can I request a poly!jegulily smut? I kind of wanted to do something where Lily and Reader teams up on Regulus cause idk, maybe he’s been stressed out? And James is there too obviously. Idk if you still write for jegulily, but I love the way you do and I hope school doesn’t kick you in the ass <3
Luckily school has not kicked my ass too hard this semester ❤️ hope you enjoy!
summary: Regulus has been being too mean to James, so you and Lily decide that enough is enough
CW: SMUT, mdni, mean!dom Regulus, oral sex (m receiving), strap on, pegging, creampie ,raw sex, edging, idk this is all just smut, not proofread- its 3:30 am ill do it later
The last time you saw Regulus like this… well now that you think about it, you don’t think you ever had seen Regulus like this. You tried to rack your brain, but nothing was coming up. Maybe you only thought this looked familiar because you’ve seen James in this position one or a million times. In fact, you saw James in this same predicament quite often just in the past week, which is exactly why you are all in this situation now.
Over a week ago, Regulus decided to roll out a punishment for James. Regulus craved control at all times, so when one of you decided to test that control, he then would figure out the best way to remind you of it. The latest reminder was because James unintentionally came inside you without asking first.
Now this small slight would probably go unnoticed by anyone other than Regulus, but he was diligent about his control.
Since that night, James hasn’t been allowed to cum at all. Regulus said that he needed to remember to ask, and that this punishment was to teach him the value of getting cum.
At first, it was kind of hot. You loved watching Regulus taunt and tease James all week, every night finding a new way to get James desperate and whiney. It wasn’t difficult, Regulus often worked James up just enough to get him hard, then left him with nothing while he got to watch you, Regulus and Lily have all the fun.
Of course you and Lily joined in as well, Lily worked James up until he was leaking and begging, only for her to stop as she felt him twitch in her palm, just before he could reach his peak. You would work him up as well, whispering sweet nothings and dirty thoughts into his ear all throughout the day, kisses that turned from small pecks to hot and heavy makeout sessions, sitting in his lap while the four of you watched tv and ‘adjusted’ yourself to get comfortable.
Needless to say, James was falling apart. He was sporting a constant half-chub no matter what time of day. He’d become more cuddly as well, clinging to one of you at all times, but this was just to feel some semblance of closeness, his only way to feel your bodies.
This clinginess and cuddling came to a stop once Regulus caught on to what exactly he was doing. With 7 whole days of the punishment under his belt, James’s body seemingly was done with the torment, no matter how hard he was to endure.
You awoke to an angry Regulus releasing you from his arms, shifting the bed, and pulling James from the bed and to the floor. Apparently James was grinding into Lily in his sleep, the evidence clear from the wet patch soaking the front of his pyjama pants.
You could have found this humorous, cute even, but Regulus was furious and James looked so guilty. Lily tried to insist that it was fine, that he could let it slide this once, that he wasn't doing it on purpose- he wasn’t even awake! But Regulus wasn't having any of it. He said that if he was going to act like a dog and hump uncontrollably, then he could sleep on the floor like one.
You and Lily both argued that this was too much, that Regulus was taking it too far. But Regulus said that he broke the rule of not cumming without asking not only once, but twice now. That this was the only way he would learn. You begged and begged and pleaded with Regulus, who caved a little and allowed him to sleep at the end of the bed like a good boy, easing your guilt only slightly.
You two didn’t want to push it any further, not wanting his wrath to turn on you, so you and Lily decided to drop it for the moment, but not without giving each other a look signaling you would talk about it later.
And talk about it you did. Once you and Lily were alone, you talked about how unfair Regulus was being and how bad you felt for James. You two decided that something needed to be done, that Regulus’s power trip needed to come to an end, that maybe he needed a taste of his own medicine.
You distracted Regulus by sucking him off, his eyes closed and head thrown back, sitting on the edge of the bed and leaning back on his hands. Lily expertly cuffed them together without him noticing.
And now, you and Lily had Regulus, a complete mess. Sweat-soaked and out of breath, squirming on top of the bed.
“What is this,” Regulus asked, more like demanded.
You and Lily were taking turns using your mouths on him. Sucking his tip, licking along the veins, and for show, making out over with him in both your mouths. You two would stop or switch when you knew he was getting close, his groans filling the bedroom and his hips attempting to buck his cock further down your throat.
“We’re just having a little fun,” Lily replied, her voice seductive and heavy. You only giggled in reply.
You continued your ministrations, sucking Regulus’s cock as deep as you could, using your hand on what you couldn’t take into your mouth. Lily muffled his sultry moans with her own mouth, swallowing every noise you were managing to pull from him and meeting each with her own.
You sputtered and gagged, drool dribbling down your chin, but you couldn’t stop now, you had a mission to complete.
