Your thoughts on the way Liam, or let's better say Debbie, obv. wants to run Liam on this reunion.
So far we have:
- separated hotels (am sure this will continue)
- driven away right after every concert to get as much rest as possible
- same goes for: doubt that he's really early at any concert venue, more likely as late as possible but at this point that's just speculation
- no fan contact at all
- no contact to media, press etc
- obviously now extra twitter cut off to make sure he hopefully doesn't offend anyone and their dog (how long also speculation)
- while at the venue his every move monitored by Debbie to keep him safe, run his schedule, keep him on point
Pro's:
- they'll definitely will make it until the last date of tour and I think it will be an utterly successful one
- his voice and health will be preserved the best way possible
- no drugs, no alcohol
- no distraction at all
- no press to haunt him
- needed routine still in full swing (and as i think he at least has ADHS, maybe autism to an extend this is really essential to him)
- won't get tired and therefore will at least savour every concert minute
- well, and obv. no bird to cheat with (pro on Debbies part ^^)
Let's make it short: the cash cow will be in full function.
Contra:
- separation meanwhile to an extent that it's not possible anymore for him to bond or grow/maintain a bond with any human being besides her and his kids.
That includes even band members,crew, Noels kids other than say hello.
You've to keep in mind that it was a long time no see for example with Andy, Gem, on a band level with Noel. So the normal human demand would be to refresh it at least a little bit. And lets all remember Liam is an absolute team player and loves the 'together ' aspect of a band and doing all kind of funny shit with members.
- no going anywhere besides hotel with anyone other than Debbie (and let's hope at least his kids)
- no fan contact (he normally really loves this one) orher than on stage
- no possibility to recap any concert other than maybe via phone or whatever impression Debbie and his kids are telling him
- no fun around any concert for him other than when they're on stage
- no twitter atm. Am speaking not on a fans level, cause twitter was obv. sth he really loved to do and what gave him the attention level his character needs
- making him look like this star he always disdaines to be: no flairs/sparks, no wrong words, censored, boring, Gen Z suitable (oh please lets not have him cancelled/loose any PR contract over a bad word/we'll all loose cash if we don't keep him shut the f*** up .....as if he'd care)
I hate esp. that they have him censored now over this last "incident " on twitter. Liam was never not one to speak whatever comes to his mind without thinking twice. That comes with all the good or bad outcome possible but he always made it round everything by just keeping in contact, not backing away, showing his really enjoyable and versatile character, maybe say sorry/maybe not. And I do think he just needs and even learns in exchange with others. Anytime you cut that off, you cut him off to shine)
- being silenced
- control, control, control
- cash cow
Dont get me wrong: its pretty clear that he will do anything to make that shit work out the best way possible 'cause his goal was and will always be to impress Noel to the point where he will start to write songs for him again and to tell him they'll never split again. I'm sure he'd cut all his fingers to reach it and therefore any way that guarantees this outcome he'll go (entirely cute ) . And Debbie is very skilled and proofed she can make him run to reach his 'career' goals without many fallouts. And she'll definitely succeed with this aswell. And I do think he asked and likes her to do it this way cause he trusts and loves her. But how long will this be fun for him to do. If they continue to tour maybe furthermore does he really endure, does he really like, does he really find fulfillment in excluding himself from everything? The man that prefers band life over any solo shit?
Oh and also to make this clear: it's totally obvious to me that there's no animosity between him and Noel or Noels kids. They do get along well and given the impressions until now Noel really loves it. But this way there's no chance for the 2 to get used to each other and learn to taste each other's needs again like they used to do (brotherly basis or whatever you like them more to be ^^)
I really hope he will figure sth out that we don't see atm and maybe will see in a tour doku . But this development run by Debbie which started far earlier than him and his brothers reunion and is noticeable in his private and public life gives me very bad chills. It continues to grow into total separation, cause even with other family members: she's always around. And excess monitoring + continued separation always goes down as very unhealthy even when the receiving part kind of needs it to a certain degree.
Since Liam is and was always this open and free spirit that needs to spread his wings to shine it's at least to me kind of ...dunno...sad development? I really think Debbie has his best in mind in whatever she does but everyone that treats a beloved one in 1 way or another has always personal desires in doing so. And her takes kind of feel like she goes down the path of fear...maybe of losing him when not around everywhere, given his past relationships? Her job as his manager helps to mask imo.
Will be interesting to see how it continues.
Sorry for my long take. Your opinions?



















