Huh
Sits down politely
Clears throat
….
I don't think Pencil should have a happy ending after Tpot.
💥💥💥💥💥
Look, Pencil is just in general a really fucking shitty and selfish person, she shouldn't be allowed to have the kind of ending where freesmart forgives her and welcomes her back like some people are expecting
She was extremely emotionally abusive to Book in particular and was constantly being flip floppy with Ruby and Bubble, she tries to control who Ice Cube is friends with and drags Match around like she's her own personal lap dog
Bubble and Ruby had a right to not originally want to go but they're only realistically doing it for Match and I seriously do hope Match starts to realise just how bad of a person Pencil can and has been while they're heading there
Especially once they realise what Pencil is doing, she's trying to go back in time to stop herself from doing the things she did so she can get her friends back. Now you can see that as her being remorseful but honestly, I see it as her being selfish. Yeah she may feel bad and realise what she did was wrong but I genuinely believe that she doesn't realise what she did was wrong.
What I mean is that she's realised that she did something bad and that's why Freesmart doesn't want to be around her, but she doesn't see what she's done wrong. Because if she did see what she did wrong, she wouldn't be actively going back in time to change the past to have them all forget what she did.
She needs to let them go. Let them decide if they want to continue being her friends or not. She needs to be ok with whatever option they choose. And I really hope that that will be the narrative path they go down, a bittersweet ending. Fitting for someone like Pencil.
Pencil isn't doing anything to change herself now. The moment she was brought back to compete in Tpot, she immediately tried forcing Ice Cube and Book to be her friends, despite the fact they were very clearly uncomfortable and no longer wanting to be around her anymore. She's instead trying to change the past.
I want to see that explored.
You can never change the past. No matter how hard you try. You can only change the you now and what you'll do going forward. Being content and accepting whatever the people around you choose to do. Because no-one deserves to be treated the way you treated them and expected to be ok with being your friend again.
There is a reason why Pencil and Pen are parallels of each other. Pen did some bad things and had his own group but he is more aware, he's willing to change and he's already come to terms with the fact that, well, his friends have moved on. And he's ready to move on too.
Pencil is the opposite.
I want to emphasise that I do not hate Pencil or think she's a bad character for having flaws, I actually really love Pencil, she's an incredibly complicated character with a lot of very visible flaws, hell I made a coloured animation of her and I almost never do that because of burnout
What I'm trying to say here is that Pencil should not have a happy ending, she should have a bittersweet ending where we leave her off with the idea that she's going to better herself and let her friends go



















