Yesterday, I posted this video & the comments about Carlisle really have me surprised. Someone mentioned that — as a possible theory — Carlisle does have a vampire gift actually. That he attracts powerful vampires to him. Now, I’ve never thought about it like that & I may be behind everyone already talking about this but that’s very interesting to say the least.
Because why does Carlisle have quite a few gifted vampires in his coven? There vampires in Carlisle’s coven literally makes Aro sweat — And aren’t gifted vampires supposed to be rare? Not to mention, he did form the freaking vampire avengers in Breaking Dawn. So I think I can get behind this theory (except for the fact that Eleazar would’ve been able to detect a gift from Carlisle, right?)
Someone just commented a silly thought after that “@Brett Micheal’s: POV Carlisle doesn’t care about them, he just wanted to build a stronger army than the voulturi” & now I’m genuinely pondering that idea because that’s even more interesting. Completely out of canon character (Since Carlisle is supposed to surpass literally everyone’s compassion & values every single person on the planet) but very, very interesting. 😏