They should be calling me the weatherman for how accurate my predictions are. This week’s forecast partly cloudy with 100% chance of that thing I fucking said would happen!
— Mikey, when he was proven right about something but his brothers didn't believe him
The Pale King is probably my favorite character and its so nice seeing someone write him with, to be blunt, *character*. You write him as the complicated person he is and fuck! Fuck! God I was gushing to my girlfriend over the fic at like, 12am. It was just very very good and I would be over the moon to read more
Thank you so much!!!! The Pale King is such a fun character, and you've activated my rambling trap card by mentioning that. Maybe I'm just not in the right corners of the fandom, but I don't see many people losing their minds over the implications of what we see of the White Palace in-game and what it says about him. I'll go insane about him and that area in more depth below, but I'll say this theory outright:
By the time the Pale King was dying alone in his throne room, "No cost too great" had taken on a very, very different meaning than when we first see him say it in the Birthplace scene.
I've written the Pale King in many different ways over the years— he's been everything from an irredeemable villain who cares for no one but himself and his wife to a goody-two-shoes who did everything he did for the sake of his beloved subjects at different points in my work— but in every interpretation, he's a fascinating character to write.
I allude to it a couple times in that Father-Daughter Bonding Session fic, but I love writing him as being deeply unsettled by the fact the Hollow Knight is the corpse of his unhatched child. He's haunted by the knowledge of what lies inside the Abyss, and even though he kept his eyes forward and didn't dare glance down the ledge where he waited for a vessel to finish the climb during the Birthplace cutscene, he knows exactly how many eggs were consumed by the Void, because he was the one to cradle every last one before casting them inside. He'd like to be able to forget it all, but he can't when he's overseeing the development of a prison built from the contents of one of those forsaken eggs.
The Hollow Knight is a corpse that he has to look at every day and remember he was the one who killed it. But even though he sees that thing's cadaverous stare in his nightmares, over time, he finds himself caring for it just as much as the child he killed to create it. Sealing the Vessel was a taxing event, but he was able to at least rationalize away his sorrow over it. His dismay at a tool successfully fulfilling its intended use was completely unfounded.
And then the Infection returns, and he learns that the Hollow Knight was NOT a mindless corpse that he had misplaced fatherly emotions about. You can only imagine the severity of crash out that followed.
Now, for the best part: the White Palace area in-game is probably the best characterization we have for PK in the entire game. We see him being a phenomenal political leader and a bizarre Higher Being as a result of that (wyrms supposedly lived to pull bugs into their thrall and replace their targets' wills with that of their own, yet a good number of Hallownest's neighboring groups hate PK's guts in a way that causes him a lot of trouble, which implies he doesn't use enthrallment to solve problems— he also doesn't seem to make use of the foresight / prescience wyrms possessed, which has Implications, to say the least), but oh my word. The White Palace. THE WHITE PALACE, YOU GUYS.
The Pale King uprooting the White Palace and hiding away in a Kingsmold's dream always felt so bizarre to me. What was his endgame? It made no sense. Was he just hoping to run away from his guilt at Hallownest failing and the contents of the Abyss? If so, why include the nursery in this curated memory of the White Palace? Why preserve the memory of that little moment alone with the Hollow Knight? If he wanted to hide from his failures, why did he showcase them so prominently in his hiding place?
But those actions start to make more sense when you notice that the Kingsmold you use to enter the White Palace looks like its been hooked up to various black tubes coming from the ground, the Abyss is directly beneath this area, the White Palace is accessible in-game through the Dream Realm, and the dream nail dialogue for the Pale King's corpse might not be saying there was "no cost too great" in reference to saving Hallownest, actually.
(What I'm implying is that the Pale King realized that the Hollow Knight wasn't hollow after the Infection returned, panicked, and tried to poison the Dream Realm with an IV drip of Void to try and fix the "there's an angry sun goddess in my kid's head" and "my kid is probably not in very good health, most likely due to Angry Sun Goddess in Your Head Syndrome" problems in one go— but he died before he was able to fully implement that and the other steps of his new plan. I think he even knew that his death was an inevitability past a certain point— but there was nothing he wouldn't sacrifice to try and help the Hollow Knight, up to and including his own life. He and Grand Mother Silk are narrative parallels and foils of each other in many fun ways to me :> )
Fogstalker soothed her disappointment over the failed mediation with Luna by craning her neck back to count the snowflakes that began to fall one by one and trying to catch a few on her tongue. The wind barely stirred them as they drifted from the chalky grey clouds overhead and it was easy to hop forward or stall for a step to snag one out of the air.
This occupied her for a while, but as they approached the barn on their way back, the chilly air seemed to thicken somehow. She felt like someone was behind her, watching intently, somehow sinister. She dropped her gaze from the clouds and looked around, suppressing a shudder.
“Do you feel that?” she asked.
“Hm?” Floodstrike seemed to only have just remembered she was there. “Feel what?”
Floodstrike took a moment to tilt his ears around, to breathe and observe the area before responding. “It’s probably those cats up there,” he said, nodding in the direction of the empty lot beside the twoleg den. Fogstalker looked and sure enough, there were a group of cats huddled in the lightly dusted snow, watching them approach. There were probably six or seven all together, some of them with notched ears.
“Oh, maybe,” she said, but the answer didn’t feel right. She could have sworn the thing was behind her.
“Let’s just keep walking,” he said, shivering in the cold. “They’re probably just hanging out there.”
As they drew closer, the cats shifted uneasily, talking amongst themselves, although the sound was swallowed by the falling snow. After a moment, three of them got up and began moving to cut her and Floodstrike off. Floodstrike’s body tensed beside her, but she hopped a half step forward to try and meet them before he did.
It wasn’t until they were close that she noticed something was off about them.
