🇱🇮🇹🇹🇱🇪 🇸🇮🇸🇹🇪🇷, 🇩🇴🇳❜🇹 🇾🇴🇺 🇩🇴 🇼🇭🇦🇹 🇾🇴🇺🇷 🇧🇮🇬 🇸🇮🇸🇹🇪🇷 🇩🇴🇪🇸
Based on this request <3
Nate Jacobs + Fem!reader. Warnings : Dark. SFW but discretion advised. Drugs.
My other Nate fics. If you have the time.
A.N: No way I managed to write something with a happy, non-cliffhanger ending. Are you guys proud of me?
P.S : My love for Elvis makes a cameo AGAIN.
You do NOT have permission to repost and/or translate any of my fics.
Desc.: "Hello, You."
════════════════════ 🔭 ═════════════════════
Joe Goldberg had it all wrong.
Sure, stalking people when you know nothing about them is rewarding, yes, but hard, and time-consuming. Good on you, Joe.
But Nate didn't have time. He wanted quick and easy.
And let me tell you something, nothing is easier than stalking a house you already know inside and out.
Nothing is easier than stalking an Instagram profile that you already follow.
Nothing is easier than stalking a girl you already know.
He hadn't exactly prayed for this, okay? But when it did happen, it hit him all at once, like a freight train. Obsession - love - is tricky like that.
What started as a way to check on Maddy after being blocked ended up with scrolling past pictures of her on others' profiles and zooming into yours. Hands in his pants.
It's not even like you reminded him of her, so it was genuinely starting to disgust him, as well, to give him the creeps. You were a junior, it was weird, but it's not like love cares. Heart wants what it wants and all that.
The last name you shared with his ex was the only thing that haunted him. Like actually, haunted him. Like, he'd have dreams about trying to erase your last name and put his instead but it stayed on, like a stain, like a reminder.
Not to mention, he was exactly the opposite of your type.
He'd liked to have tried to say he didn't fit that bill, that he was quote-unquote, not like the other guys, but he genuinely couldn't say that. He was a dick. And he knew it. Badge of honour, baby.
Fucking yay.
The badge didn't really do that great in landing him a date, though.
Yeah, a date, not even a hookup. That's what he'd been reduced to. A simp.
You weren't even all that great, either, and he was genuinely wondering if he was secretly being roofied, the way all great Kings are before attempted regicide. Sure you were hot and not a cunt, but like, that was it. Was Nate attracted to the bare fucking minimum? Is that what your sister had done to him?
No, but then you weren't just not-a-cunt. You were also genuinely kind. Charitable. Genuine.
Fuck. Fucking Perezes giving him migraines and whiplash.
════════════════════ 🔭 ═════════════════════
He was about ninety percent sure you'd be there. You were always there, he'd noticed, at about four thirty sharp, at the bus stop. Your stupid fucking wired earphones on.
Get airpods, you fucking nerd.
Knowing you, you probably didn't want to, lest someone think you were ignoring them when they were talking to you, but you actually had earphones on. Ugh.
The sheets of rain barely let him see you, let alone allow you to hear him, as he leaned with an umbrella on the side of the bus stand, his elbow almost recoiling thanks to the sharp cold. "Yo, Little Perez!"
What the fuck did he just call you? Okay, whatever. He slipped up. Happens to the best of us. Luckily, you didn't hear.
"HEY!"
You frowned, taking out one earbud and trying to look around for the source of the sound. The source waved at you with just his fingers. 'Cause he was cool like that.
"Hey!" Jesus, even with the thunder and the incessant shattering rain, he could swear your voice just changed his brain chemistry.
"You're wet as fuck!"
"That's not how you catcall someone! You fucked up the line!" Ha. Fucking amazing. THIS kinda humour, he could get by.
"Are you womansplaining how to catcall to a guy?!"
You rolled your eyes, chuckling. "What do you want, Jacobs?!"
"Having a little moment?!", he asked, nodding at your phone. "Or do you need a ride?!"
"Bus!", you called back.
"Which one?", he asked, before looking at the sign on the side of the bus stand. "Wait, 4A through Kemper?! It's cancelled 'cause of the rain!"
"What?!"
"Yeah, check it out!", he said, whipping out his phone as you moved closer, tilting it so you could see the bus schedule update. That he totally did not find from months ago and edit to pass off as today's.
Your eyes widened and your fists clenched. "Motherf--!", you cut yourself off, kicking the bench slightly. "Still offering that ride?"
"Sure, I'm going through Kemper, anyway."
"Why are you going through Kemper?"
"My Dad owns the apartment complexes past there, so I'm just doing the routine drop-ins and shit. Keep 'em scared of the boss or whatever."
