Okay so I have been hunting for a review about Ghostbusters: Afterlife that actually talks about Lucky. But I have yet to see a single one. I am going to attempt to do this subject justice but if anyone else has a piece to add on feel free to do so! This will contain spoilers relating to lucky.
So the first I’d like to point out how they did such a good job introducing Phoebe and Podcast. They had iconic moments that made them likable characters who felt right at home in the movie. The way the story flows between scenes with Trevor and Phoebe felt so lovingly crafted.
Now I say this because it felt like a stark contrast. Lucky is introduced as a romantic interest, and part of her character is that she’s “Mysterious” which felt incredibly lazy and insulting to her as a black woman. They threw in a tidbit about her family having been in the town four generations and it confused me because it doesn’t seem to have any relevance to the plot? (Correct me if I’m wrong)
Then comes the jail scene. It felt pretty gross to see her portrayed as a delinquent even as a joke. It felt like the fact that her father was a cop was thrown into this scene to make that joke seem less insulting. At this point in the movie I gave up on having any hope that they weren’t going to tokenize her.
When they broke into the police station, she stole a cop car and I know that this is a life or death situation but it rubbed me the wrong way.
The final fight scene comes up and Lucky got to kick ass for all of 5 seconds before she is literally turned into a monster. I was so shocked an appalled that this happened, and it happened in such a sloppy way that I was confused until the end of the fight scene if it was in fact her who was turned into the monster.
So to recap: lucky is introduced as a love interest and exotified by the mysterious character arc they gave her. Lucky is then made the focal point of racialized jokes, and then dehumanized and her role as a character never received any kind of characterization. Even her turning back into a human is this sort of tacked on extra.
They did lucky as a character and her actress Celeste O’Connor, such a huge disservice and black women as a whole deserve so much better than this.