idk the whole thing with eloise is irritating because her frustrations are very real but she's in an environment and a show that ultimately affirms the patriarchy so moving forward, she will necessarily have to compromise with her beliefs in some way -- either as the character or with abysmal writing -- in order to have her pre-determined "happy ending".
the show writing her as someone selfish to make up for her very right criticisms of gender roles and course-correct away from the feminist path she's put herself on is irritating. they're going to write her to "grow into" being a choice feminist - one who declares "let women be women <3" ... bc that is what regency era women needed lmfao. "Let women like girly things!!!!! <222222222 and that's feminism!" this bullshit's fucking pissing me off. i cannot BELIEVE they had the fucking audacity to position her against hyacinth and create this nothingburger conflict. to position themselves as affirming the misogynistic status quo? un fucking believable. just downright ridiculous. hyacinth - lovely girl - doing the meg march "just because my dreams are different than yours doesn't mean they're unimportant." YES THEY ARE! oh my goddddd i hate choice feminism im losing all coherence bc that's how much i fucking HATE choice feminism and "let women be women". and to do it for the 1800's definition of womanhood? ur fuckign crazy . whoever wrote and approved that needs to [redacted] on some "not all of us want independence! some of want to fall in love and be property <3" bullshit. FUCK OFF!!!!!!!!!!
can you imagine being eloise for a second? everyone in your social circle -- from your family to your best friend to the ladies of the ton -- all gladly stick to a specific, restrictive, suffocating social script and not only that, but judge you for wanting something different! meanwhile, your asshole good for nothing brother colin gets to gallivant around the world, exploring new cultures and experiencing things you'll never have the freedom to (without a husband or brother), and your (soon to be former) anti-marriage partner in crime free spirit brother benedict gets to come and go and do whatever and literally whoever he pleases with no regards for consequences? like the life and freedom you want is constantly being rubbed in your face, all the while your mother is forcing her (albeit well-meaning) idea of a happy life down your throat with no regard for your wants and no recognition of the fact that maybe there are other happily ever afters! and then here comes your teeny bopper of a little sister, rushing head-on into the fire. realizing, and enjoying!, her impending demise & objectification. bc she doesn't see it for what it really is: objectification. and then she gets mad at you for not caring about ballerinas.
i do feel for hyacinth - she wants to be treated like an adult, and her definition of adult is Woman (tm). and she wants to connect with her sister. and i can't even blame violet too much - her reality is that you either marry well, marry below your station and lead an uncomfortable life, or be a spinster and be ridiculed by society for the rest of your life. so of course she keeps pushing eloise to marry for love, especially given her own wonderful experience with it.
i think that eloise's future, marrying philip crane, is an affront to her beliefs. Not the love between them but the necessary submission and transfer of property that is marriage in the 1800s. And there's really no way to reconcile Eloise's principles with the regency reality in a show sponsored by Big Marriage. if this was set in modern day i have no doubts that eloise would be a cristina yang of the bridgerton family. it's the time period in which it's set, and the tone of the show, that inhibit eloise's narrative. If this were any other show, there would be space to explore a spinster/pre-suffragette path for Eloise, but Bridgerton nipped that shit right in the bud in s2. i don't remember much about the previous seasons (except kathony... and i didn't even watch s1) but i do believe that was the purpose of the paperboy arc. eloise, as her character is, would definitely explore the world and become more class conscious and gender critical, but they obviously cannot give her an endgame romance outside of her class (see: the other ramble about benophie) so they had LW humiliate her and basically cut her off from that portion of the world (sidenote: what are eloise's thoughts on benophie given what she had to endure...).
idk. everything is just a mess. i get the appeal of including an eloise character but they kinda backed themselves into a corner with her.
importantly, i do not believe love is antithetical to feminism. this is the Correct Take and the one that I think/hope the bridgerton writers will pursue (as long as whoever wrote s4 is in the writer's room). there's nothing wrong with eloise falling in love with philip. i hope their relationship is woke as fuck though. I guess they fall in love through letter writing? so at least El won't have to perform femininity as much one has to during balls and social events. i hope this foray into writing sparks something in her and she starts writing feminist literature lmao. idk when exactly bridgerton is set... i think it's too early for married women's property act but maybe, fantasy as bridgerton is, eloise can play a role in shaping that. incredibly farfetched, but it would be nice to see her use that Bridgerton influence & relationship with the Queen for good. there's a lot for her to work with if she decides to be an activist on the downlow. i'm excited for her season bc i see a lot of myself in eloise and i don't think the writers are going to completely assassinate her character. i think there will definitely be a lot i take issue with but i do think there will be good as well (as long as s4 writers are iN THE ROOM!)
idkkkkkkkk. i hope this made sense bc it's straight from my mouth to tumblr's ears and im aggravated by this, so a lot is probably nonsensical sry. hopefully they serve franchaela goodness before el's season so i can go back and rewatch the lesbians when i get too frustrated.
