You were being uncommonly attentive to his reasoning. He had not expected that. Good thing he didn't slack off on alibi prep.
"So. Whaddaya say? Need a ride?"
You nodded. "Of course I need a ride. This fuckin' town, man. Stupid bus schedules.", you muttered, following him - and his umbrella - to his car.
════════════════════ 🔭 ═════════════════════
"You sure it's okay?", you asked for the second time since you entered his car and graced it with your scent. "Like, it's all muddy."
He sighed, looking down under your feet. No, it irked him and if it were anyone else, he'd have tweaked out. Not you, though.
'And besides', he realised, grumbling as he looked down at his own feet, "I'm makin' it muddy, too.", he assured, completing his thought by saying it.
"Just this right.", you instructed, and he turned right. Where the fuck were you going?
"Where are you takin' me? Got a ransom or something?"
You smiled, rolling your eyes. "Left, then second right."
Okay, you wouldn't answer that, apparently. Fine. Elephant needs to be addressed, then.
"Aren't you supposed to hate me?"
You frowned, scoffing softly as you turned to him. "What?"
"I dated your big sister. All the shit that happened with us. No way she didn't tell you."
"Yeah, she did."
He waited for elaboration, but found none.
"So? You don't care?"
"Look, Nate, I think you're an asshole for what you did to my sister."
Yeah, you'd be weird as fuck to think otherwise.
"But I know my sister. She's not... she's not a complete saint, either."
Obviously, you're referring to the multiple times she's cheated on him. You're being deliberately vague because you think he doesn't know and it's that kind of concern for others' wellbeing that makes him want to tell you to do whatever the hell you want to him right now.
"So I'm just not getting into it, okay?"
Okay. "Okay."
"Yeah, right here. Right here's good.", you said, and he came to a stop, watching you gather your stuff and practically fly out.
"Rue Bennett?", you asked the - could he say receptionist? Or was this guy just out there with a ledger? - receptionist, breathlessly.
"She just signed in. Sponsor?'
"Escort."
Huh. Huh. WOW. You were charitable enough to fuck around with RUE BENNETT? Jesus, who were you, Mother Teresa?
"Hey, is this an NA meeting or something?", he called, elbow leaning out the window.
"Yeah, my friend doesn't have a good track record of attending, I gotta make sure she's there! But thanks, Nate, I owe you one big time, man!", you called back, scrawling your name onto the ledger before running into the building.
He watched you disappear until the ledger guy cleared his throat. "You an addict, too?"
Nate snorted softly, scoffing and shaking his head as ledger-dude started laughing. "Fuck off, man.", he replied, key in the ignition again.
"Don't blame you, kid!", he called, and Nate wanted to punch him. No way was he watching you go in, too. That shit was creepier than Nate wanting you. "Have a good one!"
Oh, he would.
════════════════════ 🔭 ═════════════════════
"Yo, hey. Little Perez." Fuck, why did he keep calling you that? It was fucking retarded.
"Hey, Nate."
"I think you owe me something."
"You know that's just a thing people say?"
"Mm, yeah, but...", he muttered, shrugging. "I'm a man of my word, so I think everyone else should be too. Unless you think not keeping up your promises is good?"
You rolled your eyes. "You don't need to guilt me into it. Just ask."
"There's a party. You're coming to it."
"Nah, no parties."
"What are you, gonna give me some bullshit 'I-don't do-parties-I'm-not-like-other-girls' excuse? Or the 'they're-so-overwhelming' excuse?"
"Next week's finals week."
Oh. Okay, well, now he just feels like a dick.
"Oh, shit, my bad. Forgot you little juniors have it a month earlier than we do.", he muttered, watching you for a moment before he decided enough was enough. He'd just ask.
"What are you even doing?", he asked, watching you take the last sealed box from your friend and place it in front of the notice board at the school entrance.
You looked back up at him, before unrolling the chart you'd been working on during study hall yesterday. "Hm? Oh, fundraiser."
"For this hellhole of a school?"
"Uh, no.", you replied, shaking your head. "For the soup kitchen, through the school."
He snorted. "Right. Who's even gonna sign up?"
"Hey, they signed up for the ASPCA thing last fall. Must be the community waking up.'
Or guys wanting to dick you down.
"Yeah, but that's 'cause it's you who asked them to."
"Hey, you wanna sign up?"
He scoff-laughed, raising a brow. "Me? For the soup kitchen?"
You knelt down, ironing out the poster with your palms, looking up at him expectantly.
No way you weren't doing that shit on purpose. No way. Wait... you- you weren't. That was a genuine fucking question and you didn't understand that there's no way he could say no to you when you look at him like that? Jesus.
He sighed, magnanimously. "What do you need me to do?"
