glad that weāre talking about Alison Bechdel being a terf again. really hoping that fact breaks into the general cultural zeitgeist this time but not holding my breath
because trans girls are starting to talk about this again, it isnāt going to be long before a bunch of TME people come in like āum, if Allison Bechdel is a terf how come she said this nice thing about trans women in the 90s? checkmate you hysterical trannyā with a few examples of Bechdel being mildly supportive of trans peopleās right to exist, but make no mistake ā Bechdel keeps close company with self described terfs and has done basically forever; Adrienne Rich is pretty much her idol & the basis of her understanding of feminism, and she actively attended Michfest for absolutely years and years whilst they were excluding trans women and even whilst Camp Trans protested right outside, and even in her most recent book she talks about it as this magical place that was free of men rather than the symbol of transmisogynistic hate & violence it has been recognised as for years. Some of the trans storylines in DTWOF are actively transphobic imho, and the Dykes To Watch Out For website (also Bechdelās blog) is still to this day filled to the fucking brim with blatant terf dogwhistles including referring to the trans girl character as ātrans identifiedā in her bio.
People have to stop falling for ābut they said nice things about trans peopleā¦ā stuff. Some bigots are still polite enough to refer to trans people by the correct pronouns & think we deserve some basic respects in society/to be free from violence, but still fundamentally are bigots with transphobic ideas about gender. it is desperately important that we do not let transmisogyny go unrecognised and i acknowledged within the feminism movement.
As a follow up note, in addition to the transmisogyny she has also at times blatantly misgendered trans men as well. When I was a college student, UChicago hosted an exhibit of some photography she had done around the theme of butchness. And at the end of the lineup of photos there was a note that said something like āSome of the people in these photos actually prefer he/him pronouns and identify as men, but for the sake of consistency and centering butches I am just going use she/her for them all.ā This was around somewhere between 2011 and 2014. So she fails even at ācalling trans ppl the right pronounsā in some cases too
thatās legitimately stomach/churningly disgusting
iām going a little bit crazy how many people iām seeing reblog this now that thereās something about trans men specifically, after those same people ignored transfems for years when we were telling people sheās a terf who went to michfest and kept rank with Adrienne Rich & her supporters. itās almost like you donāt actually give a fuck about transmisogyny unless it also effects men
I am once again linking Hal Schrieve's review of Alison's new book, Spent, which circles back to revisit some of her classic Dykes To Watch Out For characters.
Hal clearly has a good opinion of Alison, but even ze is startled to find that Alison completely disappears her transfem character, Janis. Several other characters vanish, too, most of them women of color, and Alison spends a good chunk of the book sympathizing with MAGA fascists and doing a whole "they're not so bad! They're just misguided!" thing about them. She truly needs to be retired from the lesbian writing lexicon, like, yesterday.
















