Bless Me Father For I Have Sinned
aka stories where either Dean and Sam are Priest (or at least dressed up as priest)
Caught Between Heaven and Hell by TheQueen (FaustusianSutcliff) Dean Winchester never thought of himself as special. He never liked his ability to see a demon's true face. And instead joined the church as a deacon. Boy king of hell, Sam, takes an interest in the deacon and as a result, heaven has to get involved.
Confessions by sammichgirl Sam likes Dean dressed as a priest. Dean likes Sam’s confessions.
Faith, Love, and Sin by deansdirtybb The fire that killed Mary Winchester changed their lives forever. Unable to handle raising his young sons, John tells Dean that Sammy died and gives the baby to family. Dean is raised by Pastor John and enters the priesthood. When Sam acts out so badly he runs out of family he is left to the care of Father Winchester and Pastor Jim at their reform school. There’s an undeniable spark between Sam and Dean…and then they discover they are brothers.
Forbidden Love by annie46 Jensen Ackles is a successful businessman. Nothing or nobody can stand in his way. His life is thrown off balance when he meets trainee Priest Father Jared Padalecki and he realises that nothing in this life goes quite as planned. (WARNING- Chapter 10 contains an attempted suicide)
Forgive Me Father by kiraynn What if Dean was the one who was going to turn evil? Learning of the probability, John sent Sam away six years ago to Pastor Jim in order to protect him. But Dean wants his brother back.
For you, I'll do anything by Tina_J2 Sam and Dean grow up on the street, which leads their lives to two very different directions.Prompts was: Can I ask for Mob Boss!Dean/Priest!Sam (still brothers)~ Maybe adding some sex toys like dildo.
Have You Seen Him Whom My Soul by veronamay Matthew 26:41—"Watch and pray, that ye enter not into temptation: the spirit indeed is willing, but the flesh is weak." (J&J fic)
Heaven's Full And Hell Won't Have Me by whiskeydays Knight of Hell Dean is on a killing spree throughout the Midwest when he makes a pit stop in a town that turns out to be much more interesting than Dean would have thought. Who is the mysterious Father Winchester and why does he seem to be immune to Dean's powers?
Pray for Me, My Priest WevyrDove Father Sam is desperate for a solution to the church's financial woes; the church and adjoining monastery have been his home since he was orphaned as a child, and he would do anything to save it from being closed. His fervent prayers are answered when help comes from an unexpected source, but Sam soon learns that it comes at much too high a cost.
Preacher Man by alphvjensen “Forgive me, father for I have sinned. My last confession was…” he trailed off, chuckling a little. “Well, probably never… but I’ve been having impure thoughts about a boy…a man really. Only know his name and where he works but that doesn’t stop the thoughts. I bet he makes the prettiest of sounds when I’ve got my mouth wrapped around his cock. Does that make me evil…corrupt…tainted? Don’t wanna ruin my chances of walking through those pearly gates upstairs if you know what I mean, preacher man.” Sam could hear the smirk in his voice.It took him a moment to find his voice, longer than what it should have and he mentally cursed himself for allowing this man to have this power over him. He shouldn’t listen to him, let those words sink into his brain, settle in other parts of his body.“Well…” He had to clear his throat before continuing. “Thoughts do not make a man corrupt. You haven’t acted on these thoughts yet, have you?” “Not yet, preacher man.”
Sacrament by riyku In Seminary, Sam cultivated a love of knowledge and of God, in exactly that order. He was taught that vampires were real, that silver could take down a werewolf, and that belief could be a living, breathing thing. In Seminary, Dean learned how to fight. Most of all, Dean learned to have faith in his brother. They were both introduced to the true meaning of war. Now the war is finished and the church has disbanded their sect of elite warriors, leaving them to fend in an unfamiliar civilian society. They are ragtag refugees of a war everyone tries to forget. For Sam and Dean, however, the fight is far from over.
Sins of the Brother by WevyrDove Dean and Sam are raised as Catholics. When their mother is taken from them by cancer, Dean loses his faith, while Sam finds comfort in it. As Dean struggles through his high school years, his relationship with his father deteriorates, and he leaves home soon after graduation. The next time he comes back to town, Sam is graduating from high school. Dean is shocked to see how much his brother has grown in the few years they have been apart, and finds himself thinking of Sam in inappropriate ways. He tries to push those feelings aside so he can take Sam on the road trip he planned as a graduation gift. But despite Dean’s best efforts, the two brothers end up in each other’s arms for one blissful night of pleasure. In the morning, Sam is gone, and Dean is heartbroken. Years later, they meet again; Sam has become the priest at their old family church, and Dean is determined to resolve the differences between them. Once more, Sam finds himself teetering on the edge of sin, and he must decide whether his own happiness or God’s calling is more important.
Take Me There [Where the Kingdom Comes] by non_tiembo_mala Sam and Dean wind up crammed into a confessional while wearing their priestly getups, and Dean isn't one to let an opportunity pass him by.
A Thing For Collars by phantisma Dean convinces Sam to pull out the priest costumes to investigate a haunting at a monastery hosting a retreat, but when disaster strikes, Sam ends up believing he really is a priest…and Dean has to find a way to help him remember.
The Vow by annie46 17 year old Jared is bound for the church, it is his destiny. He has to take vows of chastity, obedience and silence. Young and alone he goes through the motions of living, wanting only to escape the life he has been forced into.
21 year old Brother Jensen, has been a monk for most of his life. He was taken into the monastery as a child and he owes the Brother’s his life. How can these two, very different, men survive, when they begin to become more than friends and the vows they have made become less important than each other….
gif courtesy of homosmoosh