"Well, you're tall. So just help us hang this thing up. Ladder's not tall enough."
Humming, he took the poster from you, giving it a once over. Jesus. "You made this?"
"Hm? Oh, yeah.", you nodded, hands on your hips. "Cool?"
"Couldn't make this shit if I tried."
"That a compliment?"
"Supposed to be. But you're right, it's a toss-up. I'd never try in the first place.", he mumbled, nodding subtly at you before he climbed up a couple rungs. "Here?"
"Mhm. Maybe like a tiny bit higher?"
He'd climb Everest for you. He just wished you'd know that.
"Here?"
"Yeah, perfect. You need tape, or do you think you can hold it up long enough to use a couple push pins on each corner?"
"I think I can handle it.", he replied, unamused, but he hid a grin at your laughter. Not to call the Lord's name in vain, but Jesus, were you fucking with him.
He leaned down to get the clear plastic box of colourful pins from you, placing it on the top rung of the ladder for a moment and taking a couple out. "So like, two on each corner?"
No response.
"Yo, Little Perez?"
"Uh... maybe three?"
That wasn't you. Who the fuck was this dweeb?
"Who the fuck are you?"
"I'm Cole.", the kid said, still holding the ladder down securely, as if that was his life duty.
"Did I ask your fucking name?"
He's a dick, but this was too much, even for him. But you'd just gone AWOL, so yeah, he was kinda pissed.
"No, I...", the kid muttered, kinda pathetically.
He huffed. "Where is Y/N?"
"She's over there.", he mumbled, and Nate's gaze followed his scrawny little hand to see you talking to Maddy. Huh.
Yeah, Nate was the problem. Maybe he always was.
Why, in his stupid little mind, you guys were totally different universes, he didn't know.
Why his stupid little mind didn't expect for those universes to clash, he had no clue.
You were sisters! Stayed in the same fucking house, maybe even sometimes the same fucking room! What sort of idiot would hope for the opposite? Him, apparently. He needed you as far away from her as possible.
Hard task, but if Joe Goldberg could do that to a girl and her best friend, he could do it to a girl and her sister.
════════════════════ 🔭 ═════════════════════
"You're tweaking out, man, what is up with you recently?"
He rubbed his hands across his face. "The little sister asked me, okay, I didn't want beef with both Perezes, yeah? So just shut the fuck up and come."
"At least can we bring booze?"
"No, they're including East Highland Middle School, too."
Yeah, convincing an entire football team (plus Chris McKay, in hopes that he'd bring his college football gang) to take part in some soup kitchen fundraiser wasn't exactly simple.
Definitely not as simple as, say, mapping out your room in his head so that when the time came to inevitably kiss you against the door, he wasn't losing face looking for the bed or bumping into your snazzy little swivel chair.
Which he, of course, did a shitty job of. He refused, for his pride, to become one of those binoculars-using creeps. He considered himself more subtle than that. And sophisticated.
But anything was better than the mess he was making of this.
"What is this, like, a bowling thing? A raffle?"
"Car wash."
"With the cheerleaders in it?"
Maybe he should've led with that.
"I mean, maybe? I'm sure Y/N could convince them..."
"Shit, I'm down. It's one of those wet, soapy ass ones you gotta get into bathing suits for, right?"
Yeah, definitely should've led with that. He nodded.
He fist-bumped, dapped-up, and took as many shoulder pats as were thrown at him, before he raised a brow. McKay was still in there, his arms crossed.
"Was this what your whole question was about?"
"Huh?"
"You texted me last night."
Oh, yeah. Drunk.
"Shit, yeah. Just ignore that."
"Yo, McKay. Ever fallen for an ex's sister? How 2 deal with it? Lmk.", he read out, sarcastically trying to imitate Nate's voice.
"I was shitfaced, man."
"Right."
Nodding, Nate shoved his hands into his pocket. "You'll show up? To the fundraiser thing. I really am tryna be a good person, 'kay? Don't want to disappoint Perez Number Two."
"See, Nate, what's throwin' me off is that you're not saying you wanna fuck this sister, you're saying you're falling in love with her."
"Uh-uh, no, no, I said falling for her."
"Same thing, man."
"No, it's not."
McKay chuckled, and Nate couldn't help but reciprocate. "Seriously, Nate, I don't know if it's a good idea."
"She's completely fucking different, man, I'm telling you, she and her sister are, like... fucking worlds apart." Who the fuck was he trying to convince?
"That's dangerous, Nate, there's so much could go wrong--"
"Man, I just need some advice. I don't know how to do the boyfriend thing, clearly. I actually like this girl." Ew, what the fuck had you done to him?
"What are you, sweet on Lexi Howard, now?", he scoffed, clenching his jaw. "As if you haven't fucked up the Howards' life enough."
