I just came up with another HypoReboot idea:
Semblances are like Crests from 3H or Quirks from MHA.
Certain Semblances make certain results with children. Like, let’s say, hypothetically, that Pyrrha and Nora have a kid (Let’s assume some magic or science bullshit, or that one of them is intersex or trans, who cares, this is a hypothetical scenario). Then as a combination of Pyrrha’s magnetism and Nora’s electricity absorption, their kid would have powers kinda like Static. Said kid can use electricity to move metal objects around and do all sorts of things like that.
Why would this be an improvement? Because then we could infer what kind of semblances the parents have by what semblance the kid has. And maybe having a semblance that isn’t tied to the parents is rare. We could have a eugenicist villain. Endeavor. I’m basically saying that we could have Endeavor in this series.
This could also add as to why Pyrrha would want to keep her semblance a secret. She doesn’t want people wanting to date her for her semblance. Because, really, her not wanting to reveal her secret because it gives her an advantage seems a little… weird to me. She hates the fame that her victories have gotten her, but she keeps the biggest reason that she has those wins a secret?- If she had revealed it, then everyone would be downplaying her wins, and she would be able to ditch those sponsorships.
Pumpkin Pete’s: The cereal that has the girl who secretly used her semblance to make her opponents miss their attacks on the box. They’d ditch her and distance themselves from her pretty fast if it turned out that she was giving herself an unfair advantage that her opponents and the ref didn’t know about.
But if it was because she didn‘t want people after her for her semblance, then that would change everything. Suddenly, she has an even bigger reason to hate her celebrity status. All the fame and press coverage?- How does she know who wants her for her, and not for her semblance? It would certainly make her thirsting after Jaune feel less forced. He doesn‘t know what her semblance is, and he hasn’t unlocked his by that point, so there’s no way that he could be scheming to make an Ultimate Baby by combining semblances.
And then you’d have all the parents who would be pushing for certain relationships to happen so that their bloodline could be associated with a powerful semblance or manipulating their kids because they’re the reason said kid has the semblance they do. It would certainly add to jacques’ scum factor since we all know that he’d jump at this. Hell! Jacques could be our Endeavor equivalent for this whole thing. Maybe his semblance is the reason the Schnees do have the ability to summon in the first place, or maybe it’s his semblance that lets them manipulate dust so effectively. It would add to his scum factor because then he could be all “How dare you! Don’t you realize that I’m the reason you even have those abilities in the first place?”
There are so many ways this could be worked. It would make it so that characters who keep their semblance a secret have a bigger reason outside of “I want to keep it as a surprise against an opponent.” Because once it’s used against a major opponent, then everyone knows what it is, and can then formulate a means to counter it.
Plus, this kinda plays with the whole “Heroes aren’t born, they’re raised” idea. The people who have a certain semblance are going to raise their kid a certain way, and possibly pass on their personality. This would make the idea that a semblance reflects the personality make sense. It’s nurture, not nature.
That last one is kinda just there to justify why Raven and Yang’s semblances would be vastly different, not gonna lie…