James's plopped himself down on the sofa next to Sirius who was hunched over his notebook writing furiously.
"Hopefully a ballad," Sirius responded, grabbing Peter and Remus's attention. Peter jogged over when Sirius handed the notebook to James, peering over his shoulder so he could read too. Sirius tapped his nails against his jeans as he waited for them to finish. Sharing unfinished lyrics always felt uniquely vulnerable.
He could tell Remus was staring at him from across the room, but he refused to look up and meet that hazel gaze.
They had started off on such unsteady ground and Sirius knew it was his fault. Gilderoy leaving and spreading all of those lies had eaten at him in a way that the rest of the band couldn't quite understand. He was already a naturally defensive person, holding everything close to his chest while pretending to wear his heart on his sleeve. So it wasn't a shock that he'd made a horrible first impression. Nor that he had either too much pride or not enough courage to remedy it.
James got up and handed the notebook off to Remus, "Shaping up to be quite the love song Pads. Did I possess you at some point and forget?" James laughed but the words felt hollow as they bounced off of Sirius. James had always been the type to be overly generous with his love and affection.
"Yeah, it's quite soppy, but in a good way!" Peter added, "The bit about the moonlight is probably the most romantic thing you've written yet."
"You're not hiding a relationship from us are you?" James joked with an easy grin on his face, nudging Sirius with a quick jab of his elbow as he sat back down next to him. God if only he knew.
Sirius tried to laugh along but he couldn't, the smile plastered on his face fake in a way that James would've caught if he were looking a little closer.
"It's heartbreaking is what it is," Remus mumbled from his stool. Despite his low volume, all attention had been diverted to him where his head was still tucked downwards, staring at the words in front of him while he worried his bottom lip between his teeth.
"What are you talking about? Did you flip to a different page?" James asked.
Remus looked up at the three of them, his eyes a bit glassier than they'd been before, releasing his lip from his teeth. His eyebrows were furrowed together as he brought his hand up to absentmindedly rub at the scar on his jaw.
"It's about being in love with someone but not being able to express it. It screams a queer or otherwise forbidden relationship to me." The words sunk into Sirius skin where James's had bounced right off.
The confusion must have been clear on James and Peter's faces because Remus continued. "Take the line, moments under the moonlight where your heart beats next to mine, I ache for you in the sunshine. Taken very simply the first part could be a euphemism for sleeping together, obviously." His tone was almost comical in the way he brazenly implied that Sirius writing was in some way cliché.
"But when taken with the second part the contrast of the light and the dark leads you to the idea that the speaker can't or isn't allowed to love this person anywhere other than under the cover of night. Or hell, even our devotion lives in every shadow. This love is haunting the speaker, following them around but just out of reach. You can't shine a light on a shadow, it'll just disappear. It's a soul deep love, you aren't wrong. That just makes it all the more depressing that it has to be hidden."
Remus was picking up the broken scraps of a mirror and forcing Sirius to look at himself in them. The jagged edges cutting right through Sirius's carefully crafted mask and reflecting the exhaustion and hurt lying just beneath the surface. Years of lyrics laced with double, sometimes triple meanings were being flayed out for everyone to see. Sirius had always yearned to be seen and yet flinched from the insinuation that he'd put himself out there to be examined in such a way.
"Toss the bouquet beneath the stone, that's where it belongs, like you in my arms, the imagery is supposed to be flowers beneath a gravestone, yeah? But you've specifically used tossing and bouquet because it also calls to mind a wedding. That idea of a wedding, of a public declaration of their love is dead, buried."
This time both James and Peter turned to Sirius, searching for some kind of confirmation. All he could do was offer a small curt nod as he caught his breath.
"It's like how Bronze isn't really about a summer road trip, it's about a fantasy version of a childhood the speaker didn't get to experience, right?" Remus continued. And he was right, so succinctly right in a way no one had called Sirius out on before.
Spluttering sounded from the other end of the couch as the boys argued against Remus until the words scraped their way out of Sirius. "Yeah, uh, I haven't..." he cleared his throat, "I like writing songs that can be interpreted differently by the listener, but... I um... the stories I want to tell don't always... I prefer writing and playing songs you could dance to."
Betrayal flashed across James's face and Sirius felt his heart clench. He didn't mean to keep anything from his best friend, his brother, he just... His music was so deeply personal. It's why Gil's lies had cut him so deeply, why he couldn't just move on from the incident likes James and Peter could.