As Regulus’s moans were becoming breathier, Lily pulled you from his cock, crashing her mouth onto yours. You both ignored Regulus’s groans and complaints, swapping the taste of both his mouth and his cock on your tongues.
You two continued making out over Regulus, Lily pulling you closer by your hips. You moaned into her kiss, your hands wrapping around her and finding purchase in her fiery locks. The moment was so passionate, her chest against yours, skin on skin, lips on soft lips.
Lily pulled away from you and turned her attention to the man of the hour; James. Your attention followed in step, looking to where James was sheepishly watching, the only one of you still clothed. You could see the outline of his overly hard and underused cock through his pants.
“Come here baby,” you called out to him. He looked genuinely surprised that you even acknowledged him in the moment. He scrambled over to you and Lily.
Lily pulled him closer to the edge of the bed. She gripped the bottom hem of his shirt and pulled it up and over his head. His pupils blown wide and looking at you both in awe, he was skeptical about the attention he was receiving.
“I didn’t say he could join,” Regulus growled from where he was abandoned on the bed.
“We didn’t ask you.” Lily snapped back.
Regulus laid in shock, his control dwindling away moment by moment and he knew it.
Your attention left Regulus and landed back on James, pulling him to you and kissing him. He could cum just from your lips on his, it had been so long. Your lips moved in sync as Lily worked on stripping James all the way.
You could hear Regulus huffing and puffing behind you, but you didn’t exactly care, you wanted to reward James for putting up with Regulus’s cruel punishment.
James was definitely receiving death glares from Regulus from behind you, thinking you couldn’t see, but you knew Regulus too well. He hated when you disobeyed him, blatantly ignoring him, but what was he gonna do about it now?
You moved from James’s lips, kissing his cheek, along his jaw, down his neck, anywhere you could reach really. You landed on one of his collarbones, sucking and biting a bruise into the flesh. James’s moans were already loud and breathy.
Lily finally got James bare, his dick already leaking, the tip an angry red, looking like it could use some attention.
“You wanna cum baby boy?” Lily asked him. James nodded furiously, desperately.
“Don’t you dare.” Regulus chirped from behind you, making his presence known yet again. Couldn’t he take the hint? He wasn’t the one in control here, he wasn’t calling the shots. Not now, not after the hell he had put James, your sweet boy, through. You and Lily smirked, rolled your eyes, and continued on ignoring him.
“Don’t listen to him,” you tried reassuring James. “We wanna treat you right, that means you can cum whenever you want, yeah?”
James was almost shaking with arousal, still holding eye contact with Regulus, afraid of the consequences.
“Oh, baby,” Lily said, turning James’s attention to her, making him face her entirely. “What’s he gonna do, huh? We took care of him for you, you don’t have to worry.”
“You can relax baby,” you added, connecting your lips to his neck again, leaving soft kisses below his jaw. “Let us take care of you now.”
With this James broke. He nodded and allowed Lily to take his cock into her hand, letting out a shivering moan. She stroked him once, twice, precum leaking out and spilling over her hand.
Lily gave you a look, motioning for you to take over for her. She slid her hand from him and you replaced it with your own. You could feel him throbbing and twitching in your palm already. You ran your thumb over his slit, collecting the leaking pre and used it as lubricant as you stroked him up and down. James couldn’t control himself, thrusting into your hand and meeting your strokes. His moans were reverberating off the walls, his head thrown back, he was in pure ecstasy right now.
Regulus was groaning, squirming, testing the hold of the cuffs that wouldn’t budge. You threw him a look over your shoulder, making sure to give him a little look of innocence as the noises you pulled from James were anything but.
You saw what Lily was up to from the corner of your eye and smirked, neither of the boys seemed to have caught on.
“You wanna be inside me baby?” You asked. James, quite literally almost combusted, had to bite into his lip, using the pain as a distraction to stop himself from cumming.
He gave you a shy nod and you made a move instantly. You climbed off the bed turning around and shoving your ass into his pelvis. You were more than ready for him, your slick all but dripping on the floor. It had been too long since you had him inside you, you needed to feel him just as much as he needed to feel you.
You gripped the base of his cock, running it along your wet folds, both your arousal smearing together, mixing so perfectly, just like how it’s meant to be. He slipped in so easily, bottoming out in one thrust of his hips. He whimpered, holding your hips still, holding you close and savoring the feeling.
From this position, you had the perfect view of Regulus struggling to keep his composure. It was taking everything in him to keep from begging to be released, to be touched, to finally cum.
You were so close to him, you could reach out and stroke him if you so pleased, but you thought that Regulus deserved a little more torture. You kept direct eye contact with Regulus and you pushed back onto James.
James’s self control snapped, savoring the moment be damned. He rutted into you at a furious pace, hitting your sweet spot over and over. Your moans mixed with his, the symphony no doubt driving Regulus crazy.
