August 23 1919, Odessa--Although Denikin had, in his “Moscow Directive,” attempted to limit his forces’ advance to the East of the Dnepr, they were still drawn across it anyway. On August 23, the White forces, supported by what remained of the Black Sea Fleet, landed and took Odessa (which had been in Red hands less than five months and had already alienated its population to the point of revolt). Around the same time, the whites took Kiev as well. These came despite orders from the Politburo to Trotsky to hold them “to the last drop of blood” as “the fate of the entire revolution is in question.” Ultimately, Red forces west of the Dnepr, now penned between the Whites and the threat of a Romanian advance (now that Hungary was out of the way), did their best to extricate themselves from the Ukraine. The operations spread the White front considerably further west than anticipated, but White forces in the Ukraine still numbered no more than 10-15,000 men. The bulk of Denikin’s forces were further east, closer to the Volga, attempting to fight off a Red counteroffensive which had already gained around 100 miles, though on narrow fronts.