Alternative Star Trek: mistakes and a timeline change taken for Stranger Things
As we discuss time being set up for s5, I feel like coming back to startrekgate is quite reasonable.
If you are not familiar with Star Trek or you haven’t read my analysis on similarities between it and Stranger Things, check out firstly this post. And here’s the tag of the gate for more 🖖
Check the gate in general, but for tldr I’ll point out that before we mainly spoke about parallels with the universe of The Original Series of Star Trek (TOS) (and a bit about the next crew’s show, TNG ).
And now let me introduce you to Star Trek AOS: Alternative Original Series.
here are pictures for attracting your attention heh
Basically what it is: 3 movies, aired from 2009 to 2016, that rebooted the original universe with the old characters which allowed its authors to create a new story about them not butchering canon.
(So new audience didn’t even need to know the source at all, but old audience could get all the references and see how it was re-created).
You know how they did that? How they reasoned their reboot? By creating an alternative timeline.
How did they reasoned the timeline?
They depicted an enemy who went back in time and changed an event in the past that created the whole new reality.
This description 👆surprisingly valid for both: Star Trek Alternative universe AND Stranger Things s5.
Like I said, AOS consists of 3 movies. 3 to be exact
The first one establishes relationship between two main characters, Spock and Kirk (spirk), (their original story is here), which, due to the new timeline, is different from the ones we know from the original series.
How different you might ask?
That much that spirk basically haven’t even met by the beginning of the movie, but when they do, they firstly hate each other which never was the case for the original timeline (TOS), to Stranger Things it’s relevant due to Mike and Will’s lost closeness (that led us to the upsetting resolution).
Star Trek Into Darkness 2013
The second movie has now spirk’s closeness and recreates the 2nd movie from The Original universe — again, I mentioned how it was handled in TOS in this analysis, AOS’s version is kinda the same, what important for Stranger Things s5 is:
1) the plot which is still about the villain with super-blood, believing that he’s better than others acting “as a genocidal dictator and terrorist”.
2) Khan is also on one of the movie’s covers. I’d say you’ll never guess why it’s big but you saw it in this post above:
Another way of connection between these two is El having “superior” blood like Henry + her “I’m a monster” plot being played out.
3) as for promised mistakes of the 2nd movie:
Spock and Uhura is a couple. Uhura is third wheeling in Spock and Kirk relationship, even given that Kirk hits on her in this timeline initially too. Spock getting involved in a relationship with her is out of nowhere and this never happened in The Original Series (Kirk hitting on her is also not canon but at least in canon they had a kiss).
So I obviously don’t know if it can even hint now whether Eleven was not supposed to be in a “true” timeline of Stranger Things (and whether she will be with Mike at all in the edited timeline), but as for “mistakes” that The Duffer Brothers could take into their “bad finale parallel”, — m11 in the end gives all the out-of-nowhere-ships (after not being relevant for the past season), which parallels to Spock/Uhura as well. (Who, I swear, is better as a non-romantic connection.)
The final part of AOS and the bad one. Honestly, I personally don’t even rewatch it, even though it has not bad parts, it’s not that bad in general, but it still kinda is… And you know why?
Sounds like a finale of the show we know?
That’s is a taken mistake #2.
The mistake #3: separating Kirk and Spock.
The iconic duo, who in the 2nd movie (both, in the original one and in the alternate one) has just got the most intimate moment between them, in the next movie has almost no common scenes.
Which (guess what) upset the fans and didn’t help the movie with its disservice.
ST1: villain reboots a timeline, bc of that the main ship loses their closeness
ST2: revolves around a superior-human villain depicted on the poster referenced by a superior-human El + has a not needed straight couple involving the guy from the main ship
ST3: an example of a weak generic action movie (an example of the bad “finale”) that side-lined their main ship after they behaved “too gay”
I had a little bonus for you that turned into a separate post about Tales from 85 being another parallel from Star Trek!