Requested Review: Memrise Korean
I received an ask requesting I check out the Memrise Korean course, so today I’m happy to bring you guys a review of their set up. :)
For those of you unfamiliar with Memrise, it’s a website (with iOS and Android app equivalents) that teaches mostly languages--though other topics can be found--using memory exercises and “gamification” to make learning fun. Memrise employs the use of mnemonics or “mems” to help the user learn and memorize words and phrases. In simpler terms, it’s just another SRS (spaced repetition software) program. There are no ads and all courses are free to use, but the user does have the option of upgrading to a “pro” account in order to access some specialized features. In addition to the official Memrise designed/curated courses, users can create their own courses/lists/mems for any topic they’d like. The official website is here: https://www.memrise.com/
This review is of the course as presented through the iOS app.
I actually quite like Memrise as a SRS program. I've had a pro account for years and I made use of the ability to create your own courses and use other users’ courses quite heavily. However, before today I never actually took a look at any of the official Memrise created language courses.
The description for the official Memrise Korean 1 course is as follows:
Part 1 of the complete and inspirational mission to Memrise Korean. Learn to read the Korean script - perhaps the most perfectly satisfying writing system ever devised. Introduce yourself in Korean, get around Korea, and learn a bunch of useful colloquial Korean expressions to make people smile!
So I knew very well going into this that the course is not designed at all to teach you actual Korean grammar and how to use it. This course is to teach you vocabulary and useful phrases.
This is readily apparent once you get to the level selection screen. Curious, I clicked on a random level just to check and:
Starting from the beginning though the course begins by teaching the user Hangul. They use romanization, of course, but in conjunction with both a male and female speaker to do all of the audio. This is a good thing--I find that courses with audio generally have either a male or female voice, not both. Being able to hear the differences when using the same words/phrases is definitely a good thing. The other thing that struck me as odd with the course was the order in which they choose to teach the letters to the learner. Generally courses with start with either basic vowels that move into alphabetical order consonants, or they simply start with the letters in alphabetical order. There’s nothing wrong with learning the letters in any order you’d like (and I have yet to meet more than a handful of foreigners who actually know Korean alphabetical order off the top of their heads), I just found it strange that of all things, they chose to lead with the letter ㄹ.
But besides the audio, the way the course is designed around teaching Hangul isn’t that great. There’s no explanation that the letters are letters or how to put them together to form words. There’s no indication about needing to use ㅇ for singular vowels. In fact, the vowels are introduced on their own (eg: ㅏ, ㅗ, ㅡ, etc, without the null entirely). This is particularly frustrating as one of the first actual words the course teaches is “예”, immediately following the letter “ㅖ” and there’s a confusing muddle for a couple audio questions where the learner is asked for the meaning of “예” but the multiple choice answers contained both “예” and “ㅖ” so one was left to guess which one the audio was referencing.
As far as the course exercises go they’re pretty standard. There’s many different types of multiple choice questions including audio ones, but the exercise that stood out to me the most was the video audio questions:
Different native speakers come up in these videos and say a word or phrase, which the user then has to select from the options below (either in English, or Korean, depending on the exercise). This is great because it really gets the learner listening to various voices of people of different genders and ages. Varying the input means the learner gets used to the different ways people talk much faster.
The exercise I liked the least was the “fill in the blank” questions. I generally use Memrise on my computer, where the fill in the blank questions require the keyboard and are timed with a short countdown for the user to fill in the answer before it’s automatically marked wrong. This I feel is much better than the fill in the blank questions on the app:
On the app, the user is presented with preset keys to select the answer from. This isn’t the greatest because it becomes too easy for the user to rely on sight recognition instead of active recall--filling in the blank yourself helps you remember the answer better than just selecting it from a list of preset choices like this. There is an option to switch to the keyboard, but it’s way up at the top of the screen on the upper right and I can’t imagine a whole lot of people will be looking up there when the question and the answers are at the bottom of the screen.
After learning Hangul and some short phrases, I was introduced to my first important grammar point: the sentence particles -은/는. The app handled that pretty much exactly as I expected--with no explanation:
But Memrise isn’t designed to teach grammar and usage. Memrise is designed to teach you vocabulary words and everyday useful phrases. So I can’t exactly fault them for it.
My last point is actually a very important one: Memrise’s course doesn’t make distinctions for politeness levels of the words and phrases it teaches. For example all the phrases I was taught were in the informal-polite (verb/adjective conjugations ending with -요) but the first word it teaches for “I” is “나”, which is informal. And perhaps the biggest issue with the entire course: it teaches the user the word “당신” for the pronoun “you”. Don’t use 당신 when speaking to other people unless you want to offend them. There are times when using 당신 is appropriate, but just avoid using it if at all possible.
So to sum: Memrise’s course is not going to teach you Korean grammar, or how to speak Korean. It will do a poor job of teaching you Hangul, however it will do a better job of teaching you words and (reasonably) useful phrases but only if you already know enough Korean grammar to weed out the mistakes/faux pas contained therein.
If you want to learn grammar and how to actually use Korean instead of parroting sentences, check out an app like Lingodeer, or a coursebook like Korean Grammar in Use.
If you’re a beginner and want to learn more words in conjunction with your other learning, you can definitely use Memrise, but I would recommend finding a “Level 1″ course for one of the more popular Korean universities (Ehwa, Sogang, Yonsei, etc) and start learning vocab there as it’ll be geared more towards a beginners level.
If you’re a high beginner/lower intermediate learner I would recommend a course based on Korean word frequency lists, such as this one: https://www.memrise.com/course/1614/1000-most-common-korean-words/
There are also a number of user made courses on Memrise for idioms, slang, and so on for users of higher capabilities. :) So definitely check those out!
That’s it for this review! If you have any questions or want me to review something else, send me an ask!