Troy Story: What were they going for?
I was thinking about the godawful Troy movie starring Bradd Pitt today. Thankfully, that in turn, made me think of the Iliad (and Odyssey)
And I had a question. Were they trying to add dislikable protagonists?
Why did that first battle happen, where the Greeks accidentally attacked Mysia instead of Troy?
I read this version where Thetis warns Achilles about killing demigods, and gives him a servant who can see demigods for what they are. Achilles kills one when the servant isn't around, then blames (and executes) the servant for failing his duty. Wtf, hero!?
The whole situation with Iphegenia is bad all around.
Odysseus is the one to propose the suitors' oath, but feigns madness when (shocker) it's time to honor it.
When he finally returns to Ithaca, he hangs all the servant girls who served the suitors.
Agamemnon is a dick, through and through... though I suppose most tyrants are... (in Age of Mythology we have a humorous detail where Agamemnon has no weapon "because he lost his spear somewhere along the way, so he pummels things with his fists". This never fails to make me laugh)
I'm not able to think up more right now, but I remember so much stuff like this. Many of the heroes do a lot more bad than good.
What were they going for? Realism? Was it a warped, myth-laden version of what happened?