It's good that McKay thinks the ex he's talking about is Cassie. Actually kind of dumb.
He'd just tried to convince footballers to join a fundraiser for you, and he thinks it's Lexi Howard he wants.
Maybe this dumbassery is why he lost Cassie.
"Hey, Lexi did that on her own with that stupid fucking play of hers."
"Yeah? And it was the play that fucked Cassie for months?"
He fell silent. Yeah, McKay and him had never actually spoken about the whole fucking-his-ex-girlfriend thing, but he figured they weren't technically still together.
"Man, look, I'm not with her anymore. I- we're done. Yeah?"
"Yeah, I know.", he spat.
"She's all yours, man.", he muttered, before McKay scoffed.
"Like I want your sloppy seconds. And who the fuck are you, giving me permission?"
"If you think I still want Cassie, you're a fucking retard, McKay."
He scoffed, shaking his head. "Chill, man, okay, I'm not gonna--", he cut himself off, rubbing his hands over his face. "We're cool, I just wish you'd have told me, and I didn't have to find out about it fucking... months later."
Huh. Wow. McKay was a better man than Nate was, for sure. If McKay had been fucking Maddy, he'd have committed double homicide.
"Alright, look, my advice is just don't put up a front. If you're a dick- which you fucking are - just own it, and make it cute."
"Cute?"
"Self-awareness. Girls love it. Pearl of wisdom, brother, you owe me with your life."
"Wait, so I'm just gonna have to continue being a dick?", he called, as McKay shouldered past him.
"Yeah, but consciously make an effort not to be. It's a delicate balance. But you'll find it!"
Either McKay had just ruined his life or given him the best advice in the world.
════════════════════ 🔭 ═════════════════════
"Jesus Fucking Christ."
Yeah, he was going to hell.
But what the fuck else could he say?
Who the hell would have thought the turnout for a fucking soup kitchen car wash would be this huge? Who even were half these kids?
Of course, nothing would beat the ASPCA thingie you'd organised in the fall, even Nate came to that. But that was just 'cause Maddy liked cats. Or whatever.
The fucking vibe of the place - you wouldn't think this was a school, no, it was some sort of car-washing-frat-party-cult. And you, absolutely fucking oblivious to this miracle you somehow conjured up, stood in the middle, with a clipboard and a very stressed out look on your face.
"Yo, Little Perez, you seeing this shit?", he mumbled, unable to force the awe out of his tone as he nudged you.
"Yeah, your little football friends are literally supposed to be vollunteers. Instead, they're paying more than actual customers."
"Money's money, hon."
"I suppose that's true. Horny teenagers are the best market."
There we go, you were a quick study, he'd give you that.
"Why do you look like you got a stick up your ass? Relax, maybe bring your car to be washed? It's a success!"
Normally, he'd have asked you to go topless and get to work. But something told him that kind of joke wouldn't fly with you. And besides, why the fuck would he wanna see middle aged men in cars grinning at you cleaning?
"People leave without paying sometimes."
"It's for charity, no one's gonna cheap out."
You snorted, loudly at that. "You'd be fucking surprised, man."
"Still, no need to be this stressed. You're fine. See? All that? You made it happen. Little Orphan Annies throughout the state owe their lives to you, or whatever.'
"It's not just for orphans, for like, anyone who's hungry and needs some food, so, like the--"
"Okay, so homeless people. The less fortunate. My bad." Dick, but consciously trying not to be.
You smiled softly, nodding. "Yeah. Precisely. And I just hope this is enough, y'know?"
He rolled his eyes, watching the footballers wolf whistle at the cheerleaders turning on the hose. "Money-making-machine right there."
"You know what would get more female customers?"
"I don't know, Brad Pitt? Penn Badgley?"
"The 6'5 star QB giving 'em a show."
He chuckled incredulously, raising a brow at you, arms folded. "Nope. No fucking way. You want me to strip? I already brought in so many people!"
"You're right, you're right. You've done enough. I was just kidding."
He grunted softly, though it was more out of amusement than frustration. "I do this, you'll come to the party?"
"Finals week. And I was kidding, man."
"If I host a party after finals week. Will. You. Come." , he asked, battling a grin. Yeah, he sounded annoyed but that's the last thing he could be when you stood there in flip flops with a pen tapping anxiously on a clipboard you've scribbled on.
"Sure."
"No bullshit?"
"No bullshit."
"And you'll drink and actually fucking participate? You won't try to turn the whole thing into an AA meeting?"
"Jesus, no!"
His hands moved to opposite ends of the hem of his shirt, pulling it over his body. "You are a fucking genius. Getting me to do all this.", he whispered, shaking his head before flipping you off as he jogged over to the next car in the lineup.
