Trevor Slattery's Fate is How Antonia Should've Been Treated
Upon watching Wonder Man (Probably the best MCU show by a good bit too, really recommend), I have come to a kind of bitter realization.
Trevor Slattery, the one who was known as the fake Mandarine, is literal proof that even OCs and characters who may not be comic accurate, let alone are part of the comics at all, not only could be very well written but also beloved by the fandom. And this goes back to how Antonia Dreykov (Taskmaster) got treated.
For context, Iron Man 3 was hyped up by the portrayal of the Mandarin played by Ben Kingsly into this cunning and ruthless warlord who is now targeting America and Tony Stark. People were hyped up and anticipated watching this unique portrayal of the Mandarin on the big screen much like how many people were anticipating Taskmaster being on the big screen in the Black Widow movie.
Only that wasn’t the case at all. Iron Man 3 essentially made the twist that this Mandarin is nothing what people have anticipated or expected. He was not this ruthless but also wise warlord villain that Tony had to overcome, he was just an actor named Trevor Slattery who was just playing a role for the main villain of the movie Aldrich Killian and later became a joke character. To simplify it, Trevor, much like Antonia, was NOTHING like the comic Mandarin at all. When that happened, much like Antonia, people initially hated the mere existence of Trevor Slattery due how much of an insult he made to the whole Mandarin interpretation in Iron Man 3. In fact, people back then would have rather he would never get mentioned again in the MCU. I hope you see where I’m going with this.
If Trevor’s character was was written and directed by people like Jake Schrier or heavily monitored by higher ups like Kevin Feige, Trevor’s character would’ve likely been killed off and perhaps turned into a gag before being completely forgotten by the movie entirely just like Antonia and people would likely have cheered even if it was unnecessarily cruel, because the value of writing has become secondary.
Instead, we got essentially an OC who is one of the best MCU characters of all time, because the writers and directors of Wonder Man decided to actually give his character an actual second chance to be more in depth than just the “twist” funny character. They gave Trevor depth and explored his backstory, his values, and his entire arc. Trevor is not comic accurate but he is objectively a well written character.
The point I want to make with this post is that Trevor’s treatment in Wonder Man literally utterly disproves the argument that Antonia never had a chance and was “doomed from the start” or was “a horrible character” SIMPLY because she was given the name Taskmaster and wasn’t like the comics. Antonia could’ve and should’ve been given a second chance to actually write and explore her character. And she could’ve been very well written despite the fact that she’s not comic accurate or even straight up an OC.
It also further shows the state that worries me in terms of franchises; quality writing, consistency, and characters are secondary to even tertiary at best, and sometimes unimportant at worst. If the character is just not liked enough, even if it’s for an objectively arbitrary reason like a mere title and not their actual quality, said character is likely to be removed by either ceasing to exist or get killed off unceremoniously without rhyme or reason just to please whoever is loudest at the time.
Wonder Man wasn’t given anywhere near the same attention or promotions as Thunderbolts, many people wrote the show off as something that will not even have a follow up and that Marvel gave up on it due to releasing all the episodes in one day. And in a way, it seemed like a blessing in disguise because the directors were able to write their story and characters without TOO much pressure from audience and company expectations and became successful as a result.
I only hope that Antonia’s fate gets rectified one way or another, that she’s actually given a chance to be a character, regardless of whether she’s called Taskmaster or not.
Anyway sorry if this comes off as disorganized as it’s just me writing what’s the first thing on my mind rn. Thank you for reading! :D