DUDE i was watching the society of the blind eye and what if the memory machine had a tube and ford at some point decided to show stan those forty years of his life that are still a little uncertain in his mind? what if stanford had to watch all of stan's memories with him? seeing the hunger, fear, and most importantly the crushing loneliness that stan had to endure before the kids? god this scenario is killing me
I personally headcanon that when they were taking Stan back to the Shack (when it looked like the memory loss was permanent) Dipper remembered McGucket and suggested showing Stan the tube.
Ford explained that if Stan’s memories had been stored there, Bill would be too and he’d be able to be freed again, so Ford set the gun to delete the memories permanently. There was no memory cylinder this time.
That’s how I rationalize it, anyway. I like the scenario you brought up though. Nice and evil.











