I've just had an incredibly obvious epiphany!
I've seen a few theories that suggest that Aria killed Charlotte and that that is what's in her file. BUT Mrs D was the one that made the file and she died at the end of season four. Therefore, whatever it is that she did, and would make Ezra choose Nicole over her if he knew, had to have happened before this point! My brain is on fire! What did she do?!?! Was she in Radley? Was she A? Did she know who Ezra was before meeting him? Did she somehow get Nicole kidnapped 😂? WHAT DID SHE DO????? (I realise you probably all realised this already but I just got there today 😂)












