As someone underneath the trans umbrella, I should start implementing more trans characters in my fanfics. Anyways, here is a silly list I put together for the silm characters so I can do that. Feel free to disagree with me, I made this for fun.
Silmarillion characters who, in my opinion, could be transfemme:
Caranthir. Objectively just very funny and angsty if this one is female after Feanor dies, completely ruining the Feanor's sons thing. This family needs more women in it. Also lesbian Halenthir is incredible
Celeborn. Because lesbians with Galadriel
Lungorthin. Listen. We already have a Lord of Balrogs. Let's have a Lady of Balrogs too. Equality. Also, a female balrog would be hot. ...yes, that is a pun.
Celebrimbor. I think it could add some very interesting dynamics to the legacy of Feanor and Curufinwe, and Celebrimbor’s relationship with Galadriel.
Daeron. Not enough female bards in the Silmarillion. Could add a new factor to Daeron's relationship with Luthien.
Gil-Galad. Trans Gil-Galad has so many implications depending on whose daughter she is. There are so many ways you could go with this.
Silmarillion characters who, in my opinion, could be transmasc:
Celegorm. God, the angst you get from a Celegorm who looks like Miriel is cranked up by at least 100 hundred if he is afab.
Maedhros. It's funny in a simultaneously unfunny, painful, and relatable way when a character who canonically is always having the worst day also has to deal with period cramps.
Curufin. It's a similar situation to transfem Celebrimbor in that I think it adds new messy layers to Feanor's legacy and relationship with his sons.
Gil-Galad. Trans Gil-Galad has so many implications depending on whose son he is. There are so many ways you could go with this.
Silmarillion characters who, in my opinion, could be some flavour of enby, agender, bigender, genderfluid, or otherwise unspecified label.
All of the above. For the same reasons.
All the Valar and Maiar. I'm not convinced the immortal beings of the world comprehend gender.
Eru Iluvatar. I am extremely convinced the immortal all seeing being of the world does not comprehend gender.
Gil-Galad. Trans Gil-Galad has so many implications depending on whose child they are. There are so many ways you could go with this.
Also, for all of these categories: literally anyone. Anyone. There doesn't need to be some complicated lore reasons to add angst and stuff, I just like to because being trans adds angst and stuff to my daily life. The characters can just be trans.