"You volunteered!", you called back, and he could hear the laughter in your voice. Fuck, RIP his brain chemistry.
════════════════════ 🔭 ═════════════════════
"What? No! You don't get it. None of my guy friends get it."
He's gonna pretend that didn't sting. 'Guy friends'. May very well be 'gay best friend'. Being reduced to a non-dateable-option wasn't the best feeling, but part of you was better than none of you.
And he couldn't blame you, even if it was you putting your guard up.
Everyone who asks you out is turned the fuck down. And they are all a very specific genre of human - sorry, subhuman. Jocks. No, sorry, that would make him fall into that bracket.
Idiot jocks. Who couldn't think about anything but fucking and fighting.
But luckily for you, he had the looks, the physique, and the smarts and sophistication that came with being a Jacobs.
Whole package.
However, the way this shit was going, he'd have to watch as some hippie tweaker who 'believes that animals are people, too, dude, go vegan or go home!' got to date you.
It's weird, right? How someone can change you so quick.
He just wanted you. Like, he wanted you.
He wanted to know your darkest secrets and never use them.
He wanted to know how tall your walls were and break through them.
He wanted to know why you were so fucking nice to people like Rue motherfucking Bennett, and he wanted to exploit it.
But most of all, he wanted to know what made you tick. What turned you off a dude. What could possibly make you blow a gasket.
What made you... You.
"I just think that you guys don't get how much like, potential Loki has. As a boyfriend."
"Yeah, but Thor's jacked, he's not fucking evil, and he's, like, a superhero!"
"Loki isn't evil, he's just--"
"If you say misunderstood, I'm going to crash out.", he muttered, pushing some hair behind your ear. With his luck, you'd ignore it, because of course friends help you when hair's getting into your eyes!
"But he is misunderstood, okay? Like, he was constantly made to feel inferior in every way!" See? Ignored.
He watched you take a bite of your pasta before taking a bite of his burger. "I swear, girls always do this, they go for the worst possible option and then justify it instead of going to the best option and enjoying it."
Shut up. Yeah, the irony wasn't lost on him. Hardy har har.
"Loki changed at the end. Okay? He'd just assumed that Odin's mistreatment was something Thor believed in himself, even though Thor thought of him as a brother!"
He groaned, a slightly pained laugh escaping him. "Next you're gonna say you're Team Cap."
"What? No! No, Tony was right."
He tilted his head. Huh. Brains. "Yeah. Good. 'Least you got something right, but now you got me thinking you have an aversion to blondes."
You chuckled and he swears he's going to lose it from your smile alone.
"How's finals going?"
"Good. Kinda scared for results, though.", you mumbled, shaking your head. "I'm so scared that every second I don't spend studying is another mark lost, and I'm losing it."
"Jesus, there's the fucking stick again. I swear, you should just--"
But it's like the universe was not okay with him winning, because in came your gang of nerds - sorry, your fellow student council members - to whisk you away.
"I'll see you later, Jacobs, okay?"
"Nate!", he called back, almost warning, before he was affronted with the sight of Maddy rolling her eyes at him. "Did you just call out your own name?"
"Shut up, Maddy. I was talking to someone."
"That's literally fucking pathetic."
Look who's talking.
════════════════════ 🔭 ═════════════════════
You didn't seem to actually do much to give him enough insight into your life, seriously.
You came to school, talking with your sister on the way.
You spent your school day doing nothing but going to classes and occassionally talking with Nate (fucking yay), and then you spent an extra hour and a half at school for some after school bullshit you did, he didn't care enough. And then you came home and studied.
Like, what a fucking nerd. What a sexy fucking nerd.
But finals week was over, and he'd even given you another week to wait for results, and now he was hosting a party.
Well, McKay was.
And you weren't coming.
One thing he couldn't stand for was you lying to him. Which was exactly what you did.
You had a date, you said, and that would have resulted in him getting into a car accident - that wasn't really an accident - on the highway if he believed you.
But he knew you weren't going on a date. You were going back to the fucking NA meeting for fucking Rue Bennett. There should be some limit to your charity.
But like the calm, level-headed individual he was, he didn't crash out, he simply schooled his face, took deep breaths - and maybe a can of beer - and parked his car gracefully.
His hand stilled on his seatbelt, and he looked down at the buckle for a moment, lost in thought.
No, no, fuck it. No second thoughts. He undid the buckle, getting out before locking the car with a beep.
The trees shrouding his sight slowly gave way as he walked, and right there, to his left, on the stairs, was you.
Ledger-guy wasn't there, and so you were aimlessly playing with the pen that hung from the spring tether attached to his table.
