Casper crew + Finney x Tomboyish Nonbinary reader
For each character whose age differs from the other your age will change depending on the character, such as Griffin, Robin, or Vance
Also thanks for requesting it was fun writing this
You knew who you wanted to be but there wasn’t really a label for you out there so decided to just not have one
Most couldn’t dissociate you from a boy or a girl and even if you dressed boyish, they couldn’t tell
You even gave vague answers to throw them off your trail
“Are you a boy or a girl?”
”What’s in your between your legs?”
“Thighs” finger guns away
“Sponge bob underwear” finger guns away
“Do you have a penis or a vagina!?”
“Neither” finger guns away
After a whole 3 months of pestering and people asking question that were to the point you actually had to get in a fight with a guy because he thought you were a pretty boy who couldn’t fight and you kindly told him, "I'm not a boy fuck face." (You made him eat shit for that)
People then just started to not care anymore which they put your gender aside and started to look at your talents
Also, your attractiveness
It just spoke to you that no human emotions or people could ever say
Your violin was your baby and took classes when you were a child and it just stuck
Even though you can play other instruments like the piano and guitar
You met Finney when you were invited to a baseball game with a friend
Unfortunately your other friends weren’t there so it was just you and your friend, your friend group was small since some people you were just uncomfortable with
Most people must stared at you but didn’t really move to talk to you or anything just stared which kinda creeped you out
But unknowingly to you it was actually you were dubbed as “Untouchable” due to you beating up that one guy and threatening people who hurt your friends
Finney was the best and when he won the game you just had to tell him something
“Finney that was amazing! You did amazingly Finney!”
“O-oh thank you. I’m glad you’re here cheering me on”
Finney was so fucking nervous
You were so attractive and so very making Finney’s heart beat like he ran a marathon and you high fived him, you even complimented him, the most attractive person in the school
You asked for him to sign a baseball because
“I just want an original one so when your famous I can flaunt it to other fans”
You damn near killed our boy Finney
He gave you his baseball cap as a gift and now you wear it in school and he takes so much pride in being close to you
It even makes him a bit popular
You met Robin while going to the movies and he recognized you as Pretty Face from school
Robin sits next to you and try to get a conversation rolling first talking about the movies and then related movies and then interests
You happily spill about your interests since you don’t get that opportunity everyday but once you realize your ranting you try to apologize but then Robin is just sitting there listening intently smiling softly for a moment before he realizes you stopped talking and asked if you were okay
You were glad that you weren’t annoying him and asked him about his interests which he happily ranted about
This atmosphere that you had around you made his heart light and made him not even pay attention to the movie and once it was done you asked if he wanted to hang out
“I really had fun talking to you dude, can we hang out? Maybe bowling or skating?”
“Yeah I had fun talking to you too, skating sounds nice”
“Great! I’ll see you later, same time on Friday at the skating rink!”
You ran to your sister’s car since she did drop you off and you were worried that if you took any longer get she would embarrass you in front of Robin
Robin was left standing there with your number in his hand and fluttering feeling in his chest
All he could do was smile as the car drove away
He was definitely calling you later and making up some bullshit excuse to talk about your favorite horror movie
You met Bruce when he was at the bike shop
He was given some money and was sent to get his own bike of his own so he was very indecisive about his choice
Your dad worked there and had been apart of the shop for years so almost everyone knew you as the kid who brought everyone coffee on weekends in the morning
You were going to visit your dad for his break and found Bruce looking between two bikes
One was a white one and a blue one, he was really torn between the two and was muttering to himself the pros and cons of both bikes
“I say the white one it looks nice and it even has a basket”
Bruce jumped out of his skin as he heard a voice right behind him
“Oh sorry for giving you a scare, my bad”
“Oh it’s fine, I get scared easily…”
“Really? I’m sorry, how can I make it up to you?”
Bruce asked for your number, as awkward as it was
You two hung out at an arcade and had fun in the shooting games and after grabbed a smoothie and hung out just sitting at the park
You met Vance at grab n go when he was playing his pinball machine and the guy who bumped into the machine masses him up and ruined his score
Thankfully you deescalated the situation making a deal with Vance that you would buy him something to eat
You got him whatever he wanted, and you got him some fast food
You two got talking and found out that you two shard a love for music, he had an electric guitar that was gifted to him by his mother and you just had to ask for him to play
He was unexpectedly good and liked to listen to his music and even played with him with your own guitar
You loved his hair it was just long and pretty and fluffy, and for what? who gave him that right to look so angelic?
