is nothing wrong with wanting people to hear and enjoy your music.
Jon: Expect nothing. There are a lot of times when your hopes will come down and it’s better to be prepared than to be begging from forgiveness from the “industry”. And also knowing what you’re playing is great; I cannot tell you how many times I have to ask Tommy what his songs mean so I can play them better.
Nick: I agree with Tommy wholeheartedly in that you need to be genuine in your efforts, explore all the different musical avenues you’d like. I’m certainly eclectic, but you can have all sorts of fancy furniture but there has to be steel in the walls. And what I mean is that your core beliefs and the heart of what you write, should always come from an honest place whether it be personal account, or exploring different perspectives. You should stay true to what it is that you hold dear and don’t get up on the soap box unless you really feel like you have something to say. I could think of a certain subject, and nothing. Or think of another,and in 35 minutes, I have two verses a chorus and bridge all of which have words that I will stand behind in any crowd. I’ve always admired Jackson Browne, Conor Oberst of Bright Eyes, and Taylor Goldsmith as a colossal influence of mine. Hero worship isn’t healthy (as we learned from SpongeBob) and you should go your own path, but having someone your admire so purely, to me, can do nothing but help the creative process.
With their recently released EP titeld Hamartia, you can find The Real Whitaker Todd on facebook, soundcloud, Tommy's youtube channel and bandcamp where you can buy their records naming your own price!