You watched it bobble around each time you pushed it away and then watched it swing right back to you, regardless of how hard you'd pushed it, albeit unknowingly.
There was a metaphor there. He was sure of it.
"Hey.", he said softly, carefully. "Thought I'd find you here."
You looked up at him, but didn't even seem to have the energy to act guilty. "Hey."
He sat down with a low exhale, his knees bending uncomfortably as he nudged your shoulder with his own. "Yo."
You turned to him, nodding.
"What's going on? How come you're out here? She could've snuck out by now."
"She won't. She's doing really well. She's been sober for almost two months now."
He let out a soft whistle, nodding, before looking back at you, frowning slightly. "So why do you look depressed?"
"Her withdrawals, y'know, um. They're gone, but like... this two month mark is usually where it goes downhill, so I'm, like... worried, or whatever."
"It's gonna stick this time."
"Told myself that last year."
"Look, we've all grown up together. Small town. I- I'm not, like, fucking 'BFFs'... ", he muttered, using air quotes, "...with Rue, but she's strong.", he continued.
You shrugged lightly. "I guess."
"Hey, look. She's been through a lot. Her Dad kicked the bucket a while ago, her little sister found her ODd, rehab, lack thereof, relapse, all that shit. She'll get through it. And she's doing well enough right now. I saw her at school yesterday, she looks good. Like, healthy."
He was seriously wondering if he'd been hexed, because here he was, admitting he'd noticed Rue Bennett's sobriety, and spoken in favour of her, all for you. To alleviate your worries. To get that sadness off your face.
You nodded. "But I'm just... I hate that I can't be there with her through every bad moment."
Like he wanted to be with you.
"Hey.", he sighed, shuffling closer, brushing hair from your eyes and moving your head to his shoulder both in one swift motion. "She's here, isn't she? In there? Talking about her sobriety? She's going to school, too. You got her there."
Scoffing, you shook your head. Your humility would be the death of you, he's sure of it. "No, her family did. Mr. Ali did."
"You escorted her to every single meeting, without fail. You don't miss a single week."
Please don't ask how he knows, please don't ask how he knows-
"I guess."
Phew.
"Right. Trust me, one step at a time. Okay? She'll be fine."
You hummed and he looked at his reflection in his phone screen so he could analyze what a fucking simp he'd become.
"Thanks."
"Oh, shut up.", he scoffed. "'Thanks' like hundreds of people - and animals - don't owe you one already."
"Why do you do that?"
"What?"
"Put me up on a pedestal?"
"You'd rather I treat you like everyone else?"
"How do you treat everyone else?"
"How you'd expect me to."
You bit the inside of your cheek. "Why did you strangle my sister?"
If he had a beer in his mouth, he'd spit it out. "Anger issues."
"Did you get help for them?"
Who the fuck were you? He tells you he strangled your sister 'cause he was pissed, you want to know if he went to a shrink to get that shit out of him. He shook his head.
"Why not?"
"It's just about the only defence mechanism I have."
He didn't like how your stupid questioning made him feel as if he really was talking to a fucking shrink. He'd never admitted that before.
"Oh."
He took a long, deep breath, before patting on the tops of his thighs, standing. "C'mon."
"What? Where? Rue's still in there.", you asked, looking up at him as he stood over you.
"We'll be back before it's over."
════════════════════ 🔭 ═════════════════════
The waves threatened to devour your feet, but didn't seem to have the power to actually make good on their threats.
"I'm driving Rue back."
"It's PBR. It's impossible to get drunk off it, trust."
You shrugged, taking the can and popping it open.
He watched your lips wrap around the edge of the can, and your throat as it cascaded down it. Holy. Shit.
Taking a sip himself, he shifted so that his elbow was resting loosely on his knee. "Never have I ever...", he mused, grinning as he watched your eyes roll.
"Oh, sweet Jesus.", you scoffed.
"You skipped out on the party. I refuse to let you spend tonight without a little bit of fun."
"And 'never have I ever' is the way to do that?"
He shrugged. "Never have I ever.... kissed a girl.", he finished, taking a sip.
He was pleasantly surprised to see you take one, too.
"Oh, this I gotta hear."
"Keep your panties on, it was my best friend, and we just wanted to practice kissing, get my first kiss over with."
What a liar.
"Your best friend?", he scoffed, raising a brow.
"...'s sister.", you admitted, biting your lip.
"There we go. Cassie Howard isn't a bad choice for a first kiss."
You shook your head. "Yeah, I know. Just felt weird. Like I was betraying Lexi or something. You never go for the sisters, y'know?"
Oof. Right in the heart. It was like it was directed at him.
"Yeah, but you weren't dating her."
"Well, yeah, but it's the principle."
