I’ve mostly stayed out of the discussion/discourse (re: Berena, Holby City - as a show and re: cast members) for various reasons, and I hope that I’m able to convey that with some degree of coherence. These points are not listed in any specific order or degree of importance.
From a personal standpoint, since that is really all that I can rely on - same as anybody else - lived experiences colour our interactions, and one’s views of a particular storyline are no less valid than somebody else’s. Our places within various communities (geographical, familial, emotional, shared belief systems, shared interests) shape us, whether we choose them, or they choose us.
I’m a 45 year old single introverted lesbian with ADD tendencies. I’m a night shift geriatric long-term care nurse by choice. A photographer, love to travel. Most of my interactions with LGBTQ+ community are online as I don’t have a community here that I interact with much aside from Pride parade festivities once a year. I did more in my 20s but not as much in the past 10 or more years.
And I do like shows with lesbian and bi-women representation, BUT more than half of the time that is not the only draw to a tv show/film. There are a LOT of shows/films that have had a decent/semi-decent LGBT storyline (from reviews/social media commentary/clips), but the storylines themselves, the characters, actors, have not drawn me in, or it’s poorly written/performed that I can’t be bothered (I’m picky). There is no rule that all lesbians/bi-women have to be interested in the same stuff.
Keeping in mind, that I have not seen the past five episodes of HC (due to work/family/life in general - and HC is not the only show I’m terribly behind on), I have read through much commentary via social media (Twitter & Tumblr) - to a certain degree of the various Berena fandom that I follow, which is by no means extensive. Within the past two to three weeks, I have also avoided searching through/scrolling through Berena or Holby City specific tags for my own sanity. I will say this: I do think that Holby City and BBC should take into account many of the experiences and hurt (of the cheating/break-up sl) that the lesbian an bi-women communities as a whole have made them aware of. Will it make a difference in the long run, I don’t know, but I can hope. I recall the backlash after Delia’s cycling accident in S4 of Call the Midwife and the killing of Kate McKenzie in Last Tango in Halifax. So, I do hope they can learn from this Berena storyline how much it has hurt many in the community.
Aside from personal lack of time for viewing shows at a regular time-line, there is another element that has kept me from the past few weeks of HC viewing, and its not specific to what’s on-screen - but rather off-screen within the HC/Berena fandom. As I said above, each person’s view points are valid because it comes from our own experiences. As a fandom, we cross different ages/generations, sexual orientations, genders, different countries, different backgrounds - it makes us unique. And, as we know and have seen, it also results in disagreements at times. I’m not taking any sides here. However, the downside of these disagreements/arguments has temporarily soured my interest in Holby City as a whole. Right now there are a lot of hurt feelings going around for a myriad of resasons that I’m not going to wade into. Suffice to say, this distancing myself from the overall negativity is something I can afford to do at the moment. That’s not to say fighting for improved representation, especially for lesbians and bi-women 40+ & 50+, is not an important thing it do, it very much is. I can send notes to BBC/HC, but for my own sanity/piece of mind, at the moment, I need to back off HC on a temporary basis.
Which is a shame, because even as I came to Holby City back in early 2016 (and subsequently went back to watch everything from Serena’s entrance onwards (S14), full episodes, not just character storyline clips) with interest in the developing Berena friendship to love storyline, there was so much to the whole of the show that kept me engaged, that made me care about most of the characters over the past six series. It’s unfortunate because there are some good storylines going on at present - Sacha’s depression, Hanssen’s depression, Jac’s recovery post-Gaskill, Mo mentoring Nicky, and others. I will get back to Holby at some point and marathon the lot I’ve missed (Heck, I did manage to marathon 195 eps btw summer/autumn of 2016, still not sure how I did it except for sleep deprivation).