And the most concerning detail of all; jeremiah's story is inconsistent.
(still a part of details that caught my eye: the haybale murder ✨️THEORY EDITION✨️ >:))
I know this was just an improvised play and maybe luke simply misremembered this detail himself, so let's have fun theorizing and lemme elaborate on why this detail is potentially very concerning (even if this may seem far-fetched)
Imagine if jeremiah got caught by the police and was interrogated. In an investigation like this, they might also wanna question people close to him including agatha, his ex. Since luke/jeremiah never elaborates on what happened to agatha after the breakup, it opens up a possible universe where the police couldn't get in touch with her nor locate her so they asked jeremiah about her
Now had he been consistent with the claim that he left agatha, there'd be little reason to doubt his words. But because he later contradicts himself (and again, luke never elaborates on what happened to agatha), this would definitely raise more questions for the police as it could suggest that he was lying or at least trying to hide something. He also becomes unreliable and this opens up two of the many possible scenarios that might've actually happened:
1. Agatha found out about him being bloodthirsty and actually left him with/without confronting jeremiah. Cut him off completely and left no trace,
OR
2. Agatha found out but was killed by jeremiah before she could tell anyone
And we'll never know the truth whether she's still breathing or 6 feet under (unless luke will explain in the future)
But that's just a theory, A PLAAAY THEORY
(This was first thought by @yukitdffrge by asking me 'do you think he killed agatha' but it only clicked on me WAAAY later😭 and i know we were just talking abt wbtwg, but this was already in my drafts so lemme post this real quick–)
