Hihi! Hope this isnt too out of topic but,
Could I ask what your opinion is on the prohibition of men imitating women? For me, it has always been a prohibition for men to imitate women for deceitful intentions. It confuses me why mainstream scholars and most mainstream islamic websites treat masculinity as if it were set in stone, while historically, it has always been a slippery slope at best.
Whoops got too long! Hope you're having a good day 💗
As-salamu alaykum, definitely not off topic at all! I agree with your interpretation - I think it's more about deceit in general, or even about men speaking over women/speaking for women. I obviously do not think it is about trans, intersex, genderqueer/nonbinary, gender non confirming, fluid, etc people (I know a lot of those fall under the same umbrella, but I wanted to cover all my bases).
Another thing worth noting, is trans people aren't even "imitating" one gender - trans men are just men, they're not women imitating men. Trans women are just women, they're not men imitating women. Even for the people (trans or cis or otherwise) who do 'imitate' gender, i.e. in drag or cosplay or in acting and performing arts, that's not being deceitful!
Closeted trans people (so men who really do have to pretend to be women, women who really do have to be men, nonbinary people who have to be one or the other, etc) aren't even being deceitful, even though they are "lying" about their gender in a sense. If it's being done for your own safety/comfort, as closeting tends to be, I don't think "deceit" is at all an accurate word to use for situations like that.