James’s grip on your hips tightened as you bounced your ass back onto him, meeting his thrusts.
You were all but lost in the moment before you heard a deep and demanding “No” from above you. Regulus was seething, meaning that your mission was in its next phase. James’s gasp was all the confirmation you needed.
Lily stood behind James, strap on harness secure around her hips, silicon dick in place. She pressed the head of the fake cock to James’s hole. James stilled as he realized what was happening.
Lily pulled James back into her, holding him to her chest.
“This ok baby boy?” Lily asked softly, leaving a soft kiss on his shoulder.
“Y-yes, yes. Yes please.” James blabbed, lost in pleasure.
Lily hummed and pushed the lubricated head of the pink cock ever so slowly into James. James fell forward, holding himself up on his elbows above you. Lily pushed in inch by inch until James took the entirety and her hips met his ass. Lilly gripped one of his hips as leverage, her other hand running softly around his back in soothing motions.
He was still unmoving, but you didn’t mind, tonight wasn’t about you, it was about him, and you wanted him to feel the best he ever had in his life, so you’d allow him to move on his own accord.
Lily waited for James to adjust before moving. His whines and broken moans encouraging her to continue.
She started with slow, experimental thrusts, James gripping the sheets on either side of you and moaning from his soul. You looked up and caught a glimpse of Regulus, his mouth parted and eyes clouding with a mixture of lust and tears, needing desperately to get a feel of anything. Most likely wishing he was at least one of you in this trio, maybe sandwiched between.
Lily began to pick up her pace, her hips rocking into James faster and harder, meaning that his hips were now rocking into yours in turn.
James thought he was going to pass out, Lily was grazing his g-spot as he was grazing yours, your velvet walls squeezing him like a vice. James’s throaty moans became heady, he wasn’t going to last and you and Lily both knew it. After the week he’s had, you were surprised he’s lasted this long.
Regulus’s chest was heaving, a thin layer of sweat covering his body, his red-hot, leaking tip leaking and collecting on the bed between his thighs.
He deserved this, he really did, but just as you felt bad with James, you felt bad now. You didn’t like seeing your lovers needy and desperate for touch when you could so easily provide it.
You craned your neck, turning to kiss James, capturing his mouth and catching his moans.
“What do you say, baby,” you asked, grabbing his face and making him look to where you were; at a pathetic and needy Regulus in front of you, forced to watch and left with nothing. “Should we make him pay? Or should we show him mercy?”
James’s cock was throbbing inside you, he had to gather himself before he could answer that.
Even with the week of hellish torture that Regulus inflicted upon him, you knew what James’s answer would be. Your soft, sweet boy could never be mean, no matter how deserved it was.
James shook his head, gathering himself enough to moan out a “M-mercy.”
You heard Lily chuckle from behind him.
Regulus looked genuinely shocked at his answer, not expecting to be forgiven so easily by James after what he put him through. But now wasn’t the time for hesitation or second guessing, not as you gripped his dick, squeezing gently, precum cascading down the length. He was practically on the edge already, he just needed a push. That push came in the form of your lips wrapping around his tip and sucking lightly.
The guttural groan that fell from his lips was the missing piece that James needed to hear to let himself go. James’s pleasured cries prefaced him filling you to the brim, the exact act that landed him the punishment to begin with.
As James painted your walls, Regulus released down your throat. You were being filled, your senses overloaded with your lover’s pleasure. You moaned around Regulus, swallowing around him and making sure you got every last drop from him. Once Regulus fell back onto the bed, hands still cuffed behind him, you popped off of him.
James’s release was still flowing, filling you to the brim and dripping out. He had been so pent up, his cum building up for over a week, now coating your insides.
James and Regulus were panting messes. Lily slowly pulled out from James, kissing the spot between his shoulder blades before he collapsed on top of you.
You yelped and giggled, gently rolling him off you and helping him up the bed where Regulus was. Lily went to find the key for the handcuffs to finally release Regulus from his confines. You would normally be a little bit scored for what he might do in retaliation, but the blissed out look on his face put you at ease. Both James and Regulus were breathing deep, trying to regulate their breath to a normal rate. You brushed some hair from James’s face and kissed his sweat covered temple.
You did the same for Regulus as Lily rolled him over to unlock the cuffs. You smirked to yourself, an action that didn’t go unnoticed by Regulus, even in his tired and clarified state.
“What’s that look for?” he questioned you.
You chuckled before answering him.
“Well, you couldn’t endure one night of what James endured for over a week,” you stated, laying it on thick to praise James and slight Regulus at the same time. “He’s so strong, He must have more self control than even you Reggie.”
You teased him and he huffed.
Lily chuckled along with you, but you decided to stop while you were ahead, you just got James out of a gruelling punishment, you didn’t want one yourself.