A DEFINITIVE LIST AND NO I WILL NOT BE TAKING ANY CRITICISM
WEST END OR OFF BROADWAY: HEATHERS
okok
Beautiful: Off Broadway. ILY Carrie but Barrett takes the cake
Candy Store: Off Broadway but only because it's the OG (not SUPER set on this one)
Fight For Me: OFF BROADWAY that dAAAAaaAAAAmn was not on parr, sorry Carrie
Freeze Your Brain: WEST. END. I AM SORRY ANY SONG THAT RYAN MCCARTAN SINGS IN IM GIVING TO WEST END BC I HATE HIS VOICE IM NOT SORRY JAIME MUSCATO FOR THE WIN
Dead Girl Walking: West End. Now this is hard bc I love Barrett and mMMMmm her voice but also RYAN MCCARTAN IS GIVING NOTHING and Carrie and Jaime had so much emotion if you get me
The Me Inside Of Me: Off Broadway. That Barrett laugh, the Air Supply joke, IM BIGGER THAN JOHN LENNON! Ugh so much better in the original
Blue VS Your Welcome: Come on now. BLUE. It's so offensive but that's why it works. ~like princess leiA~
Our Love Is God: WEST END, SCREW YOU RYAN. (sorry but its true jaime muscato's vOIICECEEEEE AHHHHH) gET UFFFF THE FENCE GET UFF THE DAMN FENCE AHHH I LOVE HIM
My Dead Gay Son: No judgement
Seventeen: Ok so hear me out. West End. THE HARMONIES. THE CHEMISTRY. THE JAIME MUSCATO UGH I LOVE THEM
Shine A Light: A soft Off Broadway. I haven't really listened to the West End but MS FLEMING'S SLIDE NOTES ON POINT POP OFF
Lifeboat: Again no judgement
Shine a Light (Reprise): Come on now the Off Broadway just 🤌
Kindergarten Boyfriend: MMMM I haven't even listened to the West End version I just don't like either Martha stop having Sad Girl Hours (pls dont get offended by that i get its a serious topic but its fiction guys)
Yo Girl: Off Broadway until Ryan says kNoCk kNoCk bECAUSE HE IS SO MONOTONE GIVE IT SOME LIFE RYAN COME ON NOW
Meant to Be Yours: Brb currently OPENING THE DOOR FOR WEST END JD
Dead Girl Walking (Reprise): WEST END COME ON NOW COME ON
I WISH YOUR MOM HAD BEEN A LITTLE STRONGER (DON'T TALK ABOUT MY MOM) I WISH SHE'D STAYED AROUND A LITTLE LONGERRRRR (STOP)
I Am Damaged: West End. This is not only because of my Ryan Mccartan hatred, I love the lyric change too. (I am damaged, but you're different. you're the one we outta spaaaaare UGH HIS VOICE)
Seventeen (Reprise): Off Broadway. Barrett bringing it home.
BONUS: I love LOVE LOVEEEEEE I Say No. 10/10 addition, in my like top 4 at least of songs, I'm actually performing it for a thing at school!
Whereas Never Shut Up Again? Hate it. I can rave about the symbolism of Heather Duke not singing a solo song for DAYS I don't like this addition or the style it's in
btw guys i love both shows SO MUCH and both Veronicas and...
one JD iM sorry i really hate ryan mccartan's singing :(
BUT DAN DOMENECH ON THE OTHER HAND-