They had varying pelt patterns -- a ginger tabby, a dingy-white-furred cat, and a dusty brown one -- but they all had a dark stain of grime from their chins to their chests, as if they had dipped their necks in filth. As far as she could tell, it was just dirt, maybe ‘oil’ like Ghost had told her about, but the sight of it made her feel dizzy and sick to her stomach for some reason.
“Whatcha doin’?” asked the ginger tom, cocking his head to the side. He had a notched ear and a scar over his left eye that gave him a perpetual squint. “Goin’ out to wild territory in the middle of a snow storm?”
“Yep,” said Fogstalker, trying to push through her discomfort and do her job. “Just heading back home. What about you?” She meant it in a friendly way but the gaggle of toms seemed to take it as some kind of threat.
“They’re wild cats,” said the white one as if he’d caught them in a lie. The stain on his chest was the boldest of the three and Fogstalker tried to resist the grimace she wanted to make when she saw that it went all the way up to his gums, like he had opened his mouth in whatever substance he’d used to make it.
“This one’s definitely the traitor’s little bastard,” said the dusty one, tail lashing.
Fogstalker squinted in confusion. The traitor? Did they mean Ghost? Who had he betrayed? It took her way too long to realize they must have meant Sardine.
Luckily, Floodstrike was much quicker on the uptake. Before she had even finished processing, he was stepping in front of her with his tail arched in warning and saying, “We don’t want any trouble. Just leave us alone, alright?”
“What if we want trouble?” sneered the white one. “You think of that, smart guy?” Floodstrike rolled his eyes a little, lip curling in unimpressed contempt.
“I’m a mediator,” Fogstalker said, frightened despite herself. “We were here for, uh,” she tried to remember the word Scorch had taught her, “diplomatic purposes. We have a truce with the Speaker, you can’t attack us.”
“The Speaker is dead,” declared the white cat, “long may he reign.”
“Long may he reign,” the other two repeated in chorus. This was clearly something they’d said before and the way they said it sent shivers up her spine. They weren’t talking about Rudy, were they? No, she didn’t think so, and the implication there deeply unsettled her.
Floodstrike let out an uneasy growl. “Don’t do something you’ll regret,” he warned, unsheathing his claws and puffing up his thin fur. The snow was coming down thicker now, big and fat and wet. It settled over their backs and added to the chill growing in Fogstalker’s bones. It created a bubble of sound, their voices stopping a few tail lengths away, no other sounds reaching them through the storm. It made her feel suddenly and intensely isolated.
“I- I can’t fight!” Fogstalker hissed under her breath to Floodstrike. She was a mediator! She wasn’t supposed to lift a claw, even if she’d been trained to do so.
The rogues looked at each other as if making a decision. The white one took a step forward and-
The second he moved, Floodstrike struck out and jabbed him right in the throat with the butt of his paw. The tom coughed violently and stumbled back and the others bristled furiously in shock. Floodstrike took advantage of the momentary pause and lunged for the next nearest cat, slashing out at the ginger tom’s eyes. He managed to draw blood on his brow and it dribbled into the tom’s eyes as he pulled back, blinking, a noise of disgust escaping his throat.
Floodstrike wasted no time in turning on the dusty one, snapping with his teeth at the tom’s throat. The rogue scrambled back with a frightened yelp and Floodstrike pursued him a step with a series of quick strikes from his paws. It became clear to Fogstalker that he was focused on keeping them back, away from her.
The white one snarled, having caught his breath, and swept in with an overhead swipe. Floodstrike caught it out of the corner of his eye and spun around so that the swipe barely nicked his leg, then turned that momentum on his attacker and went for another jab to the throat. The white tom was prepared this time and fell back a half step, then lunged again, but Floodstrike didn’t fall back with the typical dance of a battle. He kept moving forward, head ducked, and the other tom crashed into him, being hit once again in the throat by the crown of Floodstrike’s head.
He choked and lost his footing, tumbling into the snow, and Floodstrike bore down on him with teeth and claws bared. He tore the cat’s ear in his teeth, raked his claws over the front of his neck and chest. The tom screamed and writhed beneath him, making shapes in the thick, wet snow.
“Get off him!” the dusty tom cried in distress and reared up to bat at Floodstrike’s head and Floodstrike fell back, taking up a defensive stance just in front of Fogstalker.
“I warned you,” he snapped, spitting out blood into the snow. “Back off.”
“Fucking, savages!” the cat’s ears were pressed against his head and his tail bristling. “Just get out of here! Shit!” The white one was rolling to his feet, shaking blood from his dingy white pelt onto the stark white snow.
The ginger tom growled in frustration and threw in, “Yeah, go back where you belong, degenerate scum.”
Fogstalker was frozen for a moment as her brain caught up with what had happened. But Floodstrike interrupted with a, “Come on, let’s go,” which pulled her out of her stupor.
“Yeah, okay.” She slank along beside him as they skirted the others and quickly trekked out into the snow. It wasn’t long before the rogues disappeared into the haze of the falling snow.
“That was close,” Floodstrike grumbled.
“I’m sorry I couldn’t help,” she said glumly.
“It’s fine,” he flicked an ear to dismiss the apology. “You’re a mediator. I get it.”
“You were amazing, though,” she brightened a bit. “That was so cool!”
He chuckled bashfully and flicked his tail against her side. “Thanks. I did feel pretty cool.”
“I love the throat punch!” she went on, bouncing in her steps now. “Just ‘cha!’ and bam!” She punched out a paw of her own and laughed, her steps wobbling so that she careened into him before bouncing back to her own path. He laughed and shook his head and that creeping sense of dread she had felt started to melt away.
Still, she thought, that felt significant - their black stained throats. It made her queasy for some reason. Definitely something to talk to Goldenstar about…