If I had to pick one single thing to convince you, definitively, that Rian Johnson is a flat-out bad writer, I would pick this:
When asked about why Luke throws the saber, he said “because I can’t imagine any other honest reaction from him to that moment.”
like fuckign what
If that’s the only thing you can imagine at all, you need to get your fucking imagination checked
And for two, I know of little children who are confused by that scene. They are confused why the Luke they know is acting like this. They can’t understand. Cause it doesn’t make any fucking sense. If that doesn’t speak essays on why Rian is a terrible writer and fundamentally misunderstands Luke, I don’t know what does.