You invited him to your house often and had sleepovers and let him brush your hair and in exchange he let you braid his hair, and it was fucking fantastic
You being the person you are took every opportunity to hug Vance since why not?
You and Vance now hang out annually at grab n go where you just watch Vance play pinball and eat snacks
You and Vance sometimes go to the park and play with the neighborhood stray cats and oddly enough Vance is a cat magnet
Vance literally has 4 cats that just run up to him when they go to the park
You only have one that recognizes you right away and she is your baby
Vance teases you about having the most cats which you just throw your water bottle at him, it's an empty plastic bottle that you forget to refill everyday but just have on hand
Vance was really good at hiding his adoration for you and tried to subtly give hints, but they were so obscure that you couldn't tell what he was trying to say
You met Billy while he was on his paper route because you were taking some cheesecake to your auntie
He came up behind you making you almost lose control of the bike
“Jesus- sorry I didn’t mean to scare you I just wanted to say hi, you okay?”
Y-yeah… I’m fine but what the hell.”
“My bad, how about I buy you a soda as an apology?”
“…Deal but you have to buy me soda for the next week!”
Billy sighed as he knew he was not getting out of this one
And so how your relationship started
Billy for the next week would buy you soda and would sit next to you in the morning once he was done with his paperboy work
He was always early to school almost an hour early and you came 15 minutes into his hour chatting away and him buying you your soda in the morning
You two would complain about teachers and Billy had tales and tales about his horrible PE teacher while you also had tales and tales of your guitar teacher who was just an ass but you still learned in that class surprisingly
Once it was raining and hadn’t brought your umbrella and you found Billy who was also standing under a hangover with no umbrella
“Ah (Name)! You stuck in the rain too?”
“Yup, I’m guessing you don’t have one either?”
“I wouldn’t be here if I did!”
“Oh wow. I feel so loved here.”
You said that in the most monotone voice you could muster but even still you had a little smile on your face
“Whatever- wait I got an idea”
“What? You gonna hold your jacket above us as we walk?”
“Basically but not technically”
“We’ll you got it right out his on!”
Billy hand you his jacket that was somewhat plastic fabric so the rain would roll off
You put on the jacket and Billy crouched down as if to give you a piggy back ride
You held the jacket out to cover you and Billy and he started to blitz down the sidewalk
“AAAAHHHHHHHHHHHHHH!?!?!?!?”
You both screamed until you guys got home
Griffin was a quiet child and you two met when he was getting bullied but you defended him and even though you got hurt you were able to send the bullies crying
“Am I okay!? Are you okay!?”
“T-then let me help you bandage it up!”
Griffin took your hand and took you to his front porch and he went inside to get a first aid kit
He disinfected the wounds and put Babbage’s on them
“How do you know how to do this?”
“Well-… I’m really clumsy and have to bandage myself up most the time so I learned quickly! Hahaha…”
You didn’t believe it really but you didn’t want to push Griffin so you let it go and offered him to go to your hideout
Griffin perked up when he heard hideout
“Hideout? As in secret base!?”
Griffin was absolutely enamored by the idea of a secret base and you had one? Awesome!
You took Griffin into the woods where there was an abandoned bridge that was over a small river
But the bridge was covered in rugs and half on it was covered in wood that looked to be drilled and roped together (the wood planks could only go so far up)
“How in the world did you build this?”
“I didn’t but my pops did when I was bit younger, he build it because I wanted to go camping but was too scared of the woods to actually camp so he built this near town”
“I know right? Come in we can play game boys!”
You had been Griffin’s hero and he adored you for it, you also defended him even if he didn’t need it
He always gave you a big hugs and insisted on holding hands to school
You and Griffin after school would go to the hideout to play games and hang out
During the summer you two would go down to the river to splash around and have fun in the cool water while in the summer heat
After once you had gotten somewhat dried you two would do to grab n go and get soda and even ice cream to enjoy your day even more
Griffin comes to your place more than you go to his place
In the winters you two hang by the heater and cuddle in blankets and you play the piano that’s your folks have for Griffin and he loves it