He exhaled, before taking another sip. "Tell ya what. I'll drive Rue and you home. Get the stick outta your ass.", he muttered, pulling out a packet of pre-rolleds.
"Wh- no, what? You want me stoned in a car with a recovering addict?"
Okay. Fine. Fair.
"Fine, then here.", he replied, handing you his pocket flask. "It's whiskey, not poison."
You looked at it, contemplating for a while before sighing. "You know where she lives, right?"
"Uh huh."
"And where I- well, yeah, 'course you know where I live.", you mumbled, still gazing at the bottle.
"Don't you trust me?", he asked, softly, tilting his head.
════════════════════ 🔭 ═════════════════════
The door swung open and he stood face-to-face with Maddy, the ex he hadn't seen for almost the entire school year. Well, that she knew of.
"Hey."
"Jesus.", she muttered, gently grabbing you from his arms. You were - surprisingly- still coherent, but you couldn't really be trusted to stand on your own. "The fuck did you drink?"
"Whiskey.", he piped up, handing you over carefully.
"And you just happened to be walking by?"
"No, we were waiting for Rue's drug meeting thing to get over, and we just went a couple blocks away to the beach."
Maddy scoffed, still stroking your hair as she glared at him. "Where you gave her whiskey."
"Well, yeah, she's been stressed the whole week, which you'd know if you cared."
"Oh, please, like you care more about my sister than I do." she spat.
He shoved his hands into his pockets. "I'll see you around, Maddy. Bye, Y/N.", he mumbled, turning around.
See, this was why he had to get you the fuck away from your sister. She'd never trusted anybody in her life, but you were different, you had a heart.
"What did you say to her?", she called as his key turned in his car lock.
To Rue? He'd said that you'd told him to tell you that you had an urgent emergency at the soup kitchen, and to walk herself the fuck home.
"What?"
"She'd never drink while waiting on Rue."
Huh. Okay, fine, so she knew some things about you. But she was your sister, so it was less impressive than how much he knew. So there.
Not that it was a competition.
"I didn't say anything. Told her to get the stick outta her ass."
"Did you like... how did you convince her?"
I asked whether she trusted me and gave her the most solemn look ever.
He shrugged. "Dunno. Guess she needed a break that bad and I'm the only one willing to give her one.", he responded, getting into his car.
That was so badass. Write that down.
════════════════════ 🔭 ═════════════════════
"What now? Does UNICEF need your help?", he groaned, barely holding himself back from yelling.
"I got grounded for being drunk. Maddy tried to sneak me up, but my mom caught me."
He doubted that. Maddy probably took you upstairs slowly on purpose so that you wouldn't be able to come to this party, either.
"Just sneak out. Come on. You've already skipped out on, like, two parties."
"Hey! The first one doesn't count, I wasn't coming to that, anyway, it was finals week!"
Rolling his eyes, he wrapped his arm around your shoulder. "If you come I'll donate to charity.", he whispered in your ear, breathing in the smell of your hair.
You laughed at that, exactly like he wanted. "Is that all you think my life is?"
"Come on. Do it for the kids."
"I've never snuck out before."
"Maddy'll teach you, I'm sure.", he scoffed, shooing you off to your next class. "She's coming anyway."
"You're an ass."
"Badge of honour, baby!", he called, waving. Okay. This was good. Finally.
---
Watching McKay do a keg stand wasn't exactly on his bucket list for the night, but hey, he had to do something until you arrived.
He looked down at his watch. When he'd passed by your house, he'd watched you getting dressed through your window. Maddy was doing her makeup in the room next to yours.
That was a half hour ago. The drive from your place to McKay's wasn't even fifteen minutes. So where the hell were you? He was looking around - had been since he'd arrived - for your blue dr-- oh.
What an idiot. It's possible you'd changed after he had left. Right. So blue dress not counted. Now he was left just looking for you.
Logical deduction suggested you'd already showed up, but then again, you could be in a bathroom, seeing as you seemed so nervous about sneaking out perfectly that you hadn't really had the time to put on makeup yet.
Not that you needed it. But still. Would look nice.
And he was right.
You were right there, cutting uncomfortably through the crowds, beelining to the bathroom. He called your name, but the music drowned him out. Fine. Whatever.
He stopped the bathroom door from closing behind you. "There you are."
You watched him through the mirror, before turning around. "Have you seen Rue?!", you called, your phone to your ear.
Unacceptable. Un-fucking-acceptable. You cannot be this selfless. It's actually unhealthy.
"No, why?" He fought a frustrated eye roll. Let her OD, at least the rest of the town could have some semblance of peace once she's dead!
"She's here, that I know, but she isn't responding to any of my texts! Or calls.", you added, gesturing at the phone by your ear. "Straight to voicemail."