"So you hide it behind a quick tempo and major chords," Remus said while nodding, "to keep most listeners at the surface." He took in a deep breath like he was debating whether or not to say what he said next. "Bronze needed a fiddle, and this," he gestured with the notebook, "this one needs an organ, not just standard keys. Wedding march for those on the surface and funeral dirge for those diving deeper." Despite the hesitation, Remus looked steady. Confident in a way that he hadn't been before. Like he knew for a fact he was right and didn't quite care if anyone in the room agreed or not.
"I don't have any instrumentation for it yet. Those aren't even the final lyrics," Sirius argued.
"Sure, and when you do, add an organ," Remus said with finality.
"Wait," Peter interrupted, "can we go back to Remus's fucking literary analysis. You've got an English degree or somethin'?"
That finally seemed to bring back Remus's self consciousness, as a blush fought it's way across his cheeks. "Ah, um no. Masters degree in music therapy actually." A careful smile exposing a crooked canine and a lack of eye contact made it clear to Sirius that Remus hadn't been planning on sharing this fact with them so soon, if ever. Sirius closed notebook was being gripped tightly in his left hand.
"No offense man but what the fuck were you doing auditioning for bands with a degree like that?" James chimed in and Sirius wanted badly to smack him across the back of his head. The smile dropped as Remus's face shuttered back to his normal joking detachment.
"Clinic wasn't the right fit for me." Remus shrugged it off but Sirius could see the deflection behind the half truth. Their eyes locked for a second. The moment was fleeting, but in it Sirius knew he wasn't the only one hoping nobody would risk a deeper look.
After they wrapped for the day and James and Peter made their way out to the control room, Sirius approached Remus, his hands tucked in the front pocket of his hoodie. Remus regretted ever opening his mouth. He should've let it go. Left it to Sirius to correct the boys or keep his secret meanings to himself.
Remus looked away and gestured for Sirius to continue.
"No one has ever dissected my lyrics that closely before. Not even the music journalists we have to do press with. It was a bit terrifying if not wildly impressive."
That was something Remus could believe. The band's image didn't invite you to dig any further. He was sure that there was a tumblr blog or two out there who'd figured it out but had been shut down by the whole 'sometimes the curtains are just blue' crowd.
"Look... I'm sorry I brought it up. I should've realized it was personal." Remus rubbed his sweaty palms on his joggers.
Sirius shrugged in response, "I knew the risks when we recorded our first song for public consumption."
That released some of the tension Remus had been holding in his chest. Sirius wasn't angry at him.
Wow, it'd be great if the world could've just swallowed him up right about then. "God, I promised myself I wasn't going to bring that up. Please ignore me." He tried hiding in his hands but Sirius's small laugh pulled him out of his cover.
"No, no! Please tell me how a song that spent three weeks in the top 100 could've been better." Sirius sounded mirthful, with a small grin pulling at his light pink lips.
"Well, uh," Remus rubbed the back of his neck before pulling his cell phone from his pocket, "My thesis was on how instrumentation interacts with lyrics to evoke different emotions. Fiddle is commonly used for a sense of folk tale-esque fantasy but could also fit with your descriptions of summer festivals. I have," he gestured to his phone, "if you wanted to hear."
Sirius looked at him with an unreadable expression on his face before breaking out into a grin and pulling up a stool to sit next to Remus while nodding enthusiastically. This close Remus could smell the tobacco and whiskey notes of Sirius's cologne.
He connected his phone to the studio's bluetooth speakers and pulled up the remix he'd made of Bronze. "Are you sure?"
"Just play it, Remus," Sirius responded.
Remus hit play, and for three and a half minutes he sat inches away from Sirius Black, seeping himself in the fog of false memories that he'd always pictured when this song played. His own fiddle playing was layered between the punchy bassline and the call and response of Sirius and James's guitars. In his opinion it helped round out the sound, filling the emptiness he'd felt in the original version. If anything it both helped disguise the hollowness that had made Remus read the lyrics on their own in the first place and reinforced the illusory meaning he'd found on his reanalysis.
As the last notes faded away Sirius jumped up and ran to the door. Remus was briefly confused before he heard Sirius calling for James and Peter, "-'ve gotta listen to this lads."
Sirius made his way back to the stool he'd pulled up, this time with the boys in tow. He gestured at Remus's phone, "Play it again."