so okay. I'm white, is how I should start this off. But I feel like so many people either ignore or mishandle Shane's Asianness. Like-
first bad option, ignoring it. You don't make any notion of it at all and how it affects him as a gay autistic man in (historically) Straight White Man spot. This is something that would affect his career, his ability to get there, and people's preconceived notions of him as a public figure. Not to mention where many junior leagues are. Most of those leagues are in smaller towns that are overwhelmingly white. We don't have a professional league in my town, but an NHL team trains (or trained, recently changed) here and micro aggressions (that I notice!) are rampant. He probably wouldn't been on the end of that to a degree. Second bad option- mishandling it. Often leading to fetishization, people treat Shane being Asian as either a curse or a blessing. Being Asian wouldn't have automatically made him ineligible for hockey, the NHL, NHL awards, captaincy, brand deals, and the like. It also wouldn't have rocketed him through the standings and warmed him to public opinion. Him being Asian was never a barrier to success, it was a hurdle. And it made it a lot easier for him to "fall from grace" for menial offenses. That happens in real life all the time with POC celebrities, like Manon in comparison to Lexie in Dream Academy, if that's a show you're familiar with. If not, the summary is that both of these girls missed practices for a variety of reasons, but public opinion of Manon is much lower, highly due to her race as she is black.
I have seen people straight up say they think he always got good grades, is really good at math, and don't get me started on the whole feminizing bullshit they give him (I have so many issues with that, number one being that it is so uncharacteristic for either of them! Let gay men be men without making one of them a woman - a woman).
This comes into play when talking about Shane's eating disorder. Something that is absolutely never said is that Shane truly believes he's not enough. That his hockey is always on the verge of being bad. He's an amazing player, and he knows it. He and Ilya are at the top of this game and they are well aware. (I won't hear any Ilya is worse! He's bad! Less cups! That doesn't mean anything, and you clearly don't understand hockey) Shane's eating disorder comes from a deep comfort for having discipline and a fear of retribution, from fans and from the league, for falling behind. Which, by the way, happens! He was justified with his fear! Being worried that his team and the league would turn on him was a completely valid fear, as it happened exactly as it did in Shane's nightmares. He gets outed by a close friend, he makes a mistake, his team turns on him and ousts him. The diet does not, in fact, come from wanting to be skinnier. That doesn't even make sense, he's a professional athlete. The idea of him wanting to be skinnier and hence starving himself comes from people viewing him as a woman and taking part of his struggle (how people will retaliate against him for his success and divergences from the norm) and assigning him a common problem women have.
Another issue that related to this; (I am white. I feel that should be reiterated!) Shane's move to the Ottawa Centaurs has some white savior vibes. Both in the book and in fandom. Come you poor Asian boy, mistreated by your team, to our team of happiness gay people and rainbows. We know this was your biggest fear and it came true 100%, but this will be better for you! And I understand that being in a toxic workplace and switching to a new one can feel magical, but the idea that Montreal was just always awful and hateful to Shane and he needed Ilya to pull him out and tell him that was how they acted wasn't okay is bogus. Plus, Shane went so willingly. Maybe if Shane was flaky, if he didn't show so much loyalty it would be different. But Shane was willing to put up with their behavior for a few years (granted his contract would've made changing anything difficult) he wouldn't have simply been like "fuck it I'm out"? At least he would've had much more complex feelings surrounding it. Shane would've been entering UFA anyways. Isn't it far more romantic to leave the team you did so much growing up with for the person who made you want to grow? Instead of being ousted?
I guess I see so many people mischaracterizing both Ilya and Shane, but Shane always gets it worse and I really think it's because he's Asian. And a bottom.
yall also mistreat Yuna as an ambitious woman who wants the best for her son and is willing to help him get it as an overbearing tiger mom who Shane resents when we never see him show anything besides passing exasperation at her managing him but yall really aren't ready for the conversation
anyways let me know if you think any of these are totally off base










