Give me your most unpopular fandom opinion!
This is so tough because I have so, so many.
I can’t wait for the yelling that’s about to ensue BUT -
There is NO CONCEIVABLE WAY that in canon (and really if we are going there, in almost any AU), that reg and James would end up together. James would never keep any secret from Sirius. Like. If you think James is gonna date his best friend’s brother and keep it from him, you don’t understand James. And if you think IN A WIZARDING WORLD ESPECIALLY that James would date a death eater, you really don’t understand James. James potter was a bigger blood traitor than every Weasley combined. He would never date a death eater and he would never ever not tell HIS BEST FRIEND any part of his life. I’m not sorry about this at all













