Only Lucy smells remotely good in the entire Fairy Tail franchise.
Let's break it down:
Gray and Natsu: stinks as a competition
Erza: Wears deodorant, but has a constant armour musk
Wendy: preteen/mid puberty armpits YUCK sometimes she remembers to use a deodorant, but she lathers it on top of her sweat which is a lethal combo
Happy, Carla, Lily, all other exceeds: first of all; CATS. Outdoor cats to be exact. Carla smells the best out of the bunch but yk she skips a bath if she can.
Levy: smelled good, realised she only hangs out with guys, decided that if they can stink, so can she !! And also now that she's with Gajeel she lets herself skip a shower as per his wishes (he loves her smell)
Gajeel: was a stink, is only clean during pregnancy and newborn babies, will go back to yuck-town whenever he gets the chance
Juvia: only smells good when Gray's in town
Mira: demon musk. I will not elaborate, other than that it's faint when she's human, strong asf when she's in demon mode
Freed: same there
Laxus: basically like Gajeel and Natsu, but at least he washes his hands
Evergreen: STINKS of the worst headache inducing perfume
Elfman: sweat bomb. Mix it with Ever's perfume and it's a deadly combo
Bixlow, Max, Warren, Vijeteer: guy musk. Still smell like puberty sometimes, bleh. Bixlow thinks aftershave replaces a shower.
Macao, Wakaba, Makarov: Cigars and 5 weeks of unwashed laundry
Laki: smells of wood, which is nice! But she also smells like a sex dungeon. She's a virgin, no one knows why.
Kinana: doesn't sweat (snake) but she also thinks you only have to shower if you get visibly muddy or dirty or sweaty, so she doesn't shower a lot either. Basically she smells like day 5 hair scalp
Jellal: Prince of No Showers. He's dirty with sins and owns no deodorant. Bathes in lakes, wonders why he still seems dirty.