"She's probably just having fun, like you should probably be doing.", he reasoned, gently taking the phone from you and ending the call, shoving the thing into his back pocket.
"I told her not to come."
"Then she should have fucking listened. Hey- hey, it's not your fault that she doesn't take care of herself.", he whispered, his thumbs rubbing arcs on your cheeks. "Why are you so... just relax.", he murmured, kissing your forehead.
"No, Nate, you don't get it, she came because she thinks she's ready, and that she knows if anything goes wrong, I'm right here."
"Look, you can't let people depend on you so much, you're going to lose your shit. Trust me, I know. My mother doesn't have anything but me and my brother, and it's hell. She doesn't take care of herself, she lets our Dad walk all over her-", he muttered, still wondering how you're, yet again, effortlessly making him say shit he's never told another soul.
"But what if something goes wrong?"
"Nothing's going to go wrong."
"Hey, last time she was at a party, she met this weird kid Elliot, who got her hooked again."
"She won't relapse. It won't happen. You're right here."
"I'm not with her, though."
"You don't need to be. She's a big girl, she'll take care of herself. And besides, you won't be there with her her whole life, will you? Making sure she's sober. She'll graduate this year and go to college. She isn't going to depend on a high schooler to keep her safe all the way in college, is she?"
He can tell that you fully understand what he's saying, and that you even agreed, to an extent, but he certainly didn't blame you for not accepting it. You were just unnecessarily caring, almost to a fault.
This was all you knew.
"You need someone to take care of you, too, sometimes.", he said, bending his head so he was now looking up at you, from where he had you perched on the countertop. "Yeah?"
"What? What are you even- look, you're wasting time, Nate, I don't want her relapsing, I cant- I know it's selfish, but I can't go through all that with her again, Nate--"
Selfish? You were the antonym of that word, and it was disgusting that you couldn't even see it.
"I get it. Sometimes you need a break, too. Need someone to love on you. Need to know that what you're doing isn't thankless."
You looked down at him, a soft frown on your face that he wanted to hug off you.
"I can see it. You're not denying it.", he teased sing-songily, tapping your nose.
You grinned softly, trying your damndest to hide it. "Shut up."
"You're a good person, whether you're on Rue-watch 24/7, or looking out for your sister so that she doesn't get abducted by the guys she fucks, or being the most charitable bitch this side of... well... Earth.", he chuckled.
"Do you have a point? Or are you just doing the pedestal thing again?"
"My point is this."
Kissing you was exactly how he'd imagined it would be. Smooth, slow and correct. Not correct as in he was doing it correctly - god, he fucking hoped he was - no, correct as in this was probably the only purpose he'd had for his life.
He could feel you shifting away, and he shook his head. "No. No, no, no. Don't. The sister card's not gonna work."
"But it's valid.", you murmured, trying to pull away as he pulled you closer.
"No, the fuck it isn't.", he replied against your lips, pulling you toward the edge of the counter. "Shut up."
"That's mean."
"Yeah? Well, so are you. How's that for a pedestal?", he asked, his lips on your shoulder. "Look.", he sighed, finally, finally able to bring himself to look at your face. "Just say yes."
"To what?"
He scoffed. "World peace. What do you think? Me."
"You?"
He nodded, attempting to fix your hair as best he could. "I care, see?"
"Oh, sorry, yes, messing up my hair is, like, peak boyfriend."
"Fixing it is. I don't do that for anyone.", he retorted, kissing your forehead again. "One date."
"'One date' is wild. Because that'll totally convince me.", you laughed, and he tsked, shaking his head.
"You're not funny. Seriously. Like, one date. And it's gonna be completely secret. No Maddy messing with us. No Rue messing with us. No Cassie. No... no one else."
It had just occurred to him how many people really had messed with his life so far. No longer.
"One date?"
Huh, wow. You were considering it. That's more than he'd expected from you.
"One.", he assured.
"One."
════════════════════ 🔭 ═════════════════════
"I am?"
"Yeah, like, way different than what I thought you'd be like. Your whole thing was like, asshole."
One date had turned to a second, a third, and now, here he was, on the same beach with you again, watching you smoke the pre-rolled cig you'd declined a couple months ago.
"Can't say you're that different than I thought, though. You're exactly who you seem to be."
"Is that good or bad?"
"I don't know, you tell me.", he grinned, taking the blunt back from you.
"Aren't you the expert on all this personality stuff?"
He chuckled. "There's only one thing I am - and want to be - the expert on."
"What's that?"
"You."
He was, and, if his plans went well, he would continue to be. He could one-up your sister, he could one-up Rue Bennett, he could one-up every single loser in town.
Because he'd know everything about you.
He'd know